Strategic Maneuvering in Mathematical Proofs

Erik C. W. Krabbe University of Groningen

Abstract

This paper explores applications of concepts from argumentation theory to mathematical proofs. Note is taken of the various contexts in which proofs occur and of the various objectives they may serve. Examples of strategic maneuvering are discussed when surveying, in proofs, the four stages of argumentation distinguished by pragma-dialectics. Derailments of strategies (fallacies) are seen to encompass more than logical fallacies and to occur both in alleged proofs that are completely out of bounds and in alleged proofs that are at least mathematical arguments. These considerations lead to a dialectical and rhetorical view of proofs.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2008-08-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-008-9098-7
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (2)

  1. Argumentation
  2. Argumentation

References (34) · 1 in this index

  1. Aristotle. 1965. On sophistical refutations (trans: Forster, E.S.). In Aristotle, On sophistical refutations;…
  2. Aristotle. 1976. Posterior analytics; Topica (trans: Trendennick, H., Posterior analytics; trans: Forster, E.…
  3. Bell, E.T. 1965. Men of mathematics, vol. 2. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books (Pelican Books A 277) [First ed. 1937].
  4. Mathematical thought
  5. Beth, H.E.J. 1929. Inleiding in de niet-Euclidische meetkunde op historischen grondslag [Introduction to non-…
Show all 34 →
  1. Argumentation
  2. Foundations of mathematical logic
  3. Dove, I.J. 2007. On mathematical proofs and arguments: Johnson and Lakatos. In Proceedings of the sixth confe…
  4. Fermat’s last theorem: A genetic introduction to algebraic number theory
  5. Euler, L. 1770. Vollständige Anleitung zur Algebra. St. Petersburg.
  6. Begriffsschrift, eine der arithmetischen nachgebildete Formelsprache des reinen Denkens
  7. Goethe, J.W. von. 1949. Maximen und Reflexionen. In J.W. von Goethe, Die Wahlverwandtschaften, Die Novellen, …
  8. Invalid Proof. September 10, 2007, 14: 36. In Wikipedia. Retrieved October 10, 2007, from http://en.wikipedia…
  9. Manifest rationality: A pragmatic theory of argument
  10. The development of logic
  11. Krabbe, E.C.W. 1991. Quod erat demonstrandum: Wat kan en mag een argumentatietheorie zeggen over bewijzen? [Q…
  12. Krabbe, E.C.W. 1997. Arguments, proofs, and dialogues. In Dialogisches Handeln: Eine Festschrift für Kuno Lor…
  13. Krabbe, E.C.W. 2004. Strategies in dialectic and rhetoric. In Argumentation and its applications, ed. H.V. Ha…
  14. Krabbe, E.C.W., and J.A. van Laar. 2007. About old and new dialectic: Dialogues, fallacies, and strategies. I…
    Informal Logic: Reasoning and Argumentation in Theory and Practice  
  15. Lakatos, I. 1976. In Proofs and refutations: The logic of mathematical discovery, ed. John Worral and Elie G.…
  16. Plato. 1997. Meno (trans: Grube, G.M.A.). In Plato, Complete works, ed. J.M. Cooper and D.S. Hutchinson, 870–…
  17. Saccheri, G.G. 1733. Euclides ab omni naevo vindicatus [Euclid freed from every birth mark]. Milan.
  18. Tarski, A. 1956. The concept of truth in formalized languages. In Tarski, Logic, semantics, metamathematics: …
  19. Tarski, A. 1983. The concept of truth in formalized languages. In Tarski, Logic, semantics, metamathematics: …
  20. Van Dalen, D. 2006. Weet u dat zeker? Over (on)zekerheden in de wiskunde [Are you sure? About (un)certainties…
  21. Speech acts in argumentative discussions: A theoretical model for the analysis of discuss…
  22. Argumentation, communication, and fallacies: A pragma-dialectical perspective
  23. A systematic theory of argumentation: The pragma-dialectical approach
  24. Van Eemeren, F.H., and P. Houtlosser. 1999a. Delivering the goods in critical discussion. In Proceedings of t…
  25. Van Eemeren, F.H., and P. Houtlosser. 1999b. William the silent’s argumentative discourse. In Proceedings of …
  26. Van Eemeren, F.H., and P. Houtlosser. 2002. Strategic manoeuvring in argumentative discourse: A delicate bala…
  27. Van Eemeren, F.H., and P. Houtlosser. 2004. More about fallacies as derailments of strategic maneuvering: The…
  28. Van Eemeren, F.H., and P. Houtlosser. 2005. Theoretical construction and argumentative reality: An analytical…
  29. Commitment in dialogue: Basic concepts of interpersonal reasoning