Abstract

AbstractThe Gates Foundation invokes a third way in education reform debate by appealing not to government regulation or market competition but to philanthropic investment as a catalyst for improving educational equity. While the foundation praises this investment as transcending the conventional polarities of debate, I argue that this praise assigns a familiar form of blame toward public education and educators, for it declares philanthropists the only reformers whose commitments to educational civil rights remain uncompromised by political-economic self-interest. In light of this analysis, I qualify the deliberative potential of praise as a rhetoric of education reform.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2020-06-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.23.2.0293
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (152) · 4 in this index

  1. 1. Mark Hlavacik, Assigning Blame: The Rhetoric of Education Reform (Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press, …
  2. 2. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 12.
  3. 3. Andrew Rich, “The War of Ideas: Why Mainstream and Liberal Foundations and the Think Tanks They Support Ar…
  4. 4. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 67; and Holly G. McIntush, “Defining Education: The Rhetorical Enactment of Ide…
  5. 5. Rebecca A Kuehl, "The Rhetorical Presidency and 'Accountability' in Education Reform: Comparing the Presid…
Show all 152 →
  1. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  2. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  3. 7. Asen arrives at a similar conclusion when he argues that “an education market dispenses with deliberation.…
  4. 8. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 66.
  5. 9. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 167.
  6. 10. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 167.
  7. 11. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 169.
  8. 12. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 43.
  9. 13. As Albert Hirschman defines these terms, choice and voice are the primary means of addressing decline in …
  10. 14. Hirschman, The Rhetoric of Reaction (Cambridge, MA: Belknap, 1991), 170.
  11. 15. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 161.
  12. 16. National Commission on Excellence in Education, A Nation at Risk: The Imperative for Educational Reform, …
  13. 17. Kuehl, “The Rhetorical Presidency and ‘Accountability’ in Education Reform,” 340.
  14. 18. Diane Ravitch, Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America’s Public …
  15. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  16. 20. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 60.
  17. 21. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 66.
  18. 22. National Commission on Excellence in Education, A Nation at Risk.
  19. 23. McIntush, “Defining Education,” 435.
  20. 24. National Commission on Excellence in Education, A Nation at Risk.
  21. 25. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 59.
  22. 26. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 67.
  23. 27. Kuehl, “The Rhetorical Presidency and ‘Accountability’ in Education Reform,” 330.
  24. 28. Asen, “Lyndon Baines Johnson and George W. Bush on Education Reform,” 307.
  25. 29. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 48.
  26. 30. The AEI argued that NCLB failed to embrace “a limited, incentive-based, deregulatory policy model that em…
  27. 31. As examples, Steudeman cites former Washington, D.C. School Chancellor Michelle Rhee and Teach for Americ…
  28. 32. Ravitch, Reign of Error, 4.
  29. 33. Anthony Cody, The Educator and the Oligarch: A Teacher Challenges the Gates Foundation (New York: Garn, 2…
  30. 34. Ravitch, Reign of Error, 9.
  31. 35. John F. Witte, The Market Approach to Education (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2000), 175.
  32. 36. Thomas C. Pedroni, Market Movements: African American Involvement in School Voucher Reform (New York: Rou…
  33. 37. Pedroni, Market Movements, 60.
  34. 38. In its uptake of choice advocacy, the foundation only partly engages with the BAEO’s critique that teache…
  35. 39. Gates Notes is presented as Bill Gates’s personal blog, where he describes his favorite books and muses o…
  36. 40. Bill Gates, “Catalytic Philanthropy: Innovating Where Markets Won’t and Governments Can’t,” Gates Notes, …
  37. 41. Gates, “Catalytic Philanthropy.”
  38. 42. Gates, “Catalytic Philanthropy.”
  39. 43. Gates, “Catalytic Philanthropy.”
  40. 44. Wendy Brown, Undoing the Demos: Neoliberalism’s Stealth Revolution (New York: Zone Books, 2015), 137.
  41. 45. For example, Washington Post education reporter Valerie Strauss has asked why the foundation’s initiative…
  42. 46. Education scholars explore how Gates's philanthropic reforms advance a neoliberal model of governance, bu…
  43. and Saltman, "The Rise of Venture Philanthropy and the Ongoing Neoliberal Assault on Public Education: The El…
  44. 47. Rich, “The War of Ideas,” 18.
  45. 48. Peter Frumkin, On Being Nonprofit: A Conceptual and Policy Primer (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Pres…
  46. 49. As Frumkin argues, a demand-side theory of value orients nonprofits toward public needs and assigns value…
  47. 50. Frumkin, Strategic Giving, 375. Likewise, Robert Payton and Michael Moody argue that those who engage in …
  48. 51. Frumkin, Strategic Giving, 40.
  49. 52. Frumkin, On Being Nonprofit, 37. In a similar line of argument, Payton and Moody invoke Tocqueville’s con…
  50. 53. Gates, “Catalytic Philanthropy.”
  51. 54. While Frumkin positions himself as a philanthropic studies scholar, he tends to celebrate rather than cri…
  52. 55. Bradford Vivian, “Neoliberal Epideictic: Rhetorical Form and Commemorative Politics on September 11, 2002…
  53. 56. Vivian, “Neoliberal Epideictic,” 15-16.
  54. 57. Vivian, “Neoliberal Epideictic,” 18.
  55. 58. Vivian, “Neoliberal Epideictic,” 20.
  56. 59. Between 2000 and 2005, for example, the foundation’s grants supported K-12 schools’ computer resources, I…
  57. 60. Bill Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools,” Los Angeles Times, March 1, 2005, https://www.lati…
  58. 61. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  59. 62. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  60. 63. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  61. 64. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  62. 65. George W. Bush, A Charge to Keep (New York: Morrow, 1999), 233.
  63. 66. This reduction of unequal outcomes to teachers’ lack of belief in the capacity of marginalized students r…
  64. 67. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  65. 68. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  66. 69. Gates does not mention that in 2003, his foundation awarded the Kansas City, Missouri school district a f…
  67. 70. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  68. 71. Gates, “What’s Wrong with American High Schools.”
  69. 72. Janet Quint et al., “The Challenge of Scaling Up Educational Reform: Findings and Lessons from First Thin…
  70. 73. Partnership for Children, “Putting First Things First in Kansas City, Kansas Schools.”
  71. 74. Partnership for Children, “Putting First Things First in Kansas City, Kansas Schools.”
  72. 75. Vivian, “Neoliberal Epideictic,” 17.
  73. 76. Bill Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education,” TED Talks, 2009, https://www.ted.com/talks/bill_gates_u…
  74. 77. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  75. 78. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  76. 79. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  77. 80. Education scholars and critics dispute Gates’s claim that the field does not study effective teaching. An…
  78. 81. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  79. 82. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  80. 83. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  81. 84. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  82. 85. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  83. 86. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  84. 87. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  85. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  86. 89. Gates, “Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Education.”
  87. 90. Bill Gates, “Education Reform and KIPP,” Gates Notes, January 21, 2010, https://www.gatesnotes.com/Books/…
  88. 91. Gates, “Education Reform and KIPP.”
  89. 92. Gates, “Education Reform and KIPP.”
  90. 93. Jay Mathews, Work Hard. Be Nice. How Two Inspired Teachers Created the Most Promising Schools in America …
  91. 94. Mathews, Work Hard. Be Nice, 2.
  92. 95. Mathews, Work Hard. Be Nice, 1.
  93. 96. Mathews, Work Hard. Be Nice, 1.
  94. 97. Mathews, Work Hard. Be Nice, 1.
  95. 98. Vivian, “Neoliberal Epideictic,” 20.
  96. 99. Amy Brown, A Good Investment? Philanthropy and the Marketing of Race in an Urban Public School (Minneapol…
  97. 100. Brown, A Good Investment, 82.
  98. 101. Rachel C. Reidner, Writing Neoliberal Values: Rhetorical Connectivities and Globalized Capitalism (New Y…
  99. 102. Reidner, Writing Neoliberal Values, 18.
  100. 103. Reidner, Writing Neoliberal Values, 18.
  101. 104. Brown, A Good Investment, 6.
  102. 105. Russakoff, The Prize, 61.
  103. 106. Russakoff, The Prize, 106.
  104. 107. Russakoff, The Prize, 176.
  105. 108. Tompkins-Stange, Policy Patrons, 131.
  106. 109. Tompkins-Stange, Policy Patrons, 131.
  107. 110. Tompkins-Stange, Policy Patrons, 145.
  108. 111. Tompkins-Stange, Policy Patrons, 10.
  109. 112. Editorial Board, “Gates Foundation Failures Show Philanthropists Shouldn’t Be Setting America’s Public S…
  110. 113. Editorial Board, “Gates Foundation Failures Show Philanthropists Shouldn’t Be Setting America’s Public S…
  111. 114. Bill Gates and Melinda Gates, “Annual Letter 2016: Two Superpowers We Wish We Had,” February 22, 2016, h…
  112. 115. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2016.”
  113. 116. Bill Gates and Melinda Gates, “Annual Letter 2017: Warren Buffett’s Best Investment,” February 14, 2017,…
  114. 117. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  115. 118. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  116. 119. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  117. 120. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  118. 121. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  119. 122. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  120. 123. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  121. 124. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  122. 125. As Gates puts it, “so, it’s going to take brilliant people like you to study these things, get other peo…
  123. 126. The foundation released its final report on MET in 2013. Thomas J. Kane et al., “Have We Identified Effe…
  124. 127. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2017.”
  125. 128. Frumkin, Strategic Giving, 85.
  126. 129. Bill Gates and Melinda Gates, “Annual Letter 2018: The 10 Toughest Questions We Get,” February 13, 2018,…
  127. 130. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  128. 131. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  129. 132. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  130. 133. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  131. 134. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  132. 135. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  133. 136. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  134. 137. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  135. 138. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  136. 139. Gates and Gates, “Annual Letter 2018.”
  137. 140. Vivian, “Neoliberal Epideictic,” 16.
  138. 141. Theodore M. Kerrine, “Mediating Structures: A Paradigm for Public Policy,” Soundings: An Interdisciplina…
  139. 142. Hirschman, The Rhetoric of Reaction, 168.
  140. 143. Hlavacik, Assigning Blame, 170.
  141. 144. Complicating this issue is the nature of the foundation’s praise. Nominally, it is outwardly directed, a…
  142. 145. Tompkins-Stange, Policy Patrons, 54-55.
  143. 146. Tompkins-Stange, Policy Patrons, 55.
  144. 147. Julie Turkewitz and Dana Goldstein, “Denver Teachers’ Strike Puts Performance-Based Pay to the Test,” Ne…
  145. 148. Eliza Shapiro, “New York City Public Schools Should Be Evaluated Based on Diversity, Not Just Tests, Pan…
  146. 149. Kay Bertken and Francine M. Farber, “Hold Charter Schools Accountable,” New York Times, February 26, 201…
  147. 150. Tompkins-Stange, Policy Patrons, 148.