Rhetoric Review Sep 1993

Generative semantics: Secret handshakes, anarchy notes, and the implosion ofethos

R. Allen Harris

Abstract

Ethos is generally associated with individual rhetors.1 Certainly that's association Aristotle had in mind when he recorded most influential usage of term (Rhetoric 1356a). But there is ample warrant for moving to a broader level-the level adopted in this paper, a case study of outrageous of a group of generative linguists on cusp of sixties and seventies. There is ample warrant for identifying not simply with specific individuals in specific orations but also with identifiable communities. In ordinary language, for instance, has always been far more communal than individual: Ethos.... [ 1.] The characteristic spirit, prevalent tone of sentiment, of a people or community; 'genius' of an institution or system (OED, 1933 reissue) . And it has a similar sense among our academic neighbors-in literary criticism, where books have titles like The Ethos of Restoration Comedy (Schneider); in sociology, where books have titles like The Ethos of Hong Kong Chinese (Siu-Kai), or, more famously, in Merton's discussion of general ethos of science (268). Coming closer to home, consider Augustine's notion of a Christian ethos, which presupposes that rhetor stands for group values (De Doctrina 4.27-29). Consider similarly presupposing admonition of George Campbell about influence of party-spirit (97). Consider Black's above-epigramitized talk of patterned commitments and stylistic proclivities, which, as Halloran tells us, is essentially projection of to communal level (Black 85; Halloran, Molecular Biology 71). Elsewhere, Halloran tells us more: the word has both an individual and a collective meaning. It makes sense to speak of of this or that person, but it makes equally good sense to speak of of a particular

Journal
Rhetoric Review
Published
1993-09-01
DOI
10.1080/07350199309389030
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument qualitative research literary studies
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (124) · 3 in this index

  1. Newmeyer.Linguistic Theory93–173.
  2. Huck
    Deep Structure
  3. Harris
    Linguistic Wars
     ↗
  4. Abraham Werner (1972)
    Generative Semantik.
  5. Aristotle (1991)
    A Theory of Civic Discourse: On Rhetoric.
Show all 124 →
  1. _____
    The Nichomachean Ethics.
  2. Augustine (1958)
    On Christian Doctrine.
  3. Bach Emmon (1968)
    Universals in Linguistic Theory.
  4. Bazerman Charles (1988)
    Shaping Written Knowledge: The Genre and Activity in the Experimental Article in Science.
  5. Black Edwin
    Form and Genre: Shaping Rhetorical Action.
  6. Booth Wayne C. (1974)
    Modern Dogma and the Rhetoric of Assent.
  7. Borkin Ann (1984)
    Problems in Form and Function.
  8. _____ (1968)
    Where the Rules Fail: A Student's Guide. An Unauthorized Appendix to M. K. Burt's From De…
  9. Botha Rudoph P. (1990)
    Challenging Chomsky.
  10. Bouton, Lawrence F. 1970. “Antecedent‐contained Preforms.”. Papers from the Sixth Regional Meeting of the Chi…
  11. Brame Michael K. (1976)
    Conjectures and Refutations in Syntax and Semantics.
  12. Burke Kenneth (1945)
    A Grammar of Motives.
  13. Burt Marina K. (1971)
    From Deep to Surface Structure: An Introduction to Transformational Syntax.
  14. Campbell George (1963)
    The Philosophy of Rhetoric.
  15. 10.1080/03637757009375644
     ↗
  16. 10.1080/00335637509383301
     ↗
  17. 10.1080/00335637509383302
     ↗
  18. Carden, Guy. 1970. “The Deep Structure of Both.”. Papers from the Sixth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Lingu…
  19. Carroll Lewis (1960)
    The Annotated Alice.
  20. CHERRY (1988)
    Ethos Versus Persona: Self-Representation in Written Discourse
    Written Communication
  21. Chomsky Noam (1957)
    Syntactic Structures.
     ↗
  22. _____ (1965)
    Aspects of the Theory of Syntax.
  23. _____ (1975)
    Reflections on Language.
  24. _____ (1982)
    Some Concepts and Consequences of the Theory of Government and Binding.
  25. Darnell Regna (1992)
    Studies out in Left Field: Defamatory Essays Presented to James D. McCawley.
  26. Davison, Alice. 1970. “Causal Adverbs and Performative Verbs.”. Papers from the Sixth Regional Meeting of the…
  27. Demosthenes (1930)
    Olynthiacs, Philippics, Minor Public Speeches, Speech against Leptinos.
  28. 10.2307/628928
     ↗
  29. Fillmore Charles J. (1971)
    Studies in Linguistic Semantics.
  30. Gordon W. Terrence (1987)
    Whimsy V: American Humor
  31. Gragg, Gene B. 1972. “Semi‐Indirect Discourse and Related Nightmares.”. Papers from the Eighth Regional Meeti…
  32. 10.2307/412417
     ↗
  33. _____. 1972. “Some Observations on the Syntax and Semantics of Instrumental Verbs.”. Papers from the Eighth R…
  34. Grinder, John. 1970. “Super Equi‐NP Deletion.”. Papers from the Sixth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguis…
  35. Hagège Claude (1981)
    Critical Reflections on Generative Grammar.
  36. Hall Robert A. (1987)
    Linguistics and Pseudo‐linguistics: Selected Essays, 1965–1985.
     ↗
  37. Halloran (1982)
    Aristotle's concept of ethos, or if not his somebody else's
    Rhetoric Review
  38. _____ (1978)
    Form and Genre: Shaping Rhetorical Knowledge.
  39. Halloran (1984)
    The birth of molecular biology: An essay in the rhetorical criticism of scienti…
    Rhetoric Review
  40. Harris, R. Allen. 1990. “The Life and Death of Generative Semantics.”. Troy, NY: Rensselaer Polytechnic Insti…
  41. _____ (1993)
    The Linguistics Wars.
  42. _____ (1993)
    Historiographica Linguistica
  43. Hoey Michael (1984)
    Forum Linguisticum
  44. Hoffman Abbie (1971)
    Woodstock Nation.
  45. Holton Gerald (1988)
    Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought.
  46. Horn, Laurence R. 1970. “Ain't it Hard (Anymore).”. Papers from the Sixth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Lin…
  47. _____. 1971. “Negative Transportation: Unsafe at Any Speed?”. Papers from the Seventh Regional Meeting of the…
  48. Horowitz David (1972)
    Counterculture and Revolution.
  49. Huck Geoffrey J. (1993)
    Contemporary Linguistics
  50. Jacobs Roderick A. (1970)
    Readings in English Transformational Grammar.
  51. Katz Jerrold J. (1964)
    An Integrated Theory of Linguistic Descriptions.
  52. Lakoff George (1968)
    Where the Rules Fail: A Student's Guide. An Unauthorized Appendix to M. K. Burt's
    From Deep to Surface Structure
  53. _____ (1970)
    Irregularity in Syntax
    [On the Nature of Syntactic Irregularity]
  54. _____ (1971)
    Semantics: An Interdisciplinary Reader in Philosophy, Linguistics and Psychology.
  55. _____ (1972)
    Semantics of Natural Language.
  56. _____. 1973. “Fuzzy Grammar and the Performance/Competence Terminology Game.”. Papers from the Ninth Regional…
  57. _____ (1975)
    Formal Semantics of Natural Language.
  58. _____. 1977. “Linguistic Gestalts.”. Papers from the Thirteenth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic So…
  59. _____ (1988)
    The Best of CLS
  60. Lakoff George (1976)
    Notes from the Linguistic Underground
    (=Syntax and Semantics 7)  ↗
  61. Lakoff Robin Tolmach (1968)
    Abstract Syntax and Latin Complementation.
  62. _____. 1971. “Passive Resistance.”. Papers from the Seventh Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Societ…
  63. _____. 1972. “The Pragmatics of Modality.”. Papers from the Eighth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic…
  64. _____. “What You can do with Words: Politeness, Pragmatics, and Performatives.”. Proceedings of the Texas Con…
  65. 10.1016/0378-2166(89)90016-7
     ↗
  66. McCawley James D. (1976)
    Notes from the Linguistic Underground.
     ↗
  67. Lawler, John. 1971. “Any Questions.”. Papers from the Seventh Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Soci…
  68. _____. 1972. “Generic to a Fault.”. Papers from the Eighth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society…
  69. 10.1080/00335638609383764
     ↗
  70. McCawley James D. (1976)
    Notes from the Linguistic Underground.
     ↗
  71. _____ (1976)
    Grammar and Meaning.
  72. _____ (1979)
    Adverbs, Vowels, and Other Objects of Wonder.
  73. _____ (1982)
    Thirty Million Theories of Grammar.
  74. _____
    Dictionary of Linguistics.
  75. Merton Robert K. (1973)
    The Sociology of Science: Theoretical and Empirical Investigations.
  76. Miller Carolyn (1982)
    PRE/TEXT
  77. Moravcsik Edith A. (1976)
    Current Approaches to Syntax [=Syntax and Semantics 13]
  78. Morgan, Jerry L. 1970. “On the Criterion of Identity for Noun Phrase Deletion.”. Papers from the Sixth Region…
  79. _____. 1972. “Verb‐Agreement as a Rule of English.”. Papers from the Eighth Regional Meeting of the Chicago L…
  80. _____ (1973)
    Papers in Linguistics
  81. _____ (1976)
    Notes from the Linguistic Underground.
  82. Myers Greg (1990)
    Writing Biology: Texts in the Social Construction of Scientific Knowledge.
  83. Neubauer, Paul. 1970. “On the Notion ‘Chopping Rule.’”. Papers from the Sixth Regional Meeting of the Chicago…
  84. Newmeyer Frederick J. (1980)
    Linguistic Theory in America.
  85. _____ (1986)
    Linguistic Theory in America.
  86. _____ (1991)
    The Chomskyan Turn.
  87. O'Donnell W. R. (1974)
    Archivum linguistica
  88. Parmenides (1935)
    The Early Philosophers of Greece.
  89. Peranteau Paul (1972)
    The Chicago Which Hunt: Papers from the Relative Clause Festival.
  90. Perelman Chaim (1969)
    The New Rhetoric: A Treatise on Argumentation.
  91. Postal Paul M. (1964)
    Constituent Structure.
    Publication 30 of the Indiana U Research Center in Anthropology, Folklore, and Linguistics
  92. _____ (1968)
    Aspects of Phonological Theory.
  93. _____ (1976)
    Notes from the Linguistic Underground.
  94. _____ (1988)
    The Best of CLS A Selection of Out‐of‐Print Papers from 1968 to 1975.
  95. Prelli L. J. (1989)
    Rhetoric in the Human Sciences.
  96. Pullum Geoffrey K. (1991)
    The Great Eskimo Vocabulary Hoax and Other Irreverent Essays on the Study of Language.
  97. Dong, Quang Phuc and McCawley, James D. 1971. “The Applicability of Transformations to Idioms.”. Papers from …
  98. Quine Willard Van Orman (1985)
    The Time of My Life.
  99. Rogers, Andy. 1971. “Three Kinds of Physical Perception Verbs.”. Papers from the Seventh Regional Meeting of …
  100. Ross John Robert (1970)
    Progress in Linguistics: A Collection of Papers.
  101. _____ (1972)
    Syntax and Semantics I.
  102. _____ (1972)
    Foundations of Language
  103. _____ (1973)
    The Formal Analysis of Natural Languages.
  104. Roszak Theodore (1969)
    The Making of a Counterculture: Reflections on the Technocratic Society and its Youthful …
  105. Rubin Jerry (1971)
    We are Everywhere.
  106. Sadock, Jerrold. 1974. “Read at Your Own Risk: Syntactic and Semantic Horrors You Can Find in Your Medicine C…
  107. Schmerling, Susan. 1971. “Presupposition and the Notion of Normal Stress.”. Papers from the Seventh Regional …
  108. _____. 1973. “Subjectless Sentences and the Notion of Surface Filter.”. Papers from the Ninth Regional Meetin…
  109. Schneider Ben Ross (1971)
    The Ethos of Restoration Comedy.
  110. Shenker Israel (1972)
    New York Times
  111. Siu‐Kai Lau (1989)
    The Ethos of the Hong Kong Chinese.
  112. Wall Robert (1970)
    Studies out in Left Field: Defamatory Essays Presented to James D. McCawley. Current Inqu…
  113. Weaver Richard M. (1985)
    The Ethics of Rhetoric.
  114. Weimer Walter B. (1977)
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  115. Whately Richard (1963)
    Elements of Rhetoric.
  116. Yoos George (1979)
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  117. Foo Yuck (1970)
    Studies out in Left Field: Defamatory Essays Presented to James D. McCawley. Current Inqu…
  118. Zwicky Arnold M. (1970)
    Studies out in Left Field: Defamatory Essays Presented to James D. McCawley. Current Inqu…
  119. _____. 1976. “Well, this Rock and Roll has to Stop. Junior's Head is Hard as a Rock.”. Papers from the Twelft…
CrossRef global citation count: 6 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Written Communication Jan 2023
    Humanistic Knowledge-Making and the Rhetoric of Literary Criticism: Special Topoi Meet Rhetorical Action ↗
    Sarah Banting
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis argument literary studies
  2. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Sep 2022
    Arguing with Numbers: The Intersection of Rhetoric and Mathematics ↗
    Christopher Tindale
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis writing pedagogy argument qualitative research gender and writing book reviews editorial matter
  3. Philosophy & Rhetoric Nov 2020
    Rhetoric and Demagoguery ↗
    Fielding Montgomery
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument assessment qualitative research gender and writing public rhetoric
  4. Rhetorica Sep 2019
    Persuading God: Rhetorical Studies of First-Person Psalms by Davida H. Charney ↗
    Stanley E. Porter
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis argument literary studies
  5. Rhetorica Apr 2018
    Demosthenes’ On the Crown: Rhetorical Perspectives ed. by James J. Murphy ↗
    Michael Gagarin
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis revision argument qualitative research public rhetoric