Abstract

Abstract This essay addresses China's Nobel Peace Prize-winning and now imprisoned dissident, Liu Xiaobo, and his movement-launching manifesto, Charter 08, as test cases of the fate of democracy in China. By examining how the Chinese Communist Party attacked Liu and how international nongovernmental organizations and political allies rallied to his cause, the essay probes the limits of human rights discourse in an age of globalization, wherein transnational ideals of justice crash into nation states committed to local rather than global forms of governance. Such rhetorical concerns are tempered by China's increasing dominance of global markets, meaning this essay also studies the complicated relationships among local activists, international justice movements, and neoliberal capitalism. The essay therefore maps how China marshals the rhetoric of globalization to enter new markets even as it deploys the rhetoric of nationalism to block foreign influence. Nonetheless, Charter 08's prophetic rhetoric and Liu's heroic charisma have struck a chord internationally, thus opening a new chapter in the movement to call upon globalizing human rights in the name of building democracy in China.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2013-06-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.16.2.0223
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Advances in the History of Rhetoric

References (158) · 1 in this index

  1. “Free Liu Xiaobo,”
  2. “World Awaits Verdict in Liu Xiaobo Trial,”
    PEN American Center
  3. “Chinese Dissident Wins Award,”
  4. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  5. “Europe, an ‘Unimagined’ Frontier of Democracy,”
Show all 158 →
  1. “The Criminal Verdict: Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People's Court Criminal Judgment No. 3901,”
  2. “Humanitarian Space and the Social Imaginary: Médecins Sans Frontières/Doctors Without Bo…
    Journal of Communication Inquiry  
  3. World on Fire: How Exporting Free Market Democracy Breeds Ethnic Hatred and Global Instability
  4. H. Con. Res.
  5. “‘Most Nations’ Oppose Peace Prize to Liu,”
  6. “Transitional Rhetoric of Chinese Communist Party Leaders in the Post-Mao Reform Period: …
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  
  7. “Human Rights and an Ethic of truths: Pragmatic Dilemmas and Discursive Interventions,”
    Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies
  8. Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry
  9. The Last Utopia: Human Rights in History
  10. “A Criticism of the Views of Bourgeois International Law”
  11. “Peace Prize Ignores its Ideals,”
  12. The Chinese Human Rights Reader
  13. “Vienna Conference Statement,”
  14. “Understanding Strategic Distrust: The Chinese Side,”
  15. Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry
  16. “The Moral Vernacular of Human Rights Discourse,”
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  17. “Cultural Relativism and Universal Human Rights,”
    Human Rights Quarterly  
  18. Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry
  19. “Relativism and Religion,”
  20. “Reflections by Nobel Laureates,”
  21. “Standing Amid the Execrations of Time”
    No Enemies, No Hatred
  22. “The Diatribe: Last Resort for Protest,”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  
  23. “Introduction,”
  24. Globalization & Empire: The U.S. Invasion of Iraq, Free Markets, and the Twilight of Democracy
  25. The Cultural Cold War: The CIA and the World of Arts and Letters
  26. Killing Hope: U.S. Military and CIA Interventions since World War II
  27. “Declaration of Human Rights,”
  28. Universal Declaration of Human Rights
  29. “China's Charter 08,”
  30. “The Democracy Wall Movement,”
  31. Charter
  32. Charter
  33. Inventing Human Rights: A History
  34. “China: From Famine to Oslo,”
    New York Review of Books
  35. “Contemporary Chinese Thought and the Question of Modernity,”
    Social Text
  36. Charter
  37. Charter
  38. The Prophetic Tradition and Radical Rhetoric in America
  39. “The Rhetorical Ancestry of the Declaration of Independence,”
    Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  40. “Letter from Beijing,”
    The Nation
  41. “China's West: Generating Change,”
  42. Charter
  43. China: Fragile Superpower
  44. “PEN Renews Calls for Liu Xiaobo's Release,”
  45. Charter
  46. Charter
  47. Courage to Stand Alone
  48. “Stuck in Panic Mode,”
  49. Charter
  50. “Civic Discourse with the International Community: China's Whitepapers on Human Rights,”
  51. “Eleven Year Jail Sentence for Free Speech Activist Liu Xiaobo,”
  52. “The Criminal Verdict,” No Enemies, No Hatred, hits noted on 334–35
  53. “In China, A Grassroots Rebellion,”
  54. “Liu Xiaobo's Trial a Travesty of Justice,”
  55. Courage to Stand Alone
  56. Charter
  57. Global Studies: China
  58. “The Great Himalayan Watershed,”
  59. “The State, Minorities, and Dilemmas of Development in Contemporary China,”
    Fletcher Forum of World Affairs
  60. “Who is Liu Xiaobo?”
  61. “China Will Not be Fooled,”
  62. “Nobel Committee Harbors Political Motives,”
  63. “Diatribe,”
  64. “Bellicose and Thuggish: The Roots of Chinese ‘Patriotism’ at the Dawn of the Twenty-Firs…
  65. “A Voice for the Uyghurs,”
    China Rights Forum
  66. “Memory and Commemoration: The Chinese Search for a Livable Past,”
  67. The Vagrants
  68. Charter 08
  69. “Meet Dr. Freud: Does Psychoanalysis Have a Future in an Authoritarian State?”
  70. China Rights Forum
  71. Unspeakable Truths: Confronting State Terror and Atrocity
  72. Beijing Time
  73. Charter
  74. Tang quoted in Cha, “In China, A Grassroots Rebellion.”
  75. “China: From Famine to Oslo,”
  76. Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party
  77. “Capitalist Development, Entrepreneurial Class, and Democratization in China,”
    Political Science Quarterly
  78. “Yin and Yang Rhetoric and the Impossibility of Constructive Dissent in China,”
    African Yearbook of Rhetoric
  79. “Nation Voices Pride and Outrage,”
  80. “Wife of Nobel Laureate Invites Scores of Chinese Activists to Oslo,”
  81. “Honoring Liu Xiaobo,”
  82. “Cables Reveal Early Tensions Between U.S. and China on Nobel Winner,”
  83. “Eighteen More Countries Refuse to Attend Nobel Peace Prize Ceremony,”
  84. “Freedom in Era of the Empty Chair; Letter from Europe,”
    International Herald Tribune
  85. The Beijing Consensus: How China's Authoritarian Model will Dominate the Twenty-First Century
  86. “Empty Words,”
  87. “China is a Bubble about to Burst,”
  88. “To Change a Regime by Changing Society,”
  89. “Nobel Prize Has Nothing to do with Peace,”
  90. “Beijing Blasts Nobel Peace Prize Meddling,”
  91. “What Can be Inferred from Awarding Nobel Peace Prize to Dalai Lama and Liu Xiaobo?”
  92. “The Role of Rhetorical Topoi in Constructing the Social Fabric of Contemporary China,”
    Civic Discourse, Civil Society, and Chinese Communities
  93. “China Cracks Down on Activists,”
  94. “An Empty Chair, A Deep Divide,”
    Globe and Mail
  95. “Open Letter,”
  96. “Retired Communist Party Leaders Join in a Demand for Press Freedom in China,”
  97. “China & the Nobel,”
  98. “Liu Supporters in Oslo Rally on Eve of Nobel Ceremony,”
  99. “Chinese Are Encouraged to Criticize Government by the Premier,”
  100. “Remarks by Václav Havel and Two Members of China's Charter 08 at the Ceremony for the Ho…
  101. “In China, Echoes of the Crackdown,”
  102. “Remarks by Václav Havel and Two Members of China's Charter 08.”
  103. “A Nobel Peace Prize to Celebrate,” Financial Times, October 9, 2010, 6
  104. “Beijing Strikes at Dissident,”
  105. “We are Willing to Share Responsibility with LiuXiaobo,”
  106. “China: Sham Trial of Veteran Human Rights Activist,”
  107. “Let Them Know the Will of the People Cannot be Cowed,”
  108. Debating Human Rights in China
  109. “Sixty Years: Pervasive Dictatorship Propaganda, Limited Press Freedom,”
  110. Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party
  111. “Atop a Volcano,”
    China Rights Forum
  112. “The Many Aspects of the CPC Dictatorship,”
  113. “On Living with Dignity in China,”
    No Enemies, No Hatred
  114. Rhetoric of the Chinese Cultural Revolution: The Impact on Chinese Thought, Culture, and …
  115. “Further Questions about Child Slavery in China's Kilns,”
    China Rights Forum
  116. Popular Protest & Political Culture in Modern China
  117. “That Holy Word.”
  118. Courage to Stand Alone
  119. Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party
  120. “What Beijing Fears Most,”
  121. Prophetic Tradition
  122. “Letter to Liao Yiwu”
  123. “Harmony in Contemporary New Confucianism and in Socialism with Chinese Characteristics,”
    China Media Research
  124. “Revolution and Us: A Cultural Rendition of Political Movements in Contemporary China,”
  125. “Elite-Based Discourse in Chinese Civil Society,”
  126. “The Ego-Function of the Rhetoric of Protest,”
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  127. “The Internet is God's Present to China,”
  128. “Rhetorical Forms of Symbolic Labor,”
  129. “U.S. Shifts Focus to Press Chinese to Open Markets,”
  130. “Obama and Hu Cite Mutual Aims Amid Trade Deals,”
  131. “President Hu Visits the United States, Jan. 18–Jan. 21, 2011,”
  132. “Press Conference with President Obama and President Hu of the People's Republic of China,”
  133. Human Rights in Chinese Thought
  134. “Man in the News: Ai Weiwei,”
  135. “Romney Talks Tough on China,”
  136. “Reclaiming and Rebuilding the History of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,”
    Third World Quarterly  
  137. “A Constructive Framework for Discussing Confucianism and Human Rights,”
  138. “Epilogue: Human Rights as a Confucian Moral Discourse,”
  139. “Human Rights: A Bill of Worries,”
  140. No Enemies, No Hatred
  141. When China Rules the World
  142. Rights Beyond Borders
  143. Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics
  144. China's Democratic Future
  145. “Finding the Facts about Mao's Victims,”
  146. “Two Revolutions,”
    New Left Review
  147. “Postsocialism? Reflections on ‘Socialism with Chinese Characteristics,’”
  148. The Dictator's Learning Curve: Inside the Global Battle for Democracy
  149. “Finally Free of Tyranny, Terrorism, and the U.S., Now was Supposed to Be Iraq's Moment, …”
  150. “From ‘Ideological Enemies’ to ‘Strategic Partners,’”