Argumentation Jun 2017 Open Access

The Structure of Arguments by Analogy in Law

Luís Duarte d’Almeida University of Edinburgh ; Cláudio Michelon Edinburgh College
Journal
Argumentation
Published
2017-06-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-016-9409-3
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Green
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Stevens (2020)
    On the Puzzling Death of the Sanctity-of-Life Argument
    Argumentation

References (52) · 1 in this index

  1. L Alexander (2008)
    Demystifying legal reasoning
     ↗
  2. M Atienza (1986)
    Sobre la analogía en el Derecho: Ensayo de análisis de un razonamiento jurídico
  3. Austin, J. 1911. Lectures on jurisprudence, volume 2, 5th edition, ed. R. Campbell. London: John Murray.
  4. Z Bańkowski (1991)
    Legal knowledge and analogy
     ↗
  5. N Bobbio (1938)
    L’Analogia nella logica del diritto
Show all 52 →
  1. LG Boonin (1965)
    Boonin, L.G. 1965. The logic of legal decisions. Ethics 75(3): 179–194.
    Ethics  ↗
  2. S Brewer (1996)
    Brewer, S. 1996. Exemplary reasoning: Semantics, pragmatics, and the rational force of legal argument by anal…
    Harvard Law Review  ↗
  3. CW Collier (1988)
    Collier, C.W. 1988. Precedent and legal authority: A critical history. Wisconsin Law Review 1988(5): 771–825.
    Wisconsin Law Review
  4. R Cross (1991)
    Precedent in English law
     ↗
  5. N Duxbury (2008)
    The nature and authority of precedent
     ↗
  6. MA Eisenberg (1988)
    The nature of the common law
  7. J Finnis (2011)
    Philosophy of law: Collected essays
     ↗
  8. Gianformaggio, L. 2008. L’analogia giuridica. In L. Gianformaggio, Filosofia del diritto e ragionamento giuri…
  9. MP Golding (2001)
    Legal reasoning
  10. MP Golding (1988)
    Reason in law: Proceedings of the conference held in Bologna, 12–15 December 1984
  11. AL Goodhart (1930)
    Goodhart, A.L. 1930. Determining the ratio decidendi of a case. The Yale Law Journal 40(2): 161–183.
    The Yale Law Journal  ↗
  12. T Govier (1987)
    Problems in argument analysis and evaluation
     ↗
  13. T Govier (1989)
    Govier, T. 1989. Analogies and missing premises. Informal Logic 11(3): 141–152.
    Informal Logic  ↗
  14. (1938)
    Readings in jurisprudence
  15. T Halper (1968)
    Halper, T. 1968. Logic in judicial reasoning. Indiana Law Journal 44(1): 33–48.
    Indiana Law Journal
  16. DH Hodgson (1967)
    The consequences of utilitarianism: A study in normative ethics and legal theory
  17. D Hunter (2001)
    Hunter, D. 2001. Reason is too large: Analogy and precedent in law. Emory Law Journal 50(4): 1197–1264.
    Emory Law Journal
  18. Juthe (2005)
    Argument by Analogy
    Argumentation
  19. G Kalinowski (1965)
    Introduction a la logique juridique: Éléments de sémiotique juridique, logique des normes…
  20. U Klug (1982)
    Juristische Logik
     ↗
  21. G Lamond (2005)
    Lamond, G. 2005. Do precedents create rules? Legal Theory 11(1): 1–26.
    Legal Theory  ↗
  22. G Lamond (2014)
    Lamond, G. 2014. Analogical reasoning in the common law. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 34(3): 567–588.
    Oxford Journal of Legal Studies  ↗
  23. Lamond, G. 2016. Precedent and analogy. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2016 Edition), ed.…
  24. JL Landau (1981)
    Landau, J.L. 1981. Logic for lawyers. Pacific Law Journal 13(1): 59–98.
    Pacific Law Journal
  25. EH Levi (1949)
    An introduction to legal reasoning
  26. T McKay (1997)
    McKay, T. 1997. Analogy and argument. Teaching Philosophy 20(1): 49–60.
    Teaching Philosophy  ↗
  27. JR Murray (1982)
    Murray, J.R. 1982. The role of analogy in legal reasoning. UCLA Law Review 29(4): 833–871.
    UCLA Law Review
  28. EW Patterson (1942)
    Patterson, E.W. 1942. Logic in the law. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 90(8): 875–909.
    University of Pennsylvania Law Review  ↗
  29. RA Posner (2006)
    Posner, R.A. 2006. Reasoning by analogy. Cornell Law Review 91(3): 761–774.
    Cornell Law Review
  30. GJ Postema (2007)
    Common law theory
     ↗
  31. WV Quine (1978)
    The web of belief
  32. J Raz (2009)
    The authority of law: Essays on law and morality
  33. D Reidhav (2007)
    Reasoning by analogy: A study on analogy-based arguments in law
  34. F Rinaldi (1971)
    Rinaldi, F. 1971. Is analogy a decision process in English law? Logique et Analyse 14(53–4): 363–374.
    Logique et Analyse
  35. A Rotolo (2001)
    Identità e somiglianza: Saggio sul pensiero analogico nel diritto
  36. F Schauer (2008)
    Schauer, F. 2008. Why precedent in law (and elsewhere) is not totally (or even substantially) about analogy. …
    Perspectives on Psychological Science  ↗
  37. F Schauer (2009)
    Thinking like a lawyer: A new introduction to legal reasoning
     ↗
  38. F Schauer (2013)
    Schauer, F. 2013. Analogy in the Supreme Court: Lozman v City of Riviera Beach. The Supreme Court Review 2013…
    The Supreme Court Review  ↗
  39. FP Shecaira (2013)
    Shecaira, F.P. 2013. Analogical arguments in ethics and law: A defence of a deductivist analysis. Informal Lo…
    Informal Logic  ↗
  40. AWB Simpson (1961)
    Oxford essays in jurisprudence
  41. G Spielthenner (2014)
    Spielthenner, G. 2014. Analogical reasoning in ethics. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 17(5): 861–874.
    Ethical Theory and Moral Practice  ↗
  42. CR Sunstein (1993)
    Sunstein, C.R. 1993. On analogical reasoning. Harvard Law Review 106(3): 741–791.
    Harvard Law Review  ↗
  43. CR Sunstein (1996)
    Legal reasoning and political conflict
     ↗
  44. LL Weinreb (2005)
    Legal reason: The use of analogy in legal argument
     ↗
  45. VA Wellman (1985)
    Wellman, V.A. 1985. Practical reasoning and judicial justification: Toward an adequate theory. University of …
    University of Colorado Law Review
  46. P Westen (1982)
    Westen, P. 1982. On ‘confusing ideas’: Reply. The Yale Law Journal 91(6): 1153–1165.
    The Yale Law Journal  ↗
  47. J White (2010)
    A companion to philosophy of law and legal theory
     ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 10 View in citation network → Build reading path →