Abstract

Abstract Documentary mediums have been called upon to refute denials of mass suffering throughout the twentieth century. This essay argues that refutation is a documentary impulse as definitive as the mission to amplify marginalized voices. Moreover, patterns in refuting denials of harm and moral responsibility indicate shifting conditions of public grievability. Comparing over a dozen documentaries about Prevention through Deterrence—a border control strategy nationalized under the Clinton administration—the analysis shows that migrant fatality maps and forensic lab footage not only document death but also refute commonplace denials of migrant human rights.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2019-12-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.22.4.0615
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Rhetoric & Public Affairs

References (97)

  1. 1. Luis Alberto Urrea, The Devil’s Highway: A True Story (New York: Little Brown, 2004), 32.
  2. 2. Manny Fernandez, “A Path to America, Marked by More and More Bodies,” New York Times, May 4, 2017, sec. U.…
  3. 3. U.S. Border Patrol, Border Patrol Strategic Plan: 1994 and Beyond. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Border Patrol, 2…
  4. 4. United States Commission on Civil Rights, “Presentation on the Civil and Human Rights Implications of U.S.…
  5. 5. As documentary filmmaker John Carlos Frey notes in his interview, “In 2001, if we are talking about the Bu…
Show all 97 →
  1. 6. Rachel Antell, Death on a Friendly Border, 2001; J. Palafox and C. Peek, New World Border (Peek Media, 200…
  2. 7. On dominant news frames, see Leo R. Chavez, The Latino Threat: Constructing Immigrants, Citizens, and the …
  3. 8. Moya Lloyd, ed., Butler and Ethics (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2015).
  4. 9. Taking a materialist approach to precarity, contributors to Precarious Rhetorics examine how populations a…
  5. 10. Judith Butler, Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence (London: Verso, 2006); and Judith But…
  6. 11. Butler, Frames of War, 52.
  7. 12. I use “data” here cautiously given its potential to dehumanize. However, the “data” gap between medical e…
  8. 13. Ferenc M. Szasz and Ralph H. Bogardus, "The Camera and the American Social Conscience: The Documentary Ph…
  9. Bonnie J. Dow, "Fixing Feminism: Women's Liberation and the Rhetoric of Television Documentary," Quarterly Jo…
  10. Rae Lynn Schwartz-DuPre, "Rhetorically Representing Public Policy," Feminist Media Studies 7 (2007): 433-53
  11. and Thomas Rosteck and Thomas S. Frentz, "Myth and Multiple Readings in Environmental Rhetoric: The Case of A…
  12. 14. Dow, “Fixing Feminism,” 55.
  13. 15. Bill Nichols, Introduction to Documentary, 2nd ed. (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2010), 86.
  14. 16. Dow, “Fixing Feminism,” 59.
  15. 17. Rosteck and Frentz, “Myth and Multiple Readings in Environmental Rhetoric,” 11–12.
  16. 18. Esteban Loustaunau and Lauren E. Shaw, Telling Migrant Stories: Latin American Diaspora in Documentary Fi…
  17. 19. Pooja Rangan, Immediations: The Humanitarian Impulse in Documentary (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press,…
  18. 20. Rebecca M. Schreiber, The Undocumented Everyday: Migrant Lives and the Politics of Visibility (Minneapoli…
  19. 21. Institutional review board approval was awarded on March 26, 2018. Documentation is available on request.…
  20. 22. Butler, Frames of War, 52.
  21. 23. Butler, Precarious Life, 147.
  22. 24. Butler, Frames of War; Stec, “Bringing Attention to the Human Costs of War”; Palmer-Mehta, “A ‘Suitably D…
  23. 25. Stec, “Bringing Attention to the Human Costs of War”; and Rood, “Our Tears Are Not Enough.”
  24. 26. Butler, Precarious Life, 146.
  25. 27. Butler, Precarious Life, 146.
  26. 28. Butler, Frames of War, 51.
  27. 29. Stanley Cohen, States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2001).
  28. 30. Cohen, States of Denial, 8.
  29. 31. Cohen, States of Denial, 59.
  30. 32. Cohen, States of Denial, 105.
  31. 33. Robin Reineke, phone conversation, May 2, 2018.
  32. 34. Cohen, States of Denial, 11.
  33. 35. Butler, Frames of War, 73.
  34. 36. J. Brian Harley, “Maps, Knowledge, and Power,” in The Iconography of Landscape: Essays on the Symbolic Re…
  35. 37. Humane Borders, “Arizona OpenGIS for Deceased Migrants,” 2019, http://humaneborders.info/.
  36. 38. “Mexican Map Shows Perils of Crossing,” Chicago Tribune, January 25, 2006, http://articles.chicagotribune…
  37. 39. On informational images see, James Elkins, The Domain of Images (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 2001).
  38. 40. Antell, Death on a Friendly Border.
  39. 41. "Mapping a Better World," Economist, June 4, 2009, https://www.economist.com/node/13725877
  40. Witness, "Data and Storytelling: Crisis Mapping for Human Rights Solutions," Witness Blog, 2019, https://blog…
  41. and "Geo-Mapping for Human Rights," New Tactics in Human Rights, June 2009, https://www.newtactics.org/geo-ma…
  42. 42. Robert Hariman and John Louis Lucaites, No Caption Needed: Iconic Photographs, Public Culture, and Libera…
  43. 43. Joe Burgess and Haeyoun Park, “Migrant Deaths in Southern Arizona,” New York Times, May 21, 2013, https:/…
  44. 44. Mathew et al., Crossing Arizona.
  45. 45. Frey, The 800 Mile Wall.
  46. 46. Frey, phone conversation, May 2, 2018.
  47. 47. Raquel Rubio-Goldsmith et al., “The ‘Funnel Effect’ and Recovered Bodies of Unauthorized Migrants Process…
  48. 48. Joseph Nevins, “A Matter of Life and Death: Human Rights at the Boundaries of Immigration Control,” in Hi…
  49. 49. This point was first made by Didier Fassin, who wrote of the shifts in character of humanitarian work: “T…
  50. 50. Although not all who investigate the dead identify with the designation, Lathan and O’Daniel note that “f…
  51. 51. International Organization for Migration, Fatal Journeys: Tracking Lives Lost during Migration (Grand-Sac…
  52. 52. The following is a sample of articles that feature quotes from CME Bruce Parks or Gregory Hess: Sylvia Mo…
  53. 53. Reineke describes the accompanying trauma when a bad death occurs in the Human Rights Watch video short, …
  54. Multidisciplinary Perspectives on the Disappeared, ed. Derek Congram (Canada: Canadian Scholar's Press, 2016), 264.
  55. 54. Lisa White, Transitional Justice and Legacies of State Violence (New York: Routledge, 2015), 150.
  56. 55. Latham and O’Daniel, Sociopolitics of Migrant Death and Repatriation, 6, 87–90.
  57. 56. “Not all medical examiner’s offices handle illegal border crosser deaths with the same compassion and ded…
  58. 57. “Dying to Get Back.”
  59. 58. “Dying to Get Back.”
  60. 59. “Dying to Get Back.”
  61. 60. Williams, The Undocumented.
  62. 61. Identification and repatriation have emerged as two key “rights of the dead” in the aftermath of mass fat…
  63. 62. On the rise of humanitarianism at border zones, see William Walters, “Foucault and Frontiers: Notes on th…
  64. 63. “Border Crossing by the Numbers,” Independent Lens (blog), April 26, 2013, http://www.pbs.org/independent…
  65. 64. Reineke and Anderson, “Missing in the US–Mexico Borderlands,” 265.
  66. 65. Reineke and Anderson, “Missing in the US–Mexico Borderlands,” 265.
  67. 66. Anne Teresa Demo, “Animating Death: Stills That Migrate,” in Photography and Migration, ed. Tanya Sheehan…
  68. 67. Frey, The 800 Mile Wall.
  69. 68. See Fernandez, “A Path to America, Marked by More and More Bodies.” In contrast, a USA Today project sugg…
  70. 69. Lilie Chouliaraki, “The Theatricality of Humanitarianism: A Critique of Celebrity Advocacy,” Communicatio…
  71. 70. Williams, The Undocumented.
  72. 71. Williams, The Undocumented.
  73. 72. Williams, The Undocumented.
  74. 73. Reineke, phone interview, May 2, 2018.
  75. 74. A full explication of the ethical problems with Dead in the Desert is beyond the scope of this essay but …
  76. 75. Silver, “Bodies on the Border.”
  77. 76. Although Reineke had been coordinating the program since its inception at the PCOME in 2006, her new role…
  78. 77. Silver, “Bodies on the Border.”
  79. 78. Silver, “Bodies on the Border.”
  80. 79. H2A visas permit foreign nationals to work on a temporary basis in agricultural basis, but the process of…
  81. 80. Silver, Monroe, and Pulse Films, Who Is Dayani Cristal?
  82. 81. Williams, The Undocumented.
  83. 82. Irene Bruna Seu and S. Orgad, “Mediated Humanitarian Knowledge: Audiences’ Reactions and Moral Actions,” …
  84. 83. Orgad and Nikunen, “The Humanitarian Makeover,” 243.
  85. 84. One example of that flux was the March 2018 revision to the mission of the U.S. Citizenship and Immigrati…
  86. 85. Frey, phone conversation, May 2, 2018.
  87. 86. Reineke, phone conversation, May 2, 2018.
  88. 87. Cohen, States of Denial; and Irene Bruna Seu, “‘Doing Denial’: Audience Reaction to Human Rights Appeals,…
  89. 88. Humane Borders, “Arizona OpenGIS for Deceased Migrants.”
  90. 89. In 2015, The United Nations marked the 25th anniversary of the treaty with efforts to secure additional r…
  91. 90. "Migrant Deaths Remain High Despite Sharp Fall in US-Mexico Border Crossings in 2017," International Orga…
  92. and Amanda Holpuch, "Migrant Deaths at US-Mexico Border Increase 17 Percent This Year, UN Figures Show," Guar…