Abstract

AbstractIn March 1703, hundreds of New England sailors returned home after years of slavery in the Barbary States. In response, Cotton Mather authored and circulated a sermon titled The Glory of Goodness. This text, ostensibly given in celebration of the captives’ return, gave voice to an exceptionalist understanding of Puritan identity premised on foreign—notably Muslim—others. It therefore informs our understanding of early eighteenth-century colonial depictions of Islam, while bearing insight for discourses surrounding Puritan exceptionalism, the rhetorical construction of race, and the articulation of religious identity in New England following the Glorious Revolution.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2018-12-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.21.4.0571
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (139)

  1. 1. Babette M. Levy, Cotton Mather (Boston, MA: Twayne Publishers, 1979), 20
  2. see also Cotton Mather, The Diary of Cotton Mather (New York: Frederick Ungar Publishing Co., 1957), 448-54.
  3. 2. Mather, Diary, 473.
  4. 3. Jason Gilmore, “Translating American Exceptionalism: Comparing Presidential Discourse About the United Sta…
  5. 4. See Richard L. Bushman, From Puritan to Yankee: Character and the Social Order in Connecticut, 1690-1765 (…
Show all 139 →
  1. and Allan C. Carlson, Family Cycles: Strength, Decline, and Renewal in American Domestic Life, 1630-2000 (New…
  2. 5. Such dissenters as Baptists, Anglicans, and Quakers were free to worship as they pleased with the new reli…
  3. 6. Francis J. Bremer, The Puritan Experiment: New England Society from Bradford to Edwards (Hanover, N.H.: Un…
  4. 7. Perry Miller originally designated this phrase from Samuel Danforth's 1670 sermon "A Brief Recognition of …
  5. and Arne Delfs, "Anxieties of Influence: Perry Miller and Sacvan Bercovitch," New England Quarterly 70 (1997)…
  6. 8. Stout, The New England Soul, 149.
  7. 9. That we have record of. However, there are several reasons to doubt that a large corpus of Puritan sermons…
  8. 10. Amir Hussain, Muslims and the Making of America (Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2016), 1.
  9. 11. This essay complements existing communication scholarship on the rhetorical uses of Islam in political di…
  10. Michael J. Lee, "Us, Them, and the War on Terror: Reassessing George W. Bush's Rhetorical Legacy," Communicat…
  11. Khalid Sultan, "Linking Islam with Terrorism: A Review of the Media Framing since 9/11," Global Media Journal…
  12. Jonathan J. Edwards, "Figuring Radicalization: Congressional Narratives of Homeland Security and American Mus…
  13. Aziz Douai and Sharon Lauricella, "The 'Terrorism' Frame in 'Neo-Orientalism': Western News and the Sunni-Shi…
  14. Melina Trevino, Ali M. Kanso, and Richard Alan Nelson, "Islam through Editorial Lenses: How American Elite Ne…
  15. Kimberly A. Powell, "Framing Islam: An Analysis of U.S. Media Coverage of Terrorism since 9/11," Communicatio…
  16. Ibrahim Seaga Shaw, "Stereotypical Representations of Muslims and Islam Following the 7/7 London Terror Attac…
  17. Laya Matindoost, "Media Representation of Muslim Youth in Australia," Media Development 62 (2015): 33-36
  18. Mark Featherstone, Siobhan Holohan, and Elizabeth Poole, "Discourses of the War on Terror: Constructions of t…
  19. Henri C. Nickels, Lyn Thomas, Mary J. Hickman, and Sara Silvestri, "Constructing 'Suspect' Communities and Br…
  20. and Rane Halim and Abdi Hersi, "Meanings of Integration in the Australian Press Coverage of Muslims: Implicat…
  21. 12. I use constitute here as Maurice Charland used the term—as the rhetorical means by which “those in Athens…
  22. 13. Emory Elliott, Power and the Pulpit in Puritan New England (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, …
  23. 14. Andreea Mingiuc, “Key Concepts of Puritanism and the Shaping of the American Cultural Identity,” Philolog…
  24. 15. John Winthrop, “A Model of Christian Charity,” 1630. Taken from Hanover Historical Texts Collection, http…
  25. 16. Stephen Howard Browne, “Errand into Mercy: Rhetoric, Identity, and Community in John Winthrop’s ‘Modell o…
  26. 17. Katrine Dalsgård, “The One All-Black Town Worth the Pain: (African) American Exceptionalism, Historical N…
  27. 18. Eugene E. White, Puritan Rhetoric: The Issue of Emotion in Religion (Carbondale: Southern Illinois Univer…
  28. 19. See Charles E. Hambrick-Stowe, The Practice of Piety: Puritan Devotional Disciplines in Seventeenth-Centu…
  29. 20. In fact, Stout, writing in 1986, argued that the New England sermon’s “topical range and social influence…
  30. 21. Nathaniel Eells, The Ministers of Gods Word (Boston, MA, 1725), 8–16. Also quoted by Stout, New England S…
  31. 22. After all, the original colonists did migrate for the explicit purpose of building a new society free fro…
  32. 23. Robert G. Pope, The Half-Way Covenant: Church Membership in Puritan New England (Princeton, N.J.: Princet…
  33. 24. Increase Mather, The Latter Sign (Boston, MA, 1682), 26.
  34. 25. Benjamin Wadsworth, King William Lamented in America (Boston, MA: Green and Allen, 1702), 9.
  35. 26. Benjamin Colman, Faith Victorious (Boston, MA: Green and Allen, 1702), 35–36.
  36. 27. Cotton Mather, American Tears upon the Ruines of the Greek Churches, in Europe and Asia (Boston, MA: Gree…
  37. 28. Thomas Shepard, Wine for Gospel Wantons (Cambridge, MA, 1668), 9.
  38. 29. Walter Cradock, Mount Sion, or, The Priviledge and Practice of the Saints Opened and Applied (Cambridge, …
  39. 30. Ann Kibbey, The Interpretation of Material Shapes in Puritanism: A Study of Rhetoric, Prejudice, and Viol…
  40. 31. A few depictions were more neutral, however. One account published in 1700 valorized the faith of a Purit…
  41. 32. Cotton Mather, Work upon the Ark (Boston, MA: Samuel Green, 1689), 52.
  42. 33. As William Henry Erklauer Jr. shows, this kind of analogical reasoning was central to many pastors’ conce…
  43. 34. John Davenport, Another Essay (Cambridge, MA: Samuel Green and Marmaduke Johnson, 1663), 8.
  44. 35. Samuel Nowell, Abraham in Arms (Boston, MA: John Foster, 1678), 13.
  45. 36. Cotton Mather, The Wonderful Works of God (Boston, MA: Samuel Green, 1690), 39.
  46. 37. Roger Williams, G. Fox Digg’d Out of His Burrowes, or, An Offer of Disputation (Boston, MA: John Foster, …
  47. 38. Increase Mather, Two Plain and Practical Discourses Concerning Hardness of Heart. Shewing, That some, who…
  48. 39. Cotton Mather, Decennium Luctuosum (Boston, MA: Allen, 1698), 28.
  49. 40. Cotton Mather, A Letter Concerning (Boston, MA, 1701).
  50. 41. Increase Mather, The Divine Right of Infant-Baptisme Asserted and Proved from Scripture and Antiquity (Bo…
  51. 42. Increase Mather, The Duty of Parents to Pray for their Children (Boston, MA: Green and Allen, 1703), 24–25.
  52. 43. Sylvia Söderlind, "Introduction: The Shining of America," in American Exceptionalisms: From Winthrop to W…
  53. From its First Planting, in the Year 1620, Unto the Year of our Lord 1698 (Hartford, CT: Silas Andrus and Son…
  54. 44. See Everett H. Emerson, "John Udall and the Puritan Sermon," Quarterly Journal of Speech 44 (1958): 282-84
  55. and Howard H. Martin, "Puritan Preachers on Preaching: Notes on American Colonial Rhetoric," Quarterly Journa…
  56. 45. See Walter Lazenby, "Exhortation as Exorcism: Cotton Mather's Sermons to Murderers," Quarterly Journal of…
  57. Eugene E. White, "Cotton Mather's Manductio ad Ministerium," Quarterly Journal of Speech 49 (1963): 309
  58. Ronald F. Reid. "Puritan Rhetoric and America's Civil Religion: A Study of Three Special Occasion Sermons," i…
  59. 46. I will be using the text of Mather’s sermon made available from the University of Michigan’s Evans Early …
  60. 47. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 26.
  61. 48. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 24–30.
  62. 49. Theon E. Hill, “(Re)Articulating Difference: Constitutive Rhetoric, Christian Identity, and Discourses of…
  63. 50. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 30.
  64. 51. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 1. As Perry Miller put it, “The Matherian party, to be sure, did not aband…
  65. 52. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 7.
  66. 53. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 7–8.
  67. 54. Richard Ruland and Malcolm Bradbury, From Puritanism to Postmodernism: A History of American Literature (…
  68. 55. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 17.
  69. 56. Mather, Diary, 473. As Perry Miller put it, “But in Puritanism there was also another side, an ideal of s…
  70. 57. Jason Gilmore and Charles M. Rowling, “The United States in Decline? Assessing the Impact of Internationa…
  71. 58. Michael P. Winship, Godly Republicanism: Puritans, Pilgrims, and a City on a Hill (Cambridge, MA: Harvard…
  72. 59. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 30–31.
  73. 60. John Cotton, “Swine and Goats,” quoted by Richard J. Ellis in American Political Cultures (New York: Oxfo…
  74. 61. See Robert L. Ivie, "Fighting Terror by Rite of Redemption and Reconciliation," Rhetoric & Public Affairs…
  75. Jeremy Engels, Enemyship: Democracy and Counter-Revolution in the Early Republic (East Lansing: Michigan Stat…
  76. Jason C. Flanagan, "Woodrow Wilson's 'Rhetorical Restructuring': The Transformation of the American Self and …
  77. and Kenneth Burke, "The Rhetoric of Hitler's 'Battle'," in The Philosophy of Literary Form: Studies in Symbol…
  78. 62. Garnet C. Butchart, “The Exceptional Community: On Strangers, Foreigners, and Communication,” Communicati…
  79. 63. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 32.
  80. 64. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 45.
  81. 65. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 31.
  82. 66. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 32–33.
  83. 67. Robert C. Davis, Christian Slaves, Muslim Masters: White Slavery in the Mediterranean, the Barbary Coast,…
  84. 68. Playfair, The Scourge of Christendom, 34.
  85. 69. Paul Michel Baepler, “The Barbary Captivity Narrative in American Culture,” Early American Literature 39 …
  86. 70. Paul Michel Baepler, White Slaves, African Masters: An Anthology of American Barbary Captivity Narratives…
  87. 71. Michael Guasco, Slaves and Englishmen: Human Bondage in the Early Modern Atlantic World (Philadelphia: Un…
  88. 72. Mather, Diary, 321.
  89. 73. Cotton Mather, A pastoral letter to the English captives in Africa. From New-England (Boston, MA: Green a…
  90. 74. Cotton Mather, A pastoral letter, 9–10.
  91. 75. For a discussion of this rhetorical maneuver, see Leff and Utley’s description of the “double synecdoche”…
  92. 76. Mather, A pastoral letter, 14.
  93. 77. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 39–41.
  94. 78. In his letter Things for a distress’d People to think upon, Mather describes the Catholic Church as “the …
  95. 79. See White, Puritan Rhetoric, 29–33.
  96. 80. Michael P. Winship, Making Heretics: Militant Protestantism and Free Grace in Massachusetts, 1636–1641 (P…
  97. 81. Edward Said, Orientalism (New York: Pantheon Books, 1978), 298.
  98. 82. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 44.
  99. 83. Robert L. Ivie, “Images of Savagery in American Justifications for War,” Communication Monographs 47 (198…
  100. 84. Aaron Kuecker, The Spirit and the “Other”: Social Identity, Ethnicity and Intergroup Reconciliation in Lu…
  101. 85. Jeff Motter, “American Exceptionalism and the Rhetoric of Humanitarian Militarism: The Case of the 2004 I…
  102. 86. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 45.
  103. 87. See Clissold, The Barbary Slaves, 130; Guasco, Slaves and Englishmen, 145; Colley, “Britain and Islam, 16…
  104. 88. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 38.
  105. 89. Baepler, White Slaves, African Masters, 14.
  106. 90. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 50.
  107. 91. Denise M. Bostdorff, “George W. Bush’s Post-September 11 Rhetoric of Covenant Renewal: Upholding the Fait…
  108. 92. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 49.
  109. 93. Bostdorff, “George W. Bush’s Post-September 11 Rhetoric,” 296.
  110. 94. Gary L. Ebersole, Captured by Texts: Puritan to Postmodern Images of Indian Captivity (Charlottesville: U…
  111. 95. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 34.
  112. 96. Mather, The Glory of Goodness, 39.
  113. 97. David Spurr, The Rhetoric of Empire: Colonial Discourse in Journalism, Travel Writing, and Imperial Admin…
  114. 98. This argument anticipated the traditional rationales for Western imperialism, especially with regard to s…
  115. 99. Francis Fukuyama discusses the challenges facing a “deterritorialized” Islam in the twenty-first century …
  116. 100. Of course, Mather’s resolution is imperfect, because the captives ultimately required a return to New En…
  117. 101. Abram Van Engen, Sympathetic Puritans (New York: Oxford University Press, 2015), 3.
  118. 102. Romans 12:15, English Standard Version.
  119. 103. Van Engen, Sympathetic Puritans, 4.
  120. 104. Jon Pahl, Empire of Sacrifice: The Religious Origins of American Violence (New York: New York University…
  121. 105. Richard A. Bailey, Race and Redemption in Puritan New England (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011), 116.
  122. 106. Sacvan Bercovitch, The American Jeremiad (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1978), 7.
  123. 107. Edward W. Said, Culture and Imperialism (New York: Vintage Books, 1993), 53.
  124. 108. Sylviane A. Diouf, Servants of Allah: African Muslims Enslaved in the Americas, 15th anniversary ed. (Ne…
  125. 109. “Islam in America,” Public Broadcasting Service, 2014, http://www.pbs.org/opb/historydetectives/feature/…
  126. 110. Yvonne Yazbeck Haddad, Not Quite American? The Shaping of Arab and Muslim Identity in the United States …
  127. 111. “Blackamoor” is a derogatory term referring to dark-skinned North Africans and is comparable to the wors…
  128. 112. It was the first American colony to do so. Lorenzo Greene, The Negro in Colonial New England 1620–1776 (…
  129. 113. Peter Mackinlay, “The New England Puritan Attitude toward Black Slavery,” Old-Time New England 63 (1973): 83.
  130. 114. Quoted in Baepler, White Slaves, African Masters, 8. For context on the political exchange surrounding t…
  131. 115. Quoted in Baepler, White Slaves, African Masters, 30. For a brief overview on John Jay’s attitudes towar…
  132. 116. Samuel Sewall, The Selling of Joseph: A Memorial (1700), 3.
  133. 117. It is worth noting that Mather departed from the views espoused by many of his contemporaries like Isaac…
  134. 118. Jared Hickman, “The Theology of Democracy,” New England Quarterly 81 (2008): 177.