Rhetoric & Public Affairs Sep 2013

Fundamentalist Fool or Populist Paragon? William Jennings Bryan and the Campaign against Evolutionary Theory

Kristy Maddux

Abstract

Abstract This essay revisits William Jennings Bryan's campaign against evolutionary theory through analysis of four rhetorical moments—his platform orations “The Prince of Peace” (beginning in 1904) and “The Menace of Darwinism” (beginning in 1921), his testimony at the Scopes Trial, and his undelivered closing speech, “On Evolution.” In contrast to popular memory of Bryan as the fundamentalist fool, I maintain that he shared little rhetorical ground with his fundamentalist contemporaries, who tended to make arguments that used scientific reasoning to prove empirical facts of religious truth. Instead, Bryan opposed evolution through what Michael Lee has called the “populist argumentative frame,” a rhetorical orientation devoted to guarding the interests of the common people against an oppressive elite. Recognizing the populist foundations to Bryan's anti-evolution discourse, as well as the absence of fundamentalism in his discourse, helps to explain how Bryan fared so badly on the stand at the Scopes Trial.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2013-09-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.16.3.0489
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism discourse analysis
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (133)

  1. (1971)
    The World's Most Famous Court Trial: State of Tennessee v. John Thomas Scopes
  2. (1925)
    “Big Crowd,”
  3. (1925)
    “Dramatic Scenes in Trial,”
  4. “Big Crowd”; Hyde, “Bryan on Stand,”
  5. (1925)
    “Bryan Grilled By Darrow, Defends Bible as All True,”
Show all 133 →
  1. (1987)
    “William Jennings Bryan's Last Campaign,”
  2. (1991)
    William Jennings Bryan: Orator of Small-Town America
  3. (1988)
    Eloquence in an Electronic Age
  4. (2002)
    “William Jennings Bryan: Boy Orator, Broken Man, and the ‘Evolution’ of America's Public …
    Great Plains Quarterly
  5. (2006)
    A Godly Hero: The Life of William Jennings Bryan
  6. Defender of the Faith
  7. (1943)
    “William Jennings Bryan,”
  8. Defender of the Faith
  9. (1969)
    William Jennings Bryan: III. Political Puritan, 1915–1925
  10. I maintain that these two argumentative frames were discordant or dissonant. They operate…
  11. “Bryan's Last Campaign,”
  12. William Jennings Bryan
  13. “Bryan: Boy Orator,”
  14. “William Jennings Bryan as Demosthenes,”
  15. “Bryan's Last Campaign,”
  16. Defender of the Faith
  17. “Bryan: Boy Orator,”
  18. (1997)
    “Bryan: Boy Orator,”
  19. “William Jennings Bryan as Demosthenes,”
  20. “William Jennings Bryan as Demosthenes,”
  21. (1990)
    Under God: Religion and American Politics
  22. (2006)
    “The Populist Chameleon: The People's Party, Huey Long, George Wallace, and the Populist …
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
  23. “The Populist Chameleon,”
  24. (1995)
    The Populist Persuasion: An American History
  25. “The Populist Chameleon,”
  26. “The Populist Chameleon,”
  27. Populist Persuasion
  28. (2007)
    The Populist Vision
  29. Populist Persuasion
  30. (1978)
    The Populist Moment: A Short History of the Agrarian Revolt in America
  31. The Populist Vision
  32. (2006)
    Righteous Indignation: Religion and the Populist Revolution
  33. “William Jennings Bryan,”
  34. (2001)
    “Bryan's ‘A Cross of Gold’: The Rhetoric of Polarization at the 1896 Democratic Convention,”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
  35. (1967)
    “Bryan versus ‘Bosses’ at Baltimore,”
    Southern Speech Journal
  36. Throughout this essay, I describe Bryan as a “reformer” to note his commitment to the ref…
  37. A Godly Hero
  38. A Godly Hero
  39. A Godly Hero
  40. “William Jennings Bryan,”
  41. (1919)
    “Tampering with the Main Spring,” WJB Papers, Library of Congress, Box 50, Speech, Articl…
  42. (2006)
    “William Jennings Bryan: Crusader for the Common Man,”
  43. Defender of the Faith
  44. Defender of the Faith
  45. A Godly Hero
  46. “Bryan's ‘A Cross of Gold,’”
  47. (1987)
    William Jennings Bryan: Champion of Democracy
  48. Defender of the Faith
  49. A Godly Hero
  50. Whereas Michael Lee has treated populism as a trans-historical argumentative frame, recur…
  51. (2007)
    In the Beginning: Fundamentalism, the Scopes Trial, and the Making of the Antievolution M…
  52. (1980)
    Fundamentalism and American Culture
  53. Fundamentalism and American Culture
  54. (1986)
    Fundamentalism and American Culture
  55. “Scientific Revolution,”
  56. Fundamentalism and American Culture
  57. (1970)
    The Roots of Fundamentalism: British and American Millenarianism 1800–1930
  58. Fundamentalism and American Culture
  59. In the Beginning
  60. In the Beginning
  61. In the Beginning
  62. In the Beginning
  63. In the Beginning
  64. In the Beginning
  65. (1995)
    “Is Evolution True?,”
  66. “Evolution Versus Creation,”
  67. “Evolution Versus Creation,”
  68. “Evolution Versus Creation,”
  69. “Evolution Versus Creation,”
  70. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  71. (1904)
    “The Prince of Peace,”
  72. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  73. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  74. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  75. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  76. “Prince of Peace,”
  77. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  78. “Bryan, “Prince of Peace,”
  79. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  80. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  81. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  82. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  83. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  84. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  85. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  86. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  87. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  88. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  89. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  90. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  91. “The Prince of Peace,”
  92. “The Prince of Peace,”
  93. “The Prince of Peace,”
  94. “The Prince of Peace,”
  95. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  96. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  97. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  98. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  99. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  100. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  101. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  102. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  103. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  104. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  105. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  106. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  107. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  108. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  109. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  110. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  111. “The Menace of Darwinism,”
  112. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  113. “Text of Bryan's Proposed Address in Scopes Case,”
  114. Under God
  115. World's Most Famous
  116. World's Most Famous
  117. World's Most Famous
  118. World's Most Famous
  119. World's Most Famous
  120. William Jennings Bryan
  121. World's Most Famous
  122. World's Most Famous
  123. “Dramatic Scenes in Trial,”
  124. A Godly Hero
  125. (2011)
    “The Foursquare Gospel of Aimee Semple McPherson,”
    Rhetoric & Public Affairs  ↗
  126. “Scientific Reasoning,”
  127. (1975)
    “The Polemical Mr. Darwin,”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech
  128. A Godly Hero
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Res Rhetorica Apr 2026
    Logos in ancient Greek discourse on rhetoric: An overview ↗
    Arkadiusz Sokolnicki
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  2. Rhetoric of Health and Medicine Apr 2026
    What to Expect When You’re Not Expecting: Pregnancy, Miscarriage, and Constructing Risk at Advanced Maternal Age ↗
    Melissa Carrion
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis
  3. Poroi Feb 2026
    Multi-Methodological, Multiply Ontological: Pivoting Methodologies in Rhetorical Analysis of Medical Aid in Dying (MAiD) ↗
    Paige Welsh; S. Scott Graham
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis
  4. Poroi Feb 2026
    Using Stasis Theory as a Heuristic for Examining Epistemological Dilemmas in a Post-Truth Landscape ↗
    Bruce Bowles
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  5. Written Communication Feb 2026
    Rhetoric and Affect: The Role of Faith in Student Writers’ Wayfinding ↗
    Amy D. Williams; Jonathan Ostenson
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis empirical research affect and writing