Abstract

Abstract This essay explores what it is to be a principle of charity in philosophical argumentation. In it, I explore some principles of charity found in classic and contemporary literature and textbooks on logic and philosophy. I distinguish between what I will maximal and sub-maximal principles of charity. With this distinction, I taxonomize current principles of charity on offer according to their dialectical function as rules for argument interpretation and reconstruction in philosophical argumentation. Principles of charity, I argue, are best construed as pragmatic rules for argument interpretation in philosophical argumentation, not merely moral or ratio-epistemic rules. I defend this claim against some objections.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2025-03-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-024-09648-7
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (41) · 1 in this index

  1. Adler, J. E. 1981. Why be charitable? Informal logic 4(2): 15–16.
    Why Be Charitable? Informal Logic
  2. Adler, J. E. 1984. Fallacies and Alternative Interpretations. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 72(3): 271–282.
    Australasian Journal of Philosophy  
  3. Adler, J. E. 1996. Charity, Interpretation, Fallacy. Philosophy and Rhetoric 29(4): 329–343.
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  4. Straw Man Arguments: A Study in Fallacy Theory
  5. Introducing Logic and Critical Thinking: The Skills of Reasoning and the Virtues of Inquiry
Show all 41 →
  1. Philosophical Writings. Trans. G. E. Anscombe and P. T. Geach
  2. Logic Works: A Rigorous Introduction to Formal Logic
  3. Feser, E. 2019. Simply irresistible. Theopolois Institute. Retrieved January 25, 2013, from https://theopolis…
  4. Finocchiaro, M. 2013. Meta-argumentation: An approach to logic and argumentation theory. In Studies in logic,…
  5. Govier, T. 1981a. On Adler on Charity. Informal Logic 4(3): 10–11.
    Informal Logic  
  6. Govier, T. 1981b. Uncharitable Thoughts about Charity. Informal Logic 4(1): 5–6.
    Informal Logic  
  7. Govier, T. 1983. Who Says There Are No Fallacies? Informal Logic 5(1): 2–10.
    Informal Logic
  8. Govier, T. 1989. Analogies and Missing Premises. Informal Logic 11(3): 141–152.
    Informal Logic  
  9. Govier, T. 2018. Problems in argument analysis and evaluation. Updated edition. Windsor Studies in Argumentat…
  10. Gracia, J. E. 1992. Philosophy and its history: Issues in philosophical historiography. SUNY.
  11. Hacking, I. 1975. Why does language matter to philosophy?. Cambridge University Press.
  12. Critical Thinking: The Basics
  13. What Is the Argument? An Introduction to Philosophical Argument and Analysis
  14. Good Arguments: Making Your Case in Writing and Public Speaking
  15. Johnson, R. H. 1980. Charity Begins at Home. Informal Logic 3(3): 4–9.
    Informal Logic
  16. Critique of Pure Reason. Trans. N. K. Smith
  17. The Nature of Argument
  18. Argumentation
  19. Lewiński, M. 2012. The Paradox of Charity. Informal Logic 32(4): 403–439.
    Informal Logic  
  20. Martin, R. M. 1983. Mind, modality, meaning, and method. SUNY.
  21. Mullins, R. 2019a. The doctrine of divine simplicity. Theopolis Institute. Retrieved January 25, 2023, from h…
  22. Mullins, R. 2019b. The ongoing debate over divine simplicity: a response to the conversation. Theopolis Insti…
  23. Peregrin, J. 2020. Philosophy of logical systems. Routledge Studies in Contemporary Philosophy. Routledge.
  24. Philosophical Reasoning: A Study in the Methodology of Philosophizing
  25. Philosophical Dialectics: An Essay on Metaphilosophy
  26. Reasoning
  27. Making Sense: A Theory of Interpretation
  28. Argumentation Theory: A Pragma-dialectical Perspective. Argumentation Library
  29. Argumentation: Analysis and Evaluation
  30. Vorobej, M. 2006. A Theory of Argument. Cambridge University Press.
  31. Walton, D. 1998. The new dialectic: Conversational contexts of argument. University of Toronto.
  32. Walton, D. 2008. Informal logic: A pragmatic approach. 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press.
  33. Walton, D. 2013. Methods of argumentation. Cambridge University Press.
  34. Walton, D., C. Reed, and F. Macagno. 2008. Argumentation schemes. Cambridge University Press.
  35. Wilson, N. 1959. Substance without substrata. Review of Metaphysics 12(4): 521–539.
    Review of Metaphysics
  36. Yaqub, A. M. 2013. An Introduction to Logical Theory. Toronto: Broadview Press.