Abstract

AbstractThis article investigates how slavery tours on the former estates of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison negotiate memories of the presidents as historically revered figures and prominent slaveholders. I argue that these tours recirculate benevolent memories of the presidents that work to sanitize the sites’ slave history and venerate the founders’ legacy. My analysis demonstrates that these tours do not just work to recirculate artifacts and narratives that speak to the presidents’ lives, but they revive a republican culture of remembrance from the nineteenth century through which to justify presidential actions and beliefs. In short, I suggest that this rhetorical negotiation helps craft new narratives of historical U.S. slavery and the early presidents’ lives that appear both more credible and less disturbing.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2019-12-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.22.4.0495
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (133) · 6 in this index

  1. 1. Azie Dungey, “Ask a Slave and Get a Real Answer,” Here and Now, National Public Radio, September 6, 2013, …
  2. 2. Amy M. Tyson and Azie Mira Dungey, “‘Ask a Slave’ and Interpreting Race on Public History’s Front Line: In…
  3. 3. Researchers toured 122 Southern plantations and observed that 55 percent of them made no mention of slaver…
  4. 4. The Mount Vernon Ladies’ Association opened Washington’s home to the general public in 1860, and more than…
  5. 5. Edmund S. Morgan, “Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox,” Journal of American History 59 (1972): 5–29.
Show all 133 →
  1. 6. Christine N. Buzinde and Carla Almeida Santos note a growing awareness among the general public regarding …
  2. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  3. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  4. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  5. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  6. 8. Shawn J. Parry-Giles and Trevor Parry-Giles, “Collective Memory, Political Nostalgia, and the Rhetorical P…
  7. 9. In situ is Latin for “in the original place.” See Angus Stevenson, Judy Pearsall, and Patrick Hanks, eds.,…
  8. 10. Lester C. Olson, “Pictorial Representations of British America Resisting Rape: Rhetorical Re-Circulation …
  9. 11. Public memories shape and reflect a group’s “culture of remembrance,” or commemorative norms that guide h…
  10. 12. Barry Schwartz, "The Social Context of Commemoration: A Study in Collective Memory," Social Forces 61 (19…
  11. Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  12. Geoff Eley, "The Past Under Erasure? History, Memory, and the Contemporary," Journal of Contemporary History …
  13. and Paul A. Shackel, "Public Memory and the Search for Power in American Historical Archaeology," American An…
  14. 13. Definition based on Carole Blair, Greg Dickinson, and Brian L. Ott’s note that memories are crafted “in c…
  15. 14. Bradford Vivian, Being Made Strange: Rhetoric Beyond Representation (Albany: SUNY Press, 2004), 153.
  16. 15. Roy Rosenzweig and David Thelen conducted a survey showing that Americans feel most connected to the past…
  17. 16. James E. Young, “The Veneration of Ruins,” Yale Journal of Criticism 6 (1993): 276.
  18. 17. Matthew Reeves, "A Community of Households: Early 19th-Century Enslaved Landscapes at James Madison's Mon…
  19. Diana C. Crader, "Slave Diet at Monticello," American Antiquity 55 (1990): 690-717
  20. Dennis J. Pogue, "The Domestic Architecture of Slavery at George Washington's Mount Vernon," Winterthur Portf…
  21. Patricia Samford, "The Archaeology of African-American Slavery and Material Culture," William and Mary Quarte…
  22. and Jerome S. Handler and Frederick W. Lange, "On Interpreting Slave Status from Archaeological Remains," Afr…
  23. 18. Theresa A. Singleton, “The Archaeology of Slave Life,” in Images of the Recent Past: Readings in Historic…
  24. 19. Steven Hoelscher, “The White-Pillared Past: Landscapes of Memory and Race in the American South,” in Land…
  25. 20. Eichstedt and Small, Representations of Slavery, 108.
  26. 21. Eichstedt and Small, Representations of Slavery, 81.
  27. 22. Derek H. Alderman and Rachel M. Campbell, “Symbolic Excavation and the Artifact Politics of Remembering S…
  28. 23. As Blair, Dickinson, and Ott argue, historic sites are often able to position themselves as “the sites of…
  29. 24. Buzinde and Santos, “Interpreting Slavery Tourism,” 441.
  30. 25. Gordon S. Wood, Revolutionary Characters: What Made the Founders Different (New York: Penguin Press, 2006…
  31. 26. Dagobert D. Runes, ed., The Selected Writings of Benjamin Rush (New York: Philosophical Library, 1947), 52–53.
  32. 27. William Livingston, “Of Patriotism,” in The Independent Reflector Or, Weekly Essays on Sundry Important S…
  33. 28. Peter Kolchin, American Slavery: 1619–1877 (New York: Hill and Wang, 2003), 59.
  34. 29. For example, William Harper, a state senator from South Carolina, asserted that U.S. slavery was a means …
  35. 30. John C. Calhoun, “On the Reception of Abolition Petitions,” February 6, 1837, Reports and Public Letters …
  36. 31. In fact, Dew argued that slaveholding allowed men to “acquire a more exalted benevolence, a greater gener…
  37. 32. David Zarefsky, Lincoln, Douglas, and Slavery: In the Crucible of Public Debate (Chicago, IL: University …
  38. 33. An editorial published in an 1840 issue of the Colored American asserted that black Americans “should ent…
  39. 34. For example, in his 1852 speech, “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?” Douglass speaks to his mostly…
  40. 35. Henry Highland Garnet, “An Address to the Slaves of the United States,” in A Memorial Discourse (Philadel…
  41. 36. Stephen J. Hartnett, Democratic Dissent and the Cultural Fictions of Antebellum America (Urbana: Universi…
  42. 37. Kolchin, American Slavery, 120–25.
  43. 38. Saidiya V. Hartman, Scenes of Subjection: Terror, Slavery, and Self-Making in Nineteenth-Century America(…
  44. 39. Elizabeth Fox-Genovese, Within the Plantation Household: Black and White Women of the Old South (Chapel H…
  45. 40. For example, William Harper told his audience at the Society for the Advancement of Learning of South Car…
  46. 41. Harriet Ann Jacobs, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl, ed. Lydia Maria Child (Boston, 1861), 45.
  47. 42. Fritz Hirschfeld, George Washington and Slavery: A Documentary Portrayal (Columbia: University of Missour…
  48. 43. “Life on the Monticello Plantation,” Slavery at Jefferson’s Monticello: Paradox of Liberty, https://www.m…
  49. 44. Eric Foner, Gateway to Freedom: The Hidden History of America’s Fugitive Slaves (New York: W.W. Norton, 2…
  50. 45. Lucia C. Stanton, “Those Who Labor for My Happiness”: Slavery at Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello (Charlotte…
  51. 46. Kolchin, American Slavery, 133.
  52. 47. John Rhodehamel, The Great Experiment: George Washington and the American Republic (New Haven, CT: Yale U…
  53. 48. Jared Sparks, ed., The Writings of George Washington: Being His Correspondence, Addresses, Messages, and …
  54. 49. Washington’s will was viewed as so radical in his desire for the eventual emancipation of his slaves that…
  55. 50. Sparks, The Writings of George Washington, vol. 1, no. 5, 569.
  56. 51. St. Louis Jefferson Club Association, The Pilgrimage to Monticello: The Home and Tomb of Thomas Jefferson…
  57. 52. Thomas Jefferson, “Notes on the State of Virginia,” The Avalon Project: Documents in Law, History, and Di…
  58. 53. Thomas Jefferson to Clement Caine, September 16, 1811. in The Writings of Thomas Jefferson: 1807–1815, ed…
  59. 54. Samuel Eagle Forman, ed., The Life and Writings of Thomas Jefferson (Indianapolis, IN: Bowen-Merrill Comp…
  60. 55. Jefferson’s inaugural address also exemplified his commitment to republican virtues and “strength of char…
  61. 56. “African Americans,” Montpelier Research and Collections, 2019, http://www.montpelier.org/research-and-co…
  62. 57. James Madison, State of the Union, December 5, 1810, http://archive.org/stream/stateoftheuniona05013gut/s…
  63. 58. Ralph Ketcham, ed., Selected Writings of James Madison (Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing, 2006), 315.
  64. 59. Mason Locke Weems, The Life of George Washington: With Curious Anecdotes, Equally Honorable to Himself, a…
  65. 60. In 1826, Congressman William Johnson commended Jefferson for his “moral greatness” and remembered him as …
  66. 61. Aaron Bancroft, An Essay on the Life of George Washington, Commander in Chief of the American Army, throu…
  67. 62. Brackenridge, “Eulogy on John Adams and Thomas Jefferson,” 171.
  68. 63. Gaillard Hunt, The Life of James Madison (New York: Doubleday, Page and Co., 1902), 76.
  69. 64. 64. Brackenridge, “Eulogy on John Adams and Thomas Jefferson,” 177.
  70. 65. The Hon. William Rives, “Prefatory Note,” in The Papers of James Madison (Mobile, AL: Allston Mygatt, 184…
  71. 66. “Mission Statement,” Monticello, 2019, http://www.monticello.org/site/about/mission-statement.
  72. 67. “Our Mission,” Mount Vernon, 2019, http://www.mountvernon.org/about/our-mission.
  73. 68. “The Montpelier Foundation Board of Directors,” James Madison’s Montpelier, 2019, http://www.david rubens…
  74. 69. “Field Slave Quarters Excavation Begins,” James Madison’s Montpelier, 2019, http://www.montpelier.org/blo…
  75. 70. Buzinde and Santos note that “the authority and meaning of heritage sites” is dependent on visitors’ own …
  76. 71. Cornelius Holtorf, Archaeology Is a Brand! The Meaning of Archaeology in Contemporary Popular Culture (Ox…
  77. 72. Roslynn D. Haynes, From Faust to Strangelove: Representations of the Scientist in Western Literature (Bal…
  78. 73. Mount Vernon Docent, “Slave Life Tour” (Mount Vernon, VA, September 28, 2014).
  79. 74. Tourists visit historic sites with the expectation that they will be able to depart from their everyday l…
  80. 75. Edward S. Casey, Remembering: A Phenomenological Study (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2009), 178.
  81. 76. One study recently documented ways that tour guides on plantations provide more emotionally evocative acc…
  82. 77. In the Rosenzweig and Thelen study, they found that when tourists encountered historic objects and sites,…
  83. 78. George Washington was frequently depicted in art as both the nation’s Moses and its Christ. For examples,…
  84. 79. For example, Thomas Jefferson viewed his decision to maintain his slaves as evidence of his concern “for …
  85. 80. Thomas Jefferson to Clement Caine, September 16, 1811.
  86. 81. Gordon S. Wood notes that eighteenth-century definitions of character referred to “the outer life, the pu…
  87. 82. Wayne Martin Mellinger, “Representing Blackness in the White Imagination: Images of’Happy Darkeys’ in Pop…
  88. 83. For more information, see “Paul Jennings,” Montpelier Research and Collections, 2019, http://www.montpeli…
  89. 84. Jonathan Mitchell Sewall, Eulogy on the Late General Washington; Pronounced at St. John’s Church in Ports…
  90. 85. Bancroft, The Life of George Washington, 529.
  91. 86. Thomas Thacher, An Eulogy on George Washington, First President of the United States, and Late Commander …
  92. 87. Barbie Zelizer, “Reading the Past against the Grain: The Shape of Memory Studies,” Critical Studies in Ma…
  93. 88. An account of Madison’s decision to sell Billey into servitude is described in a letter to his father. Ja…
  94. 89. Michael Lee Lanning, African Americans in the Revolutionary War (New York: Kensington Publishing Corporat…
  95. 90. Henry Wiencek, An Imperfect God: George Washington, His Slaves, and the Creation of America (New York: Fa…
  96. 91. “Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings: A Brief Account,” Monticello: Plantation and Slavery, 2019, http://w…
  97. 92. A study by John Hope Franklin and Loren Schweninger suggests that “the great majority of [slaves] struggl…
  98. 93. Many early biographers and eulogists praised Washington for his disinterest in leaving agricultural pursu…
  99. and David Ramsay, The Life of George Washington (Baltimore, MD: Joseph Cushing, 1814), 223.
  100. 94. Brackenridge, “Eulogy on John Adams and Thomas Jefferson,” 172.
  101. Advances in the History of Rhetoric
  102. 96. Allison M. Prasch, “Toward a Rhetorical Theory of Deixis,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 102 (2016): 171–72.
  103. 97. Detailed information about the numerous white men and women indentured by Washington can be found here: P…
  104. 98. William Johnson, “Eulogy, Pronounced at Charleston, South Carolina, August 3, 1826,” in A Selection of Eu…
  105. 99. Hunt, The Life of James Madison, 76.
  106. 100. “James Madison, Letter to General La Fayette, February 1, 1830,” in Letters and Other Writings of James …
  107. 101. “Thomas Jefferson to Jean Nicolas Demeunier, Paris, June 22, 1786,” in Thomas Jefferson: A Chronology of…
  108. 102. Jean M. Yarbrough, American Virtues: Thomas Jefferson on the Character of a Free People (Lawrence: Unive…
  109. 103. Hunt, The Life of James Madison, 76.
  110. 104. Castronovo, Fathering the Nation: American Genealogies of Slavery and Freedom, 31. In E. M. Hudson’s 186…
  111. 105. Rationalizing his decision to chronicle Washington’s home life, Weems wrote: “It is not then in the glar…
  112. 106. In 1902, Hunt wrote that of the founders’ “higher qualities slavery did much to develop. It habituated t…
  113. 107. As Timothy Bigelow noted: “Highly honorable would it be to our fellow-citizens in the South, if this mag…
  114. 108. For a more in-depth overview of how Mount Vernon’s enslaved community was divided between the Washington…
  115. 109. “Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included wi…
  116. 110. Tyson and Dungey, “‘Ask a Slave’ and Interpreting Race on Public History’s Front Line,” 49.
  117. 111. “Ask a Slave and Get a Real Answer.”
  118. 112. Allison Landsberg, Prosthetic Memory: The Transformation of American Remembrance in the Age of Mass Cult…
  119. 113. William Palmer, “How Ideology Works: Historians and the Case of British Abolitionism,” Historical Journa…
  120. 114. Morgan, “Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox,” 5–6.
  121. 115. Danielle Allen, Our Declaration: A Reading of the Declaration of Independence in Defense of Equality (Ne…
  122. 116. Colonists and early Americans often highlighted their moral superiority to the British people as a means…
  123. 117. Parry-Giles and Parry-Giles, “Collective Memory, Political Nostalgia, and the Rhetorical Presidency,” 417-37.
  124. 118. John Bodnar draws a helpful (though blurry) distinction between official and vernacular memories: “Publi…
  125. 119. Martell Teasley and David Ikard, “Barack Obama and the Politics of Race: The Myth of Postracism in Ameri…
  126. 120. “Full Text: President Donald Trump’s Inauguration Speech,” ABC News, January 20, 2017, http://abcnews.go…
  127. 121. Researchers toured 122 Southern plantations and observed that 55 percent of them made no mention of slav…
  128. 122. Buzinde and Santos, “Interpreting Slavery Tourism,” 440.