Abstract

AbstractRational agency is of central interest to philosophy, with evolutionary accounts of the cognitive underpinnings of rational agency being much debated. Yet one building block—our ability to argue—is less studied, except Mercier and Sperber’s argumentative theory (Mercier and Sperber in Behav Brain Sci 34(02):57–74,10.1017/s0140525x10000968, 2011, in The enigma of reason. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 2017). I discuss their account and argue that it faces a lacuna: It cannot explain the origin of argumentation as a series of small steps that reveal how hominins with baseline abilities of the trait in question could turn into full-blown owners of it. This paper then provides a first sketch of the desired evolutionary trajectory. I argue that reasoning coevolves with the ability to coordinate behavior. After that, I establish a model based on niche construction theory. This model yields a story with following claims. First, argumentation came into being during the Oldowan period as a tool for justifying information ‘out of sight’. Second, argumentation enabled hominins to solve collective action problems with collaborators out of sight, which stabilized argumentative practices eventually. Archeological findings are discussed to substantiate both claims. I conclude with outlining changes resultant from my model for the concept of rational agency.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2020-06-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-020-09510-6
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (84)

  1. After Phrenology
  2. Antón, Susan C., William R. Leonard, and Marcia L. Robertson. 2002. An Ecomorphological Model of the Initial …
    Journal of Human Evolution  
  3. Antón, Susan C., and Carl C. Swisher III. 2004. Early Dispersals of Homo From Africa. Annual Review of Anthro…
    Annual Review of Anthropology  
  4. More Than Nature Needs
  5. Blumenschine, Robert J., Henry T. Bunn, Valerius Geist, Fumiko Ikawa-Smith, Curtis W. Marean, Anthony G. Payn…
    Current Anthropology  
Show all 84 →
  1. Boesch, Christophe, and Hedwige Boesch. 1984. Mental Map in Wild Chimpanzees: An Analysis of Hammer Transport…
    Primates  
  2. The Chimpanzees of the Tai Forest
  3. Material Cultures, Material Minds
  4. Bunn, Henry T. 1994. Early Pleistocene Hominid Foraging Strategies Along the Ancestral Omo River at Koobi For…
    Journal of Human Evolution  
  5. Bunn, Henry T., Ellen M. Kroll, Stanley H. Ambrose, Anna K. Behrensmeyer, Lewis R. Binford, Robert J. Blumens…
    Current Anthropology  
  6. Machiavellian Intelligence II: Extensions and Evaluations 2
  7. Byrne, Richard W. 2000. Evolution of Primate Cognition. Cognitive Science 24 (3): 543–570.
    Cognitive Science  
  8. Calcott, B. 2008. Lineage Explanations: Explaining How Biological Mechanisms Change. The British Journal for …
    The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science  
  9. The Rise of Homo Sapiens: The Evolution of Modern Thinking
  10. The Evolution of Reason: Logic as a Branch of Biology
  11. The Nature of Reasoning
  12. Darmstadter, Howard. 2013. Why Do Humans Reason? A Pragmatist Supplement to an Argumentative Theory. Thinking…
    Thinking & Reasoning  
  13. Day, Rachel L., Kevin N. Laland, and F.John Odling-Smee. 2003. Rethinking Adaptation: The Niche-Construction …
    Perspectives in Biology and Medicine  
  14. de Heinzelin, Jean, J. Desmond Clark, Tim White, William Hart, Paul Renne, Giday WoldeGabriel, Yonas Beyene, …
    Science  
  15. Domı́nguez-Rodrigo, Manuel, Ignacio de La Torre, Luis de Luque, Luis Alcalá, Rafael Mora, Jordi Serrallonga, …
    Journal of Archaeological Science  
  16. Formal Languages in Logic
  17. Enactivist Interventions
  18. Complexity and the Function of Mind in Nature
  19. The Evolution of Intelligence
  20. Godfrey-Smith, Peter. 2017. Complexity Revisited. Biology & Philosophy 32 (3): 467–479. https://doi.org/10.10…
    Biology & Philosophy  
  21. Goren-Inbar, Naama, Nira Alperson, Mordechai E. Kislev, Orit Simchoni, Yoel Melamed, Adi Ben-Nun, and Ella We…
    Science  
  22. Harmand, Sonia, Jason E. Lewis, Craig S. Feibel, Christopher J. Lepre, Sandrine Prat, Arnaud Lenoble, Xavier …
    Nature  
  23. Geology of the Olduvai Gorge: A Study of Sedimentation in a Semiarid Basin
  24. Heyes, Cecilia. 2012. New Thinking: The Evolution of Human Cognition. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal…
    Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences  
  25. Cognitive Gadgets: The Cultural Evolution of Thinking
  26. Entangled
  27. Hodder, Ian. 2014. The Entanglements of Humans and Things: A Long-Term View. New Literary History 45 (1): 19–…
    New Literary History  
  28. The MIT Encyclopedia of the Cognitive Sciences
  29. Proceedings of the Conference of the Australasian Society for Cognitive Science
  30. Jeffares, Ben. 2013. Back to Australopithecus: Utilizing New Theories of Cognition to Understand the Pliocene…
    Biological Theory  
  31. Embodied Mind, Meaning, and Reason
  32. Modelling the Early Human Mind
  33. Kappelman, John. 1996. The Evolution of Body Mass and Relative Brain Size in Fossil Hominids. Journal of Huma…
    Journal of Human Evolution  
  34. Laden, Greg, and Richard Wrangham. 2005. The Rise of the Hominids as an Adaptive Shift in Fallback Foods: Pla…
    Journal of Human Evolution  
  35. Laland, Kevin N., and Gillian R. Brown. 2006. Niche Construction, Human Behavior, and the Adaptive-Lag Hypoth…
    Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews  
  36. Laland, Kevin N., John Odling-Smee, and Marcus W. Feldman. 2000. Niche Construction, Biological Evolution, an…
    Behavioral and Brain Sciences  
  37. Lamb, Trevor D., Shaun P. Collin, and Edward N. Pugh. 2007. Evolution of the Vertebrate Eye: Opsins, Photorec…
    Nature Reviews Neuroscience  
  38. On the Move: How and Why Animals Travel in Groups
  39. Leonard, William R., and Marcia L. Robertson. 1997. Comparative Primate Energetics and Hominid Evolution. Ame…
    American Journal of Physical Anthropology  
  40. Le Geste Et La Parole
  41. How Things Shape the Mind
  42. Marwick, Ben. 2003. Pleistocene Exchange Networks as Evidence for the Evolution of Language. Cambridge Archae…
    Cambridge Archaeological Journal  
  43. McHenry, Henry M. 1992. Body Size and Proportions in Early Hominids. American Journal of Physical Anthropolog…
    American Journal of Physical Anthropology  
  44. From Biped to Strider: The Emergence of Modern Human Walking, Running, and Resource Transport
  45. Cognitive Integration
  46. Open MIND
  47. Mercier, Hugo. 2013. The Function of Reasoning: Argumentative and Pragmatic Alternatives. Thinking & Reasonin…
    Thinking & Reasoning  
  48. Mercier, Hugo, and Dan Sperber. 2011. Why Do Humans Reason? Arguments for an Argumentative Theory. The Behavi…
    The Behavioral and Brain Sciences  
  49. The Enigma of Reason
  50. Nilsson, D.E. 2013. Eye Evolution and Its Functional Basis. Visual Neuroscience 30 (1–2): 5–20. https://doi.o…
    Visual Neuroscience  
  51. Norman, Andy. 2016. Why We Reason: Intention-Alignment and the Genesis of Human Rationality. Biology & Philos…
    Biology & Philosophy  
  52. Ohel, M. 1984. Spatial Management of Hominid Groups at Olduvai: A Preliminary Exercise. Paleoecology of Afric…
    Paleoecology of Africa
  53. O’Madagain, Cathal. 2019. Is Reasoning Culturally Transmitted? Teorema: Revista Internacional De Filosofía 38…
    Teorema: Revista Internacional De Filosofía
  54. O’Madagain, Cathal, and Michael Tomasello. 2019. Joint Attention to Mental Content and the Social Origin of R…
    Synthese  
  55. Osvath, Mathias, and Peter Gärdenfors. 2004. Oldowan Culture and the Evolution of Anticipatory Cognition. Lun…
    Lund University Cognitive Studies
  56. Blackwell Handbook of Judgement and Decision Making
  57. Overmann, Karenleigh A. 2017. Thinking Materially: Cognition as Extended and Enacted. Journal of Cognition an…
    Journal of Cognition and Culture  
  58. Plummer, Thomas. 2004. Flaked Stones and Old Bones: Biological and Cultural Evolution at the Dawn of Technolo…
    American Journal of Physical Anthropology Suppl  
  59. Potts, Richard. 1984. Home Bases and Early Hominids. American Scientist 72: 338–347.
    American Scientist
  60. Evolutionary Psychology as Maladapted Psychology
  61. Articulating the World
  62. Santibáñez Yáñéz, Cristián. 2015. Steps Towards an Evolutionary Account of Argumentative Competence. Informal…
    Informal Logic  
  63. Seitz, Fabian. 2020. A mind selected by needs. Acta Analytica. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12136-020-00421-5.
    Acta Analytica  
  64. Semaw, Sileshi. 2000. The World’s Oldest Stone Artefacts From Gona, Ethiopia: Their Implications for Understa…
    Journal of Archaeological Science  
  65. Semaw, Sileshi, Michael J. Rogers, Jay Quade, Paul R. Renne, Robert F. Butler, Manuel Dominguez-Rodrigo, Diet…
    Journal of Human Evolution  
  66. Sober, Elliott. 1981. The Evolution of Rationality. Synthese 46 (1): 95–120.
    Synthese  
  67. Human Reasoning and Cognitive Science
  68. The Evolved Apprentice
  69. Sterelny, Kim. 2012b. Language, Gesture, Skill: The Co-Evolutionary Foundations of Language. Philosophical Tr…
    Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences  
  70. Sterelny, Kim. 2016a. Deacon’s Challenge: From Calls to Words. Topoi 35 (1): 271–282. https://doi.org/10.1007…
    Topoi  
  71. Sterelny, Kim. 2016b. Cumulative Cultural Evolution and the Origins of Language. Biological Theory 11 (3): 17…
    Biological Theory  
  72. The Routledge Handbook of Evolution and Philosophy
  73. A Companion to the Philosophy of Action
  74. Sutton, John. 2010. Exograms and Interdisciplinarity: History, the Extended Mind, and the Civilizing Process.…
  75. A Natural History of Human Thinking
  76. Ungar, Peter S., Frederick E. Grine, and Mark F. Teaford. 2006. Diet in Early Homo: A Review of the Evidence …
    Annual Review of Anthropology  
  77. The Nariokotome Homo Erectus Skeleton
  78. Wood, Bernard. 1992. Early Hominid Species and Speciation. Journal of Human Evolution 22 (4–5): 351–365.
    Journal of Human Evolution  
  79. Wynn, Thomas. 2002. Archaeology and Cognitive Evolution. The Behavioral and Brain Sciences 25 (3): 389–402. (…
    The Behavioral and Brain Sciences