Erikson on Freud on Irma: The rhetoric of the patriarchy

Darryl Hattenhauer Bemidji State University

Abstract

Abstract In their writings about one of the most important cornerstones in the edifice of psychoanalysis, Freud's interpretation of his Irma Dream, Freud and Erikson act as apologists for the modern patriarchy. Using the rhetorical persona of the progressive, scientific hero, Freud and Erikson cast themselves as protagonists in the drama of modernization. Their rhetorical structures, syntax, and diction reveal their sexism. The strategy of their discourses invites their audience to believe that the audience is witnessing scientific discoveries in the making; the rhetoric of Freud and Erikson suggests that their discourse is not patriarchal rationalization, but rational analysis, the drama of the scientific method applied for progress. Their interpretation of Freud's Irma Dream disassociates Freud from women, assigning separate behaviors for rational, progressive males and irrational, traditional females. But the truth of the Irma Dream is that it associates Freud with females and reveals the irresponsibility of both his pharmacological and psychological prescriptions.

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
1984-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773948409390702
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (45)

  1. The Interpretation of Dreams
  2. 10.1177/000306515400200101
    American Psychoanalytic Association Journal  
  3. Campbell, Karlyn Kohrs. 1972.Critiques of Contemporary Rhetoric, 137Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
  4. Freud.Dreamsxxiv
  5. Freud.Dreamsxxiv
Show all 45 →
  1. Freud.Dreams142
  2. Freud.Dreams137
  3. Freud.Dreams151
  4. Freud.Dreams138
  5. Diacritics
  6. Willbern. “Interpenetration,”. 98
  7. Willbern. “Interpenetration,”. 99
  8. Willbern. “Interpenetration,”. 104
  9. Freud.Dreams106
  10. Freud.Dreams151
  11. Freud.Dreams152
  12. Freud.Dreams144–45.
  13. Freud.Dreams139
  14. Freud.Dreams150
  15. Freud.Dreams149
  16. Freud.Dreams138
  17. Freud.Dreams144
  18. Freud.Dreams148
  19. Freud.Dreams150
  20. Freud.Dreams153
  21. Freud.Dreams151
  22. Freud.Dreams153
  23. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 45
  24. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 5
  25. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 7
  26. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 9
  27. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 8
  28. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 33
  29. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 51
  30. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 8–9.
  31. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 16
  32. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 49
  33. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 45
  34. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 46
  35. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 54
  36. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 31
  37. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 33
  38. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 33–34.
  39. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 26
  40. Erikson. “Specimen,”. 48