Variation and Authenticity in a Study of Children's Written Humor

CAROLE EDELSKY; LYNDON W. SEARFOSS; YVONNE M. MERSEREAU

doi:10.1177/0741088386003003004

Written Communication Jul 1986

Variation and Authenticity in a Study of Children's Written Humor

CAROLE EDELSKY ; LYNDON W. SEARFOSS ; YVONNE M. MERSEREAU Arizona State University

Abstract

Presented here is a brief report of a study along with an extensive criticism of this and other studies that use contrived tasks for investigating children's humor and writing. The original study had hoped to anwer questions related to how child-produced humor might vary with the sex and age of the intended audience, how writing would figure in child-produced humor, and any relationships that might exist between production of and talk about humor. Two middle-class fourth-grade classrooms were told a contrived story and asked to produce something funny for some sick children. Children in one class produced something for two sick children, both male, one in first and one in eighth grade. The other class produced something for two sick children, both female, one in first and one in eighth grade. Productions (N = 136) were collected and analyzed. Of the fourth graders, 9 were then interviewed about their conceptions of humor and of their productions. Children's productions did vary according to the age and sex of the intended audience. There were no particular relationships between the humor of variability of the productions and the talk about humor. The major criticism in this and similar studies is that the data are flawed. Despite efforts in the opposite direction, the contrived task produced a confused pragmatic context. Once the pragmatics were distorted, the data no longer represented the phenomena of interest—humor and writing. Without extensive observations and interviews, there is little evidence that these findings represent what the chosen variables make them appear to represent. An argument is thus made for increased sensitivity to what phenomena research data actually represent.

Journal: Written Communication
Published: 1986-07-01
DOI: 10.1177/0741088386003003004
CompPile: Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access: Closed
Topics: discourse analysis
Export: BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (33)

Bereiter, C.

Cognitive processes in writing
Bogdan, R. C.

Qualitative research for education: An introduction to theory and methods
Britton, J.

Research on composing
Calkins, L.

Lessons from a child
10.1111/j.1460-2466.1976.tb01920.x

↗

Show all 33 →

Dyson, A. (1982)

10.58680/la198226471

Language Arts ↗
Edelsky, C.

Development of writing in a bilingual program
Edelsky, C.

Writing in a bilingual program: Habia una vez
10.2307/356600

↗
10.1017/S0305000900001781

↗
Goffman, E.

Forms of talk
Graves, D.

Writing: Teachers and children at work
Green, J.

Ethnography and language in educational settings
Guba, E.

Toward a methodology of naturalistic inquiry in educational evaluation
Harste, J.

annual meeting of American Education Research Association
Kroll, B. (1978)

Language Arts
Lindfors, J.

Children's language and learning
10.1037/h0076942

↗
10.1017/S0305000900007534

↗
McDermott, R.

Future of education for exceptional students
Mehan, J.

The reality of ethnomethodology
Montes, R.

Children's functional language and education in the early years
10.1037/0022-0663.73.1.106

↗
Newkirk, T. (1982)

Harvard Educational Review
Odell, L.

Colloquium Series on Qualitative Research, Arizona State University
10.2307/1127755

↗
10.1037/h0035549

↗
10.1080/00221325.1976.10533994

↗
Smelstor, M.

A guide to teaching the importance of audience and subject
10.1080/00405847909542843

↗
10.1086/461174

↗
Taylor, D.

Family literacy
10.3102/0013189X012010006

↗

CrossRef global citation count: 1 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Variation and Authenticity in a Study of Children's Written Humor

Abstract

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

References (33)

Related Articles