Philosophy & Rhetoric Dec 2011

Not Dialectical Enough:

Karen S. Feldman University of California, Berkeley

Abstract

ABSTRACTWith respect to Benjamin’s treatments of the work of art and his historiographical method, Adorno accuses Benjamin of not being dialectical enough and of inadequate theorizing. This article argues that Adorno’s blanket prescription for more dialectics covers over a chiastic relationship between his particular concern in each case. On one hand, Adorno worries that Benjamin gives over the artwork to ideological narratives. On the other hand, Adorno is concerned that Benjamin’s historical materialism refuses historical narrative, which is precisely where Benjamin locates ideology. Indeed the disruptive potential that Adorno grants the artwork with respect to social and political ideology thus corresponds to the disruptive potential that Benjamin ascribes to his historical materialism with respect to historicist ideology. In this context the article considers the nature of autonomy for Benjamin and Adorno and its relationship to subversion, disruption, and redemption.

Journal
Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published
2011-12-01
DOI
10.5325/philrhet.44.4.0336
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (72)

  1. Adorno, Theodor . 1973. Negative Dialectics. Trans. E. B. Ashton. New York. Continuum.
  2. Adorno, Theodor . 1974. Minima Moralia. Trans. Edmund Jephcott. London: Verso.
  3. Adorno, Theodor . 1981. Prisms. Trans. Samuel and Shierry Weber. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
  4. Adorno, Theodor . 1991. Notes to Literature. Vol. 1. Ed. Rolf Tiedemann. Trans. Shierry Weber Nicholsen. New …
  5. Adorno, Theodor . 1996. Gesammelte Schriften. 20 vols. Ed. Rolf Tiedemann. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
Show all 72 →
  1. Adorno, Theodor , and Walter Benjamin. 1994. Briefwechsel, 1928–1940. Ed. Henri Lonitz. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
  2. Adorno, Theodor . 1999. The Complete Correspondence, 1928–1940. Ed. Henri Lonitz. Trans. Nicholas Walker. Cam…
  3. Adorno, Theodor , and Max Horkheimer. 1997. Dialectic of Enlightenment. New York: Verso, 1997.
  4. André, Chris . 1998. “Aphrodite's Children: Hopeless Love, Historiography, and Benjamin's Dialectical Image.”…
     ↗
  5. Arendt, Hannah . 1969. “Walter Benjamin, 1892–1940.” In Illuminations, by Walter Benjamin, trans. Harry Zohn,…
  6. Ash, Beth Sharon . 1989. “Walter Benjamin: Ethnic Fears, Oedipal Anxieties, Political Consequences.”New Germa…
     ↗
  7. Auerbach, Anthony . 2007. “Imagine No Metaphors: The Dialectical Image of Walter Benjamin.”Image and Narrativ…
  8. Bahti, Timothy . 1992. Allegories of History: Literary Historiography After Hegel. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopki…
  9. Benjamin, Walter . 1966. Briefe. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
  10. Benjamin, Walter . 1991. Gesammelte Schriften. 7 vols. Ed. Rolf Tiedemann et al. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
  11. Benjamin, Walter . 1994. The Correspondence of Walter Benjamin, 1910-1940. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
     ↗
  12. Benjamin, Walter . 1999a. The Arcades Project. Trans. Howard Eiland and Kevin McLaughlin. Cambridge, MA: Harv…
  13. Benjamin, Walter . 1999b. Selected Writings. Vol. 2. Ed. Michael W. Jennings, Howard Eiland, and Gary Smith. …
  14. Benjamin, Walter . 2003. Selected Writings. Vol. 4. Ed. Howard Eiland and Michael W. Jennings. Trans. Edmund …
  15. Bernstein, Jay M. 1992. The Fate of Art: Aesthetic Alienation from Kant to Derrida and Adorno. University Par…
  16. Bruns, Gerald L. 2008. “On the Conundrum of Form and Material in Adorno's Aesthetic Theory.”Journal of Aesthe…
     ↗
  17. Buck-Morss, Susan . 1977. The Origin of Negative Dialectics: Theodor W. Adorno, Walter Benjamin, and the Fran…
     ↗
  18. Buck-Morss, Susan . 1991. The Dialectics of Seeing: Walter Benjamin and the Arcades Project. Cambridge, MA: M…
  19. Caygill, Howard . 1998. Walter Benjamin: The Colour of Experience. London: Routledge.
  20. Caygill, Howard . 2004. “Walter Benjamin's Concept of Cultural History.” In The Cambridge Companion to Walter…
     ↗
  21. Chalmers, Adam W. 2004–5. “The Aporias of Theory: Negotiating the Dialectical Image in Walter Benjamin's Arca…
  22. Chambers, Ross . 2008. “Heightening the Lowly (Baudelaire: ‘Je N'ai Pas Oublié …’ and ‘A une Passante’).”Nine…
     ↗
  23. Cohen, Margaret . 1993. Profane Illumination: Walter Benjamin and the Paris of Surrealist Revolution. Berkele…
     ↗
  24. Corngold, Stanley , and Michael Jennings. 1986. “A Review Essay: Walter Benjamin in Recent Critical Perspecti…
     ↗
  25. Debord, Guy . 2008. The Society of the Spectacle. Trans. Donald Nicholson Smith. New York: Zone Books.
  26. Friedlander, Eli . 2008. “The Measure of the Contingent: Walter Benjamin's Dialectical Image.”Boundary35 (3): 1–26.
     ↗
  27. Gandesha, Samir . 2004. “Writing and Judging.”Philosophy and Social Criticism30 (4): 445–75.
     ↗
  28. Hall, Mirko M. 2010. “Dialectical Sonority: Walter Benjamin's Acoustics of Profane Illumination.”Telos152: 83–102.
     ↗
  29. Hamacher, Werner . 2002. “‘Jetzt’: Benjamin zur Historischen Zeit.” In Benjamin Studies 1: Perception and Exp…
     ↗
  30. Hansen, Miriam Bratu . 2004. “Room-for-Play: Benjamin's Gamble with the Cinema: The Martin Walsh Memorial Lec…
     ↗
  31. Hanssen, Beatrice . 2000. Walter Benjamin's Other History: Of Stones, Animals, Human Beings, and Angels. Berk…
  32. Haverkamp, Anselm . 1992. “Notes on the Dialectical Image: How Deconstructive Is It?”Diacritics22 (3): 69–80.
     ↗
  33. Helmling, Steven . 2003. “Constellation and Critique: Adorno's Constellation, Benjamin's Dialectical Image.”P…
     ↗
  34. Jameson, Fredric . 1971. Marxism and Form: Twentieth-Century Dialectical Theories of Literature. Princeton, N…
  35. Jameson, Fredric . 1982. The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act. Ithaca, NY: Cornell…
  36. Jameson, Fredric . 1990. Late Marxism: Adorno; or, The Persistence of the Dialectic. London: Verso.
  37. Jameson, Fredric . 1999. “The Theoretical Hesitation: Benjamin's Sociological Predecessor.”Critical Inquiry25…
     ↗
  38. Jay, Martin . 1996. The Dialectical Imagination: A History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute of Socia…
  39. Kaufman, Robert . 2001. “Negatively Capable Dialectics: Keats, Vendler, Adorno, and the Theory of the Avant-G…
     ↗
  40. Kaufman, Robert . 2008. “Lyric Commodity Critique, Benjamin Adorno Marx, Baudelaire Baudelaire Baudelaire.”PM…
     ↗
  41. Kaufmann, David . 2001. “Beyond Use, Within Reason: Adorno, Benjamin and the Question of Theology.”New German…
     ↗
  42. Kiloh, Kathy . 2007. “The Linguistic Image: Mediation and Immediacy in Adorno and Benjamin.” In Adorno and th…
     ↗
  43. Kittsteiner, H. D. , Jonathan Monroe, and Irving Wohlfarth. 1986. “Walter Benjamin's Historicism.”New German …
     ↗
  44. Koch, Erec R. 1997. Pascal and Rhetoric: Figural and Persuasive Language in the “Scientific Treatises,” the “…
  45. Lehman, Robert S. 2008. “Allegories of Rending: Killing Time with Walter Benjamin.”New Literary History39 (2)…
     ↗
  46. Martin, Stewart . 2006. “Adorno's Conception of the Form of Philosophy.”Diacritics36 (1): 48–62.
     ↗
  47. Merlin-Kajman, Hélène . 2010. “Benjamin, the Baroque and the Peculiar Historicity of Literature.”Paper presen…
  48. Mitchell, W. J. T. 1984. “What Is an Image?”New Literary History15 (3): 503–37.
     ↗
  49. Nealon, Jeffrey T. 2000. “Maxima Immoralia? Speed and Slowness in Adorno's Minima Moralia.”Theory and Event4 …
  50. Nicholsen, Shierry Weber . 1997. “Aesthetic Theory's Mimesis of Walter Benjamin.” In The Semblance of Subject…
     ↗
  51. Osborne, Peter . 1992. “A Marxism for the Postmodern? Jameson's Adorno.”New German Critique56: 171–92.
     ↗
  52. Osborne, Peter . 1994. “Small-scale Victories, Large-scale Defeats: Walter Benjamin's Politics of Time.” In W…
  53. Pensky, Max . 2004. “Method and Time: Benjamin's Dialectical Images.” In The Cambridge Companion to Walter Be…
     ↗
  54. Rabaté, Jean-Michel . 2002. The Future of Theory. Oxford, UK: Wiley-Blackwell.
     ↗
  55. Richter, Gerhard . 2006. “Aesthetic Theory and Nonpropositional Truth Content in Adorno.”New German Critique3…
     ↗
  56. Richter, Gerhard . 2007. Thought-Images: Frankfurt School Writers' Reflections from Damaged Life. Stanford, C…
     ↗
  57. Rose, Gillian . 1978. The Melancholy Science: An Introduction to the Thought of Theodor W. Adorno. London: Ma…
  58. Salzani, Carlo . 2009.Constellations of Reading: Walter Benjamin in Figures of Actuality. Bern: Peter Lang.
  59. Sieburth, Richard . 1988. “Benjamin the Scrivener.”Assemblage6: 7–23.
     ↗
  60. Smith, Gary . 1989. “Thinking Through Benjamin: An Introductory Essay.” In Benjamin: Philosophy, Aesthetics, …
  61. Smith, Gary . 1999. “Dialectics at a Standstill.” In The Arcades Project, by Walter Benjamin, 929–45. Trans. …
  62. Weber, Samuel . 2008. Benjamin's -abilities. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
     ↗
  63. White, Hayden . 1980. “The Value of Narrativity in the Representation of Reality.”Critical Inquiry7 (1): 5–27.
     ↗
  64. Wiggershaus, Rolf . 1995. The Frankfurt School: Its History, Theories, and Political Significance. Cambridge,…
  65. Wolin, Richard . 1982. Walter Benjamin, an Aesthetic of Redemption. New York: Columbia University Press.
  66. Wolin, Richard . 1997. “Benjamin, Adorno, Surrealism.”The Semblance of Subjectivity: Essays in Adorno's Aesth…
     ↗
  67. Zuidervaart, Lambert . 1991. Adorno's Aesthetic Theory: The Redemption of Illusion. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
CrossRef global citation count: 3 View in citation network → Build reading path →