Philosophy & Rhetoric Dec 2023

Enlightenment Rhetoric Reconsidered: Hume’s Discursive Transcendence in “Of Eloquence”

Alexander W. Morales University of Memphis

Abstract

ABSTRACT The phrase “Enlightenment rhetoric” typically denotes discourses bent on rejecting classical oratorical styles in favor of purportedly scientific ones. Likewise, scholars often associate Enlightenment rhetorical styles with the scientific epistemologies that emerged in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. This article reconsiders Enlightenment rhetoric by analyzing David Hume’s 1742 essay “Of Eloquence.” More specifically, the article argues that the Scottish Enlightenment context necessitated a rhetoric that compensated for the discursive limitations of new scientific worldviews. In so doing, the article argues that Hume verbalizes the transcendent dimension of classical eloquence in ways commensurate with the emphasis on perspicuity emerging in English culture, a rhetorical maneuver that the author calls discursive transcendence. Hume’s “Of Eloquence” thus serves as a case study demonstrating how an Enlightenment writer advanced a rhetoric that both rejects and pulls from prior rhetorical traditions, constituting a new understanding of Enlightenment rhetoric.

Journal
Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published
2023-12-31
DOI
10.5325/philrhet.56.3-4.0242
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism voice and style qualitative research
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (98) · 3 in this index

  1. Aristotle (1994)
    Metaphysics
  2. (1980)
    “Why the French Christian Democrats Were Condemned.”
    Church History  ↗
  3. (2022)
    Communication Ethics and Tenacious Hope: Contemporary Implications of the Scottish Enligh…
  4. (2004)
    The Enlightenment and Religion: The Myths of Modernity
  5. (2016)
    “The Philosophy of Prosopopoeia.”
    Journal of Nietzsche Studies  ↗
Show all 98 →
  1. (1983)
    “David Hume and the Suppression of ‘Atheism.’”
    Journal of the History of Philosophy  ↗
  2. (1969)
    “Hume’s Philosophy in George Campbell’s ‘Philosophy of Rhetoric.”’
    Philosophy & Rhetoric
  3. (1961)
    “Hume, ‘Philosophe’ and Philosopher in Eighteenth-Century France.”
    French Studies  ↗
  4. (2014)
    The Suasive Art of David Hume
  5. (2021)
    The Emergence of Pastoral Authority in the French Reformed Church (c.1555–c.1572)
  6. (1997)
    “Water for Roman Brothels: Cicero ‘Cael.’ 34.”
    Phoenix  ↗
  7. (1961)
    The Rhetoric of Religion: Studies in Logology
  8. (1981)
    The Great Debate on Miracles: From Joseph Glanvill to David Hume
  9. (1933)
    “Classical Rhetoric and the Mediaeval Theory of Preaching.”
    Classical Philology  ↗
  10. (2005)
    La hybris del punto cero: Cienza, raza e Ilustración en la Nueva Granada (1750–1816)
  11. (2014)
    The Cambridge Companion to the French Enlightenment, Cambridge
  12. (2009)
    The Rhetoric of Aristotle
  13. (1977)
    “Apostrophe.”
    Diacritics  ↗
  14. (2007)
    “Has Anything Changed? Hume’s Theory of Association and Sympathy after the Treatise.”
    British Journal for the History of Philosophy  ↗
  15. (1991)
    Empiricism and Subjectivity: An Essay on Hume’s Theory of Human Nature
  16. (2012)
    “Hume’s Experimental Method.”
    British Journal for the History of Philosophy  ↗
  17. (1997)
    “Foundational Standards and Conversational Style: The Humean Essay as an Issue of Philoso…
    Philosophy & Rhetoric
  18. (2011)
    The Jewish Enlightenment
  19. (2009)
    Diccionario político y social del mundo iberoamericano
  20. (2012)
    La aurora de la libertad. Los primeros liberalismos en el mundo iberoamericano
  21. (1995)
    “Hume’s Concealed Attack on Religion and His Early Critics.”
    Journal of Philosophical Research  ↗
  22. (1996)
    “The Eighteenth-Century British Reviews of Hume’s Writings.”
    Journal of the History of Ideas  ↗
  23. (1984)
    Techniques of Good Writing
  24. Frogel (2004)
    Philosophical Argumentation: Logic and Rhetoric
    Argumentation
  25. (1998)
    Scottish Rhetoric and Its Influences
  26. (2002)
    Cognition and Commitment in Hume’s Philosophy
  27. (1966)
    The Enlightenment, an Interpretation: The Rise of Modern Paganism
  28. (1994)
    “The Objects of Hume’s Treatise.”
    Hume Studies  ↗
  29. (2000)
    Rereading Aristotle’s Rhetoric
  30. (2012)
    The Politics of Eloquence: David Hume’s Polite Rhetoric
  31. (1972)
    “Empiricism, Description, and the New Rhetoric.”
    Philosophy & Rhetoric
  32. (1992)
    “Idealizing Hume.”
    Hume Studies  ↗
  33. (1992)
    “The Rhetorical Career of Thomas Woolston: A Radical Challenges the Rules of Discourse.”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
  34. (2007)
    “Relations of Literary Form and Philosophical Purpose in Hume’s Four Essays on Happiness.”
    Hume Studies  ↗
  35. Homer (2019)
    Odyssey
  36. (2000)
    Hume’s Problem: Induction and the Justification of Belief
  37. (1932)
    The Letters of David Hume
  38. (1977)
    An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding
  39. (1983)
    An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals
  40. (1987)
    Essays: Moral, Political and Literary
  41. (2000)
    A Treatise of Human Nature
  42. (1992)
    “Hume’s Revised Racism.”
    Journal of the History of Ideas  ↗
  43. (2001)
    Radical Enlightenment: Philosophy and the Making of Modernity, 1650–1750
  44. (2006)
    “Enlightenment! Which Enlightenment?”
    Journal of the History of Ideas  ↗
  45. (2005)
    The Reception of David Hume in Europe
  46. Kennerly (2010)
    Getting Carried Away: How Rhetorical Transport Gets Judgment Going
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  47. (2005)
    Women, Gender and Enlightenment
  48. (2013)
    “Anglicanism, Scottish Presbyterianism, and the Irreligious Aim of Hume’s Treatise.”
    Hume Studies
  49. (2010)
    “Saphêneia in Aristotle: Clarity, Precision, and Knowledge.”
    Apeiron
  50. Mackay (2014)
    Prosopopoeia, Pedagogy, and Paradoxical Possibility: The “Mother” in the Sixtee…
    Rhetoric Review
  51. (2015)
    “Introduction: Enlightenments in Ibero-America.”
    Colonial Latin American Review  ↗
  52. (2014)
    “The Politics of Eloquence: David Hume’s Polite Rhetoric by Marc Hanvelt.”
    University of Toronto Quarterly
  53. (2011)
    Rhetorical Devices: A Handbook and Activities for Student Writers
  54. (1969)
    “Rhetorical Methods in Hume’s Works on Religion.”
    Philosophy & Rhetoric
  55. (1947)
    “The Continental Reception of Hume’s Treatise, 1739–1741.”
    Mind
  56. (1952)
    “Hume and the French Men of Letters.”
    Revue Internationale de Philosophie
  57. (1980)
    The Life of David Hume
  58. (1972)
    “Two Main Questions Concerning Hume’s Treatise and Enquiry.”
    Philosophical Review  ↗
  59. (2021)
    “Hume’s Rhetorical Strategy: Three Views.”
    Journal of Scottish Philosophy  ↗
  60. (2006)
    “Hume on Meaning,”
    Hume Studies  ↗
  61. (2013)
    Hume’s Intentions
  62. (1975)
    “Experience and Imagination: Approaches to Rhetoric by John Locke and David Hume.”
    Southern Speech Communication Journal  ↗
  63. (2008)
    “The Humean Problem of Induction and Carroll’s Paradox.”
    Philosophical Studies  ↗
  64. (2017)
    The Military Enlightenment: War and Culture in the French Empire from Louis XIV to Napoleon
  65. (1980)
    The High Road to Pyrrhonism
  66. (1991)
    “Classical Eloquence and Polite Style in the Age of Hume.”
    Eighteenth-Century Studies  ↗
  67. (1994)
    The Fate of Eloquence in the Age of Hume
  68. (1992)
    “Hume and the End of Religious Dialogue.”
    Eighteenth-Century Studies  ↗
  69. (2020)
    Hume’s Epistemological Evolution
  70. Quintilian (1920)
  71. (1997)
    “The Enlightenment Above National Context: Political Economy in Eighteenth-Century Scotla…
    Historical Journal  ↗
  72. (2005)
    The Case for the Enlightenment: Scotland and Naples, 1680–1760
  73. (1994)
    “Religion in the English Enlightenment: A Review Essay.”
    Eighteenth-Century Studies  ↗
  74. (2008)
    The Riddle of Hume’s Treatise: Skepticism, Naturalism, and Irreligion
  75. (2008)
    Measuring the New World: Enlightenment Science and South America
  76. (1997)
    “A Note on Newton, Boyle, and Hume’s ‘Experimental Method.’”
    Hume Studies  ↗
  77. (2006)
    The Enlightenment and the Book: Scottish Authors and Their Publishers in Eighteenth-Centu…
  78. (1995)
    La Ilustración en la América colonial
  79. (2003)
    Recepción y difusión de textos ilustrados
  80. (1974)
    “Sympathy and Propriety in Adam Smith’s Rrhetoric.”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
  81. (1977)
    An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding
  82. (2010)
    The Anti-Enlightenment Tradition
  83. (2006)
    “The Constraints of Hume’s Naturalism.”
    Synthese
  84. (2010)
    Cultural Transfer through Translation
  85. (2011)
    Hume and the Enlightenment
  86. (1975)
    From Enlightenment to Revolution
  87. Voltaire (1919)
    Voltaire in His Letters: Being a Selection from His Correspondence
  88. (1995)
    “What Was Hume’s Contribution to the Problem of Induction?”
    Philosophical Quarterly (1950–)
  89. (1972)
    “David Hume and America.”
    Journal of the History of Ideas  ↗
  90. (2015)
    Toward a Humean True Religion: Genuine Theism, Moderate Hope, and Practical Morality
  91. (2010)
    William Wordsworth: 21st-Century Oxford Authors
  92. (1980)
    “Hume’s Ideas.”
    Hume Studies
  93. (2012)
    Hume: Precursor of Modern Empiricism
CrossRef global citation count: 1 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Written Communication Jan 2025
    Getting to “the Upper End of the Novice Zone”: An Exploration of Doctoral Students’ Writer Identity in Coauthoring With Supervisors for Publication ↗
    Jiayu Wang; Cassi Liardét
    rhetorical criticism graduate education voice and style collaborative writing qualitative research
  2. Philosophy & Rhetoric Dec 2023
    Limit Formations: Violence, Philosophy, Rhetoric ↗
    Omedi Ochieng
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis voice and style argument qualitative research social media race and writing gender and writing editorial matter
  3. Rhetorica Mar 2017
    Rhetorical Style and Bourgeois Virtue: Capitalism and Civil Society in the British Enlightenment by Mark Garrett Longaker ↗
    Glen McClish
    rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy teacher development voice and style argument qualitative research literary studies
  4. Journal of Writing Research Jun 2016
    Using Corpus Results to Guide the Discourse-Based Interview: A Case Study of a Student Writer’s Awareness of Stance in Philosophical Argumentation ↗
    Z. Lancaster
    rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis voice and style argument qualitative research
  5. IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication Sep 2003
    Case study on the development of a computer-based support tool for assisting Japanese software engineers with their English writing needs ↗
    M. Narita; K. Kurokawa; T. Utsuro
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis voice and style technical communication qualitative research digital rhetoric