Abstract

Taking stock of the diminishing material conditions faced by contemporary writers broadly conceived, this article (re)frames writing as a site and a practice of exploited labor. Arguing that writing scholars have often avoided interrogating writing’s links to labor, particularly with respect to declining working conditions and the appropriation of value from workers, I draw attention to the pervasive crisis of writing’s devaluation under late capitalism. To evidence this assessment, I apply political economist Harry Braverman’s conception of the “progressive alienation of the process of production”—the notion that labor is increasingly eroded through capitalism’s advancement—to the scene of contemporary gig writing, specifically Amazon’s microtask platform Mechanical Turk (MTurk). MTurk, I maintain, offers a paradigmatic illustration of contemporary writers’ material exploitation, both for its efforts to de-skill writers and for its conscription of writers to advance their own exploitation by employing them to train generative AI.

Journal
College Composition and Communication
Published
2025-12-01
DOI
10.58680/ccc2025772243
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (92) · 5 in this index

  1. A Worker site improvement to help increase Worker productivity
    Happenings at MTurk, Medium
  2. Amazon Mechanical Turk in 2025!
    YouTube
  3. The Jobless Future
  4. These Books Are Being Used to Train AI. No One Told the Authors
    CNN
  5. Sports Illustrated Found Publishing AI Generated Stories, Photos and Authors
    PBS News
Show all 92 →
  1. The Life and Death of Hollywood
    Harper’s Magazine
  2. When A.I.’s Output Is a Threat to A.I. Itself
    New York Times
  3. Gamification Is Bullshit: My Position Statement at the Wharton Gamification
    Ian Bogost
  4. College Composition and Communication
  5. Composition as Management Science: Toward a University Without a WPA
    JAC
  6. Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century
  7. The Hidden Inequalities in Labor-Based Contract Grading
  8. Writing Democracy: The Political Turn in and Beyond the Trump Era
  9. Digital Worker Lives: Worker Autonomy and the Gig Economy
  10. Mechanical Turk Workers Are Using AI to Automate Being Human
    TechCrunch
  11. Writing as Social Action
  12. Writing Across Difference: Theory and Intervention
  13. This Time Last Year, Hollywood Writers Were on Strike. Now, Many Can’t Find Work
    NPR
  14. How Gamification Affects Crowdsourcing: The Case of Amazon MTurk
    Eludamos: Journal for Computer Game Culture  
  15. AI and Writing
  16. AI’s Impact Will Extend Far Beyond the Classroom
    Chronicle of Higher Education
  17. As the Technology Becomes Ubiquitous, a Vast Tasker Underclass Is Emerging—and Not Going …
    New York Magazine
  18. Digital Rhetoric: Theory, Method, Practice
  19. Contemporary Perspectives on Cognition and Writing
  20. Braverman, Monopoly Capital, and AI: The Collective Worker and the Reunification of Labor
    Monthly Review  
  21. Storying Writing Center Labor for Anti-Capitalist Futures
  22. Rhetorical Feminism and This Thing Called Hope
  23. Paying the Price: College Costs, Financial Aid, and the Betrayal of the American Dream
  24. Gig Workers Are Writing Essays for AI to Learn From
    Business Insider
  25. Revolutions in Reverse: Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, and Imagination
  26. Post-Process But Not Post-Writing: Large Language Models and a Future for Composition Pedagogy
    Composition Studies
  27. Circulation, Writing, and Rhetoric
  28. The Ghost of the Mechanical Turk
    Jacobin
  29. ChatGPT Is Reshaping Crowd Work
    WIRED
  30. Horribly Low Pay Is Pushing Out My Fellow Authors – and Yes, That Really Does Matter
    The Guardian
  31. Materiality and Writing Studies: Aligning Labor, Scholarship, and Teaching
  32. Attentive Turkers: MTurk Participants Perform Better on Online Attention Checks Than Do S…
    Behavioral Research Methods  
  33. AI Needs to Face Up to Its Invisible-Worker Problem
    MIT Technology Review
  34. MOOCs Are Dead. Long Live Online Higher Education
    The Chronicle of Higher Education
  35. Research in the Crowdsourcing Age, a Case Study
    Pew Research Center
  36. Rewriting Composition: Terms of Exchange
  37. Economies of Composition: Reevaluations in Rhetoric and Composition
  38. How Much Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTURK) Pays per Hour in 2024!
    YouTube
  39. I Did Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) for 1 Hour! Should You Do It in 2025?!
    YouTube
  40. I Spent 1 Hour Doing Amazon Mechanical Turk
    YouTube
  41. Antiracist Writing Center Ecologies: Teaching and Assessing Writing for a Socially Just Future
  42. Crossing Divides: Exploring Translingual Writing Pedagogies and Programs
  43. Assessment Is the Engine of Learning’: An Interview with Asao Inoue
    Writing on the Edge
  44. Thinking through Writing: A Guide to Becoming a Better Writer and Thinker
  45. What Do We Mean by Academic Labor (in Rhetorical Studies)?
    Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  46. History of Marginal Utility
  47. Turk Wars: How AI Threatens the Workers Who Fuel It
    Stanford Social Innovation Review
  48. AI May Ruin the University as We Know It
    The Chronicle of Higher Education
  49. Introduction from Guest Editors
    Academic Labor: Research and Artistry
  50. Writer Alarmed When Company Fires His 60-Person Team, Replaces Them All with AI
    Futurism
  51. Are You Ready for the AI University?
    The Chronicle of Higher Education
  52. What Students Are Saying About Using A.I. for Schoolwork
    New York Times
  53. Beyond the ‘Improvement Imperative’: Writing to Change Oneself and the World in First Yea…
    Composition Studies
  54. Low-Skill Workers Aren’t a Problem to Be Fixed
    The Atlantic
  55. The Faculty Squeeze
    The Chronicle of Higher Education
  56. Writer Earnings Fell $600 Million Due to Strike and Industry Contraction, WGA Says
    Variety
  57. Capital, A Critique of Political Economy: Volume I
  58. Capital, A Critique of Political Economy: Volume III
  59. The Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844
  60. Theory as Critique: Essays on Capital
  61. Mute Compulsion: A Marxist Theory of the Economic Power of Capital
  62. The Value of Everything: Making and Taking in the Global Economy
  63. Horror Stories From Inside Amazon’s MTurk
    Gizmodo
  64. What We Are Becoming: Developments in Undergraduate Writing Majors
  65. AI Was Enemy No. 1 during Hollywood Strikes. Now It’s in Oscar-Winning Films
    BBC
  66. For Karl Marx, Alienation Was Central to Understanding Capitalism
    Jacobin
  67. I Found Work on an Amazon Website. I Made 97 Cents an Hour
    New York Times
  68. What Is to Be Done about the Enclosures of the Academic Publishing Oligopoly?
    Community Development Journal  
  69. AI Is a Multi-Billion Dollar Industry. It’s Underpinned by an Invisible and Exploited Workforce
    The Conversation
  70. The Promise of the ‘Learn to Code’ Movement
    The Conversation
  71. College Composition and Communication
  72. Dangerous Writing: Understanding the Political Economy of Composition
  73. College English
  74. The Internet Is Enabling a New Kind of Poorly Paid Hell
    The Atlantic
  75. Culture Wars: School and Society in the Conservative Restoration
  76. Assessing Writing
  77. Tracing the Human in Amazon MTurk through Rhetorical Text Mining
    enculturation: Intermezzo
  78. College Composition and Communication
  79. Smart University: Student Surveillance in a Digital Age
  80. Composition in the Age of Austerity
  81. Fiverr Wants Gig Workers to Offload Some of Their Work to AI
    TechCrunch
  82. Freelancers Are Getting Ruined by AI
    Futurism
  83. The Exploited Labor Behind Artificial Intelligence
    Noema Magazine
  84. The People Paid to Train AI Are Outsourcing Their Work … to AI
    MIT Technology Review
  85. Marx’s Ethical Vision
  86. The Deskilling Debate, New Technology and Work Organization
    Acta Sociologica  
  87. Your First 100 HITS on Amazon MTURK | Working from Home with Mechanical Turk
    YouTube