Reading Material

Abstract

It is not uncommon to find literacy figured as “toxic” in discussions of its power to regulate and discipline social behavior. The author's aim in this article is to move from metaphor to material as he explores the toxicity inherent in the manufacturing processes that make print available for mass consumption. He argues that over the past century, the demand for print in certain regions of the United States, primarily the North and West, spurred the growth of commercial papermaking—and the spread of devastating mill pollution—in the South, where demand for print has historically lagged. He suggests that one result of this pollution has been the weakening of social institutions that typically promote and value normative forms of literate activity. With the industries that enable the mass circulation of print now going global, this pattern of uneven and unjust literacy development may well be repeated.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
2001-10-01
DOI
10.1177/0741088301018004001
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (4)

  1. College English
  2. College English
  3. Literacy in Composition Studies
  4. Literacy in Composition Studies

References (207) · 2 in this index

  1. Health-track
  2. Paper cuts: Recovering the paper landscape
  3. The Associate Press State and Local Wire
  4. Paper profits: Pollution in the pulp and paper industry
  5. The education of Blacks in the South, 1860-1935
Show all 207 →
  1. Critical literacy: Politics, praxis, and the postmodern
  2. Preliminary estimated book publishing industry net sales: 1987, 1992, 1997-1999
  3. What works: A decade of change at Champion International
  4. An index number for state school systems
  5. Troubled waters: Champion International and the Pigeon River controversy
  6. The state of inequality
  7. The invention of Appalachia
  8. Poisoning our water: How the government permits pollution
  9. Milwaukee Journal
  10. The manufactured crisis: Myths, fraud, and the attack on America's public schools
  11. The employment of English: Theory, jobs, and the future of literary studies
  12. Appalachia in the making: The mountain South in the nineteenth century
  13. 10.1007/BF02678330
  14. 10.1017/9780521780339
  15. 10.17763/haer.69.4.n17353q6lw872473
  16. Literacy in American lives
  17. Chattanooga Times/Chattanooga Free Press
  18. 10.1086/448889
  19. Pulping the south: Industrial tree plantations and the world paper economy
  20. Waste Treatment Technology News
  21. Champion: 100 years of papermaking in Hamilton, Ohio
  22. 1994 annual report
  23. Reader's Digest
  24. Angels' town: Chero ways, gang life, and rhetorics of the everyday
  25. Industrialization and Southern society, 1877-1984
  26. The selling of the South: The Southern crusade for industrial development, 1936-1990
  27. In the Tennessee Mountains
  28. In the Tennessee Mountains
  29. The raid of the guerilla and other stories
  30. The struggle and the tools: Oral and literate strategies in an inner city community
  31. Journal of Proceedings and Addresses [of the Southern Educational Association]
  32. University of Cincinnati Record
  33. Universal education in the South
  34. A memoir
  35. Revolution and the word: The rise of the novel in America
  36. The Houston Chronicle
  37. From mountain to metropolis: Appalachian migrants in American cities
  38. Sentimental education: Schooling, popular culture and the regulation of liberty
  39. The French Broad
  40. Miners, millhands, and mountaineers: Industrialization of the Appalachian South, 1880-1930
  41. The Associated Press State and Local Wire
  42. Education of the American population
  43. Christy
  44. Changes in the location of manufacturing in the United States since 1929
  45. The signifying monkey: A theory of African-American literary criticism
  46. Critical literacy: Politics, praxis, and the postmodern
  47. The betrayal of Local 14
  48. The uneducated
  49. Critical literacy: Politics, praxis, and the postmodern
  50. `Round my way: authority and double-consciousness in three urban high school writers
  51. The legacies of literacy: Continuities and contradictions in Western culture and society
  52. Christy
  53. An economic analysis of the pulp and paper
  54. The Virginian-Pilot
  55. College Composition and Communication
  56. College Composition and Communication
  57. To the people: James Yen and village China
  58. Harbrace college handbook
  59. Two worlds in the Tennessee mountains: Exploring the origins of Appalachian stereotypes
  60. International Paper: From innovation to results, a conversation about the future
  61. New York Times
  62. The Reading Teacher
  63. Literacy in the United States: Readers and Reading since 1880
  64. New York Times
  65. Adult literacy in America: A first look at the results of the National Adult Literacy Survey
  66. The case against standardized testing: Raising the scores, ruining the schools
  67. 10.1002/bms.1200140811
  68. 10.1016/0045-6535(87)90003-8
  69. Tappi
  70. Equity and adequacy in education finance: Issues and perspectives
  71. Carnival on the page: Popular print media in antebellum America
  72. The possessive investment in Whiteness: How White people profit from identity politics
  73. Literacies of power: What Americans are not allowed to know
  74. Shooting for excellence: African American and youth culture in new century schools
  75. E: The Environmental Magazine
  76. Who was who in America
  77. Christy
  78. Rich media, poor democracy: Communication politics in Dubious Times
  79. The Baltimore Sun
  80. The invisible minority: Urban Appalachians
  81. The hangman's beautiful daughter
  82. Most wonderful machine: Mechanization and social change in Berkshire paper making, 1801-1885
  83. Contradictions of school reform: Educational costs of standardized testing
  84. Something new under the sun: An environmental history of the twentieth-century world
  85. 1990 Lockwood-Post's directory of the pulp, paper and allied trades
  86. As if learning mattered: Reforming higher education
  87. Mr. Clog and the log
  88. Newport Plain Talk
  89. The Herald
  90. Literacy across communities
  91. Tennessee school report card
  92. The Nation
  93. The digest of educational statistics
  94. The National Cyclopædia of American Biography
  95. The state of literacy in America: Estimates at the local, state, and national levels
  96. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction for the scholastic years 1889…
  97. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction of North Carolina for the sch…
  98. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction of North Carolina to Governor…
  99. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction of North Carolina for the sch…
  100. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction of North Carolina for the sch…
  101. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction of North Carolina for 1938-19…
  102. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction of North Carolina for 1950-19…
  103. Biennial report of the superintendent of public instruction of North Carolina for 1958-19…
  104. Consuming power: A social history of American energies
  105. From mountain to metropolis: Appalachian migrants in American cities
  106. The American pulp and paper industry, 1900-1940: Mill survival, firm structure, and indus…
  107. Thirty-seventh annual report of the state commissioner of common schools to the general a…
  108. The forty-seventh annual report of the state commissioner of common schools to the govern…
  109. The fifty-eighth annual report of the state commissioner of common schools to the governo…
  110. Sixty-ninth annual report of the director of education to the governor of the State of Oh…
  111. Seventy-seventh and seventy-eighth annual reports of the director of education to the gov…
  112. Eighty-fifth and eighty-sixth annual reports of the director of education to the governor…
  113. The sixty-fifth annual report of the superintendent of public instruction to the governor…
  114. The sixty-eighth annual report of the superintendent of public instruction to the governo…
  115. Selling culture: Magazines, markets, and class at the turn of the century
  116. The paper plantation: Ralph Nader's study group report on the pulp and paper industry in Maine
  117. Industry Week
  118. 2001 Lockwood-Post's directory of the pulp, paper and allied trades
  119. Paper Task Force recommendations for purchasing and using environmentally preferable pape…
  120. The Florida Times-Union
  121. Educational Marketer
  122. Educational Marketer
  123. 10.1017/S030574100005284X
  124. Publishers Weekly children's bestseller list, July 2000
  125. Pulp & paper mills in the U.S. & Canada
  126. Other people's words: The cycle of low literacy
  127. Primetime live
  128. 1997 annual report
  129. Market guide
  130. Synthetic estimates of adult literacy proficiency
  131. EDF's Paper Task “Force” or “farce”?
  132. The way we were: The myths and realities of America's student achievement
  133. Standardized minds: The high price of America's testing culture and what we can do to change it
  134. New York Times
  135. The business of books
  136. The rise and fall of English: Reconstructing English as a discipline
  137. Newport Plain Talk
  138. Appalachia on our mind: The Southern mountains and mountaineers in the American conscious…
  139. History of papermaking in the United States (1691-1969)
  140. The U.S. paper industry and sustainable production: An argument for restructuring
  141. Erin Brockovich
  142. Literacy in theory and practice
  143. The copyright book: A practical guide
  144. The violence of literacy
  145. Toxic literacies: Exposing the injustice of bureaucratic texts
  146. Tennessee communities: County profiles
  147. Annual report of the Department of Education for the scholastic year ending June 30, 1931
  148. Annual report of the Department of Education for the scholastic year ending June 30, 1940
  149. Annual statistical report of the Department of Education for the scholastic year ending J…
  150. Annual statistical report of the Department of Education for the scholastic year ending J…
  151. 21st century report card
  152. Annual report of the state superintendent of public instruction for Tennessee for the sch…
  153. Annual report of the state superintendent of public instruction for Tennessee for the sch…
  154. Biennial report of the state superintendent of public instruction for Tennessee for the s…
  155. Biennial report of the state superintendent of public instruction for Tennessee for the s…
  156. Ohioana
  157. The China Human Development Report
  158. Education for all year 2000 assessment: Statistical document
  159. UNESCO annual statistical yearbook 1999
  160. United States historical census browser
  161. County and city data book: 1994 county files
  162. Cost of living in the United States
  163. Money disbursements of wage earners and clerical workers in the North Atlantic region, 1934-36
  164. Money disbursements of wage earners and clerical workers in the North Atlantic region, 1934-36
  165. Money disbursements of wage earners and clerical workers in five cities in the Pacific re…
  166. Money disbursements of wage earners and clerical workers in five cities in the West Centr…
  167. Money disbursements of wage earners and clerical workers in eight cities in the East Nort…
  168. Money disbursements of wage earners and clerical workers, 1934-36, summary volume
  169. Money disbursements of employed wage earners and clerical workers in twelve cities of the…
  170. Consumer expenditures and income: Detail of expenditures and income; total northeastern r…
  171. Consumer expenditures and income: Detail of expenditures and income; total North Central …
  172. Consumer expenditures and income: Detail of expenditures and income; total Southern regio…
  173. Consumer expenditures and income: Detail of expenditures and income; total Western region…
  174. Consumer expenditures and income: Detail of expenditures and income; total United States,…
  175. Consumer expenditure survey: Interview survey, 1972-73
  176. Consumer expenditure survey, 1984
  177. Consumer expenditure survey, 1985
  178. Consumer expenditure survey, 1986
  179. Consumer expenditure survey, 1987
  180. Consumer expenditure survey, 1988
  181. Consumer expenditure survey, 1989
  182. Consumer expenditure survey, 1990
  183. Consumer expenditure survey, 1991
  184. Consumer expenditure survey, 1992
  185. Consumer expenditure survey, 1993
  186. Consumer expenditure survey, 1994
  187. Consumer expenditure survey, 1995
  188. Consumer expenditure survey, 1996
  189. Consumer expenditure survey, 1997
  190. Consumer expenditure survey, 1998
  191. Population: 1790 to 1990
  192. The farmer's standard of living
  193. Eighteenth annual report of the commissioner of labor, 1903
  194. Sixth annual report of the commissioner of labor, 1890
  195. Top 25 U.S. Export Destinations for HTS 4901990010: Textbooks
  196. Top 25 U.S. Import Sources for HTS 4901990010: Textbooks
  197. Tappi
  198. Study of consumer expenditures, incomes and savings
  199. Illiteracy in the United States
  200. Funding public schools: Politics and policies
  201. A civil action
  202. Rebuilding the pulp and paper workers' union, 1933-1941