Argumentation Theory for Mathematical Argument

Joseph Corneli University of Edinburgh ; Ursula Martin University of Oxford ; Dave Murray-Rust Edinburgh College ; Gabriela Rino Nesin University of Brighton ; Alison Pease University of Dundee

Abstract

To adequately model mathematical arguments the analyst must be able to represent the mathematical objects under discussion and the relationships between them, as well as inferences drawn about these objects and relationships as the discourse unfolds. We introduce a framework with these properties, which has been used to analyse mathematical dialogues and expository texts. The framework can recover salient elements of discourse at, and within, the sentence level, as well as the way mathematical content connects to form larger argumentative structures. We show how the framework might be used to support computational reasoning, and argue that it provides a more natural way to examine the process of proving theorems than do Lamport’s structured proofs.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2019-06-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-018-9474-x
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

Cites in this index (2)

  1. Argumentation
  2. Argumentation
Also cites 47 works outside this index ↓
  1. The argument of mathematics
  2. Aliseda, A. 2003. Mathematical reasoning versus abductive reasoning: a structural approach. Synthese 134(1–2)…
    Synthese  
  3. Barany, M. 2010. ‘[B]ut this is blog maths and we’re free to make up conventions as we go along’: Polymath1 a…
  4. Botting, D. 2015. Inferences and illocutions. Argument & Computation 6(3): 246–264.
    Argument & Computation  
  5. Budzynska, K. 2013. Circularity in ethotic structures. Synthese 190(15): 3185–3207.
    Synthese  
  6. Budzynska, K., M. Janier, C. Reed, and P. Saint-Dizier. 2016. Theoretical foundations for illocutionary struc…
    Argument & Computation  
  7. Corneli, J., U. Martin, D. Murray-Rust, and A. Pease. 2017a. Towards mathematical AI via a model of the conte…
  8. Corneli, J., U. Martin, D. Murray-Rust, A. Pease, R. Puzio, and G. Rino Nesin. 2017b. Modelling the way mathe…
  9. Corneli, J., A. Pease, and D. Stefanou. 2018. Social aspects of concept invention. In Concept invention: foun…
  10. Dove, I.J. 2009. Towards a theory of mathematical argument. Foundations of Science 14(1–2): 137–152.
    Foundations of Science  
  11. The argument of mathematics
  12. Dutilh Novaes, C. 2016. Reductio ad absurdum from a dialogical perspective. Philosophical Studies 173(10): 26…
    Philosophical Studies  
  13. Epstein, S.L. 2015. Wanted: collaborative intelligence. Artificial Intelligence 221: 36–45.
    Artificial Intelligence  
  14. Rhetorical figures in science
  15. Fahnestock, J. 2004. Figures of argument (OSSA 2005 Keynote Address). Informal Logic 24(2).
  16. Fiedler, A., and H. Horacek. 2007. Argumentation within deductive reasoning. International Journal of Intelli…
    International Journal of Intelligent Systems  
  17. Ganesalingam, M. 2013. The language of mathematics: a linguistic and philosophical investigation, LNCS, vol 7…
  18. Ganesalingam, M., and W. Gowers. 2017. A fully automatic theorem prover with human-style output. Journal of A…
    Journal of Automated Reasoning  
  19. On the shape of mathematical arguments
    Lecture Notes in Computer Science  
  20. Harris, R., and C. D. Marco. 2017. Argument & Computation 8(3) [Special Issue on Rhetorical figures, argument…
  21. Associative networks: representation and use of knowledge by computers
  22. Hersh, R. 1991. Mathematics has a front and a back. Synthese 88(2): 127–133.
    Synthese  
  23. Inglis, M., J.P. Mejia-Ramos, and A. Simpson. 2007. Modelling mathematical argumentation: the importance of q…
    Educational Studies in Mathematics  
  24. Kamp, H., and U. Reyle. 1993. From discourse to logic introduction to modeltheoretic semantics of natural lan…
  25. Karttunen, L. 1976. Discourse referents. In Syntax and semantics, vol 7, ed. J.D. McCawley. Notes from the Li…
  26. Proofs and refutations: the logic of mathematical discovery
  27. Lamport, L. 1995. How to write a proof. The American Mathematical Monthly 102(7): 600–608.
    The American Mathematical Monthly  
  28. Lamport, L. 2012. How to write a 21st century proof. Journal of Fixed Point Theory and Applications 11(1): 43–63.
    Journal of Fixed Point Theory and Applications  
  29. Larvor, B. 2012. How to think about informal proofs. Synthese 187(2): 715–730.
    Synthese  
  30. Lawrence, J., J. Visser, and C. Reed. 2017. Harnessing rhetorical figures for argument mining. Argument & Com…
    Argument & Computation  
  31. Automated deduction—CADE-25
  32. Mercier, H., and D. Sperber. 2011. Why do humans reason? Arguments for an argumentative theory. Behavioral an…
    Behavioral and Brain Sciences  
  33. Mitrović, J., C. OReilly, M. Mladenović, and S. Handschuh. 2017. Ontological representations of rhetorical fi…
    Argument & Computation  
  34. Modgil, S., and J. McGinnis. 2007. Towards characterising argumentation based dialogue in the argument interc…
  35. Moens, M. F. 2018. Argumentation mining: How can a machine acquire common sense and world knowledge? Argument…
  36. Pease, A., A. Smaill, S. Colton, and J. Lee. 2009. Bridging the gap between argumentation theory and the phil…
    Foundations of Science  
  37. Pedemonte, B. 2007. How can the relationship between argumentation and proof be analysed? Educational Studies…
    Educational Studies in Mathematics  
  38. Reed, C., K. Budzynska, R. Duthie, M. Janier, B. Konat, J. Lawrence, A. Pease, and M. Snaith. 2017. The argum…
    Philosophy & Technology  
  39. Robertson, D. 2012. Lightweight coordination calculus for agent systems: retrospective and prospective. Sprin…
  40. Robinson, J.A. 1965. A machine-oriented logic based on the resolution principle. Journal of the ACM (JACM) 12…
    Journal of the ACM (JACM)  
  41. Sowa, J. F. 2008. Conceptual graphs. In Handbook of knowledge representation, ed. van Harmelen F, Lifschitz V…
  42. Tanswell, F. 2015. A problem with the dependence of informal proofs on formal proofs. Philosophia Mathematica…
    Philosophia Mathematica  
  43. van der Sandt, R.A. 1992. Presupposition projection as Anaphora resolution. Journal of Semantics 9(4): 333–37…
    Journal of Semantics  
  44. van Oers, B. 2002. Fruits of polyphony: a commentary on a multiperspective analysis of mathematical discourse…
    Journal of the Learning Sciences  
  45. Argumentation schemes
  46. Tropics of discourse: essays in cultural criticism
  47. Zack, V., and B. Graves. 2001. Making mathematical meaning through dialogue: “once you think of it, the Z min…
    Educational Studies in Mathematics