Rhetoric Society Quarterly Jan 1996

The rhetoric of liberty

Deirdre McCloskey

Abstract

For a long time now, of course, intellectuals have been trying to avoid rhetoric in defense of liberty. They might as well avoid mere reasoning or mere speaking. The defenses are commonly set in the axiom-and-proof rhetoric of the line Eucid-Aquinas-Hobbes-Russell. Formality is trumps and the meaning of formality is an imitation of Euclid's certitude. Consider Alan Peacock's twopage article on Economic Freedom in The New Paigrave: A Dictionary of Economics (which with Alan Ryan's other two on Liberty in the Dictionary brings the total of modem economic reflection on liberty to four pages out of some 4000). Peacock begins by setting the question of economic freedom into the standard Samuelsonian framework of modem economics-maximization of utility under a budget constraint-with careful delineation of the subscripts, as though relevant. After two opening paragraphs of such mathpride, however, he rejects his own formal construct, pointing out that mere liberty to move within a budget constraint is not what people mean by liberty.Anything-the KGB's rules of conduct in pre-democratic Lithuania, for example-can be included in the budget constraint, making slaves by definition into men, to choose within the constraints of their shackles. Peacock argues plausibly that more than liberty to move about within a budget constraint must be required: Economic freedom requires that the various terms in the budget constraint reflect the absence of 'preference or restraint' (Adam Smith) on the (Vol. 2,33). As Herbert Spencer said, when he is under the impersonal coercion of Nature, we say that he is free (493, italics added). Peacock then tries to connect the absence of or to the market: Therefore (the prices must) ... result from the operation of competitive market forces with the individual being to choose between alternatives (italics added). The therefore fails in strict logic, though demanded by the axiom-and-proof rhetoric of his piece. The problem is that it is not obvious that an absence of preference or restraint requires competition. Peacock does

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
1996-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773949609391057
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (39)

  1. Aristotle (1991)
    Rhetoric
  2. Barry Brian (1965)
    Political Argument
  3. Berlin Isaiah (1969)
    Four Essays on Liberty
  4. Booth Wayne (1974)
    Modern Dogma and the Rhetoric of Assent
  5. Fish Stanley (1994)
    There's No Such Thing as Free Speech . . . And It's a Good Thing, Too
Show all 39 →
  1. Friedman Milton (1962)
    Capitalism and Freedom
  2. Fussell Paul (1989)
    Wartime: Understanding and Behavior in the Second World War
  3. Guthrie W. K. C. (1971)
    The Sophists
     ↗
  4. Jaeger Werner (1965)
    Paideia: the Ideals of Greek Culture
    Archaic Greece. The Mind of Athens
  5. Kerferd G. B. (1981)
    The Sophistic Movement
  6. Knight Frank (1929)
    Freedom and Reform: Essays in Economics and Social Philosophy
  7. _____ (1936)
    Freedom and Reform
  8. _____ (1944)
    Freedom and Reform
  9. Lanham Richard A. (1974)
    Style: An Anti‐Textbook
  10. _____ (1991)
    A Handlist of Rhetorical Terms.
  11. _____ (1992)
    The Politics of Liberal Education
  12. _____ (1993)
    The Electronic Word: Democracy, Technology, and the Arts
  13. McCloskey D. N. (1990)
    If You're So Smart: The Narrative of Economic Expertise
  14. _____ (1995)
    American Economic Review
  15. Macaulay Thomas B. (1830)
    Edinburgh Review
  16. 1881.Macaulay's Essays, Riverside Edition vol. I, iiBoston reprinted 1860 in
  17. Nozick Robert (1974)
    Anarchy, State, and Utopia
  18. Partridge H. (1967)
    The Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  19. Peacock Alan
    The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics
  20. Plato (1925)
    Plato III: Lysis, Symposium, Gorgias
  21. _____ (1914)
    Plato I: Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Phedo, Phaedrus
  22. _____ (1921)
    Plato VII: Theaetetus, Sophist
  23. Polanyi Michael (1951)
    The Logic of Liberty
  24. Rowley Charles (1975)
    Welfare Economics: A Liberal Re‐Interpretation
  25. Ryan Alan (1987)
    The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics
  26. Smith Adam (1976)
    An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations
  27. _____ (1976)
    The Theory of Moral Sentiments
  28. Spencer Herbert (1891)
    A Plea for Liberty
  29. Spencer, ed. 1981.The Man versus the State, 487–518. Indianapolis: Liberty Classics. reprinted
  30. Tacitus C. (1914)
    101 AD. Dialogus in Tacitus in Five Volumes
  31. Taylor Charles (1979)
    The Idea of Freedom: Essays in Honor of Isaiah Berlin
  32. 10.1017/CBO9780511607875
     ↗
  33. Vickers Brian (1989)
    Classical Rhetoric in English Poetry
  34. White James Boyd (1984)
    When Words Lose Their Meaning
     ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 1 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Computers and Composition Jun 2026
    Navigating platform algorithms: Global south feminist activists’ rhetorical and composition practices in digital advocacy on social media ↗
    Kalpana Shrestha
    rhetorical criticism social media gender and writing
  2. Computers and Composition Jun 2026
    Legacies, commitments, and new challenges: The Sweetland Digital Rhetoric Collaborative interviews three generations of Computers and Composition editors ↗
    Ali Alalem; Alyse Campbell; Thais Rodrigues Cons; Funmilola Fadairo; Nicole Koyuki Golden
    rhetorical criticism collaborative writing digital rhetoric
  3. Computers and Composition Jun 2026
    How Baldwin's voice moved Cambridge: Activation contours, mimesis, and a computational approach to rhetoric's sensorium ↗
    David M. Rieder; Michael R. Jackson
    rhetorical criticism
  4. Written Communication May 2026
    Genres Fall Apart: Recuperating the Centrifugal in Rhetorical Genre Analysis ↗
    Rebecca Lorimer Leonard; Angela Rounsaville
    rhetorical criticism genre theory multilingual writers literacy studies community literacy
  5. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly May 2026
    Andrew Carnegie and the Rhetorical History of Business and Professional Communication ↗
    Joe Edward Hatfield
    rhetorical criticism teacher development professional writing archival research