Pedagogy Jan 2014

The Composition Classroom and the Political Sex Scandal

Lisa M. Dresner

Abstract

This article details a newspaper-based composition exercise focused on examining coverage of a trio of local political sex scandals. The exercise encouraged first-year composition students to analyze how the rhetorical strategies that the New York Post used in covering these three similar scandals—which involved former New York governor Eliot Spitzer, then-current New York governor David Paterson, and former New Jersey governor Jim McGreevey—differed markedly depending on the Post’s then-relationship to each political figure. In the exercise, students chose several articles at random from a selection of newspaper clippings about these scandals and wrote any interesting headlines, epithets, or descriptions of cartoons they had found on the section of the board dedicated to each governor; students then used the evidence gathered in each section to generate and support thesis statements about the Post’s differing coverage of the three governors’ scandals. This examination through close reading of the Post’s rhetorical strategies in covering parallel sex scandals inspired thoughtful discourse among my composition students, including an increased appreciation of and interest in the news media, an improved understanding of the strategies that scholars use when they gather and interpret textual evidence, and intelligent discussions about the implications of rhetorical strategies utilizing Otherness.

Journal
Pedagogy
Published
2014-01-01
DOI
10.1215/15314200-2348947
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism discourse analysis first-year composition writing pedagogy
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (72) · 2 in this index

  1. Allen (2007)
    Newspapers and Magazines: Using Headlines as Prompts
  2. Alpert (2008)
    Eliot’s Sexual Healing: ‘Addiction’ Therapy
    New York Post
  3. (2007)
    An Abuse of Power?
    New York Post
  4. Associated Press (2008)
    Photo—Flattering photograph of Paterson
    New York Post
  5. (2008)
    Bed Fellow: Lov Guv’s Boy Toy Tells of Threesomes
    New York Post
Show all 72 →
  1. Blatchford (1973)
    Newspapers: Vehicles for Teaching ESOL with a Cultural Focus
    TESOL Quarterly  ↗
  2. (2004)
    Bombshell: ‘My Truth Is I Am a Gay American.’
    New York Post
  3. Bowden (2009)
    The Inheritance
    Vanity Fair
  4. Brown Merrill . 2005. “Abandoning the News.” Carnegie Reporter3.4: 2–11, carnegie.org/fileadmin/Media/Publica…
  5. Brueggeman (1986)
    React First, Analyze Second: Using Editorials to Teach the Writing Process
    Journal of Reading
  6. Christian (2006)
    Get Me Rewrite! Five Years of the Student Newspaper Diversity Project
    Reflections: A Journal of Writing, Service-Learning, and Community Literacy
  7. Cornell (2008)
    State of Disgrace: Feds Take Over Probe
    New York Post
  8. Delonas (2008)
    Cartoon—Paterson’s blindness as excuse for affair: “Sorry, Randy. I thought she was my wife
    New York Post
  9. (2008)
    Cartoon—Spitzer’s offering to serve as Melinda Katz’s sperm donor
    New York Post
  10. Dicker (2007)
    Gov’s Trooper Snoop Job on Bruno: Ordered Police to Track GOP Foe’s Movements
    New York Post
  11. (2008)
    Bruno Hails ‘Truth’ about Tricky Spitz
    New York Post
  12. (2008)
    Doobie Dave Admits Youthful Drug Use
    New York Post
  13. (2008)
    I Knew He Was a Fraud and a Hypocrite from the Day He Swaggered into Capitol
    New York Post
  14. (2008)
    Man of the People Just What NY Needs
    New York Post
  15. ———. 2008e. “Paterson: I’ve Had Several Affairs: One Woman Was a State Employee.” New York Post, web version …
  16. (2009)
    ‘Mediator’ Dave Drawing Hoots
    New York Post
  17. (2009)
    Pooh-Bah Paterson Flouts Law
    New York Post
  18. Dicker (2008)
    State of Affairs: New Gov Dave and Wife Cheated on Each Other
    New York Post
  19. Dicker (2008)
    Be Very Afraid of This Hubby: Stud Gov’s Lover Wed to BIG Shot
    New York Post
  20. (2008)
    Disgrace: And Don’t Let the Door Hit You on the Way Out
    New York Post
  21. Fenner (2008)
    ‘Ho’ Lot of Dirt to Dish
    New York Post
  22. Fenner (2008)
    Godly McGs: ‘Tip of Iceberg’ for McGreeveys [with Felix Bryant photograph—Dina Matos McGr…
    New York Post
  23. Flint (1917-22)
    Newspaper Writing in High Schools, Containing an Outline for the Use of Teachers
  24. Geller (2004)
    N.J. Governor Resigns Over Gay Affair with Aide in $5M Blackmail Flap
    New York Post
  25. Gonen (2013)
    El’s Lame ‘Duck’ on Affair Rumor: He Refuses to Say if He Has a Lover
    New York Post
  26. (2008)
    Good Riddance
    New York Post
  27. (2008)
    Gov Love Letter: GOP Big Outed Eliot to Feds
    New York Post
  28. Greene (2008)
    A Man of the People, a Map of the Future
    New York Post
  29. Haberman (2008)
    Gov Wins Love in Polls, Too
    New York Post
  30. (2008)
    Hot Sheets Gov Puts $$ Back ‘Inn’: Repays 2002 Election Fund for Motel Stays
    New York Post
  31. (2008)
    It’s Her ‘Term’ in Office: ‘Pol’ to Be Single Ma
    New York Post
  32. Harrington (1927)
    The Newspaper Club: A Natural Approach to Composition in the Schools
  33. Jackson Fleda Brown Jackson Dennis . 1986. “The Newspaper in the Composition Classroom.” Teaching Writing: Me…
  34. Johnson (2002)
    ‘Searching for Sentences’ or ‘Headlines Are a Hit.’
    Teaching English in the Two-Year College
  35. Johnson (2008)
    ‘Silda Knew of Hookers.’
    New York Post
  36. Kaiser (1982)
    Composition and Newspapers: Information, Illustration, Stimulation, Evaluation
    Exercise Exchange: A Journal for Teachers of English in High Schools and Colleges
  37. Karni Annie . 2012. “Sliwa’s a Parent and Guardian to Secret Donor Kids with Fmr. City Councilwoman Melinda K…
  38. Lathan (1981)
    Using the Newspaper in the Business Communication Classroom
    ABCA Bulletin  ↗
  39. Long (1988)
    The Newspaper and the Five Skills
  40. Lovett (2008)
    Dave’s Got a Horny of Plenty
    New York Post
  41. Fenner (2008)
    Sexxx-Rated New Gov: Girls! Girls! Girls!: David Bares Dirty Harem
    New York Post
  42. Lovett (2008)
    Paterson’s Excuse Is Simply Inn-Credible
    New York Post
  43. Lukens (1968)
    Using Your Daily Newspaper to Teach Vocabulary and Writing
  44. MacIntosh (2008)
    Hi Ho, Hi Ho, It’s Off to Work We DON’T Go
    New York Post
  45. (2008)
    I Was McG and Wife’s Three-Way Sex Stud: Ex-Driver
    New York Post
  46. (2008)
    McG: It Was 3-Mendous Sex: Admits ‘Menage,’ But Dina Denies It
    New York Post
  47. Miller (1929)
    High-School Reporting and Editing: A Text in Applied Composition and Newspaper Appreciation
  48. Minicz (1985)
    A Bag Full of Newspaper Clippings and Other Tricks of the ESL Trade
    Lifelong Learning
  49. Moore (1989)
    Using the Front Page of the Wall Street Journal to Teach Document Design and Analysis
    ABCA Bulletin
  50. Nestel (2008)
    Illicit Lovers Go Incog-vito: Rendezvous on Run
    New York Post
  51. (2008)
    New Gov and Wife in Sex Shocker
    New York Post
  52. (2008)
    New Hooker Reveals Spitzer’s Kinky Sex Games
    New York Post
  53. Otis (2008)
    Eliot Tipster a GOP ‘Swinger’: Told FBI of Hooker Habit Back in Nov
    New York Post
  54. (2009)
    Paterson’s Plummeting Polls
    New York Post
  55. Rose (2010)
    Opinion: Writing for the Public
    College English
  56. Schram (2008)
    And There He Ho’s Again: ‘Wicked’ Spitzer Linked to Busty Busted Madam’s Biz
    New York Post
  57. Schram (2008)
    Ice Tale Melting: Ranger a Stranger, Madam Says
    New York Post
  58. Scott (2008)
    Studly Dave Says It with 5G Worth of Flowers
    New York Post
  59. Searles (1996)
    Using Newspapers to Teach Plain English
    Teaching English in the Two-Year College
  60. Shuck (1869)
    The California Scrap-book: A Repository of Useful Information and Select Reading, Compris…
  61. Smelcer (1994)
    When Bad Writing Is Good: Using Newspaper Errors in Composition
    Exercise Exchange: A Journal for Teachers of English in High Schools and Colleges
  62. So (2005)
    From Analysis to Pedagogic Applications: Using Newspaper Genres to Write School Genres
    Journal of English for Academic Purposes  ↗
  63. (2006)
    Spitzer for Governor
    New York Post
  64. Stabley (1946)
    Newspaper Editorials and College Composition
    College English
  65. Stadtmiller (2008)
    Whip It! Whip It Good!: Local ‘Doms’ Pack a Punch and a Ball Gag
    New York Post
  66. Virtanen (2008)
    His Disgrace Unmatched in NY’s History
    New York Post
  67. Weiss (2008)
    ‘Two on One’ vs. Spitzer: 2nd Call Girl Dishes Dirt to Feds on Randy Ex-Gov
    New York Post
CrossRef global citation count: 1 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Technical Communication Quarterly Oct 2024
    Editors’ Use of Comprehensive Style Guides: The Case of Singular They ↗
    Jo Mackiewicz; Shaya Kraut; Allison Durazzi
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis first-year composition writing pedagogy graduate education teacher development writing centers technical communication professional writing digital rhetoric multilingual writers grammar and mechanics literacy studies race and writing public rhetoric editorial matter
  2. Writing and Pedagogy Apr 2024
    Designing Writing Across the Professions (WAP) programs at the intersection of work-integrated learning and writing transfer research ↗
    Ina Alexandra Machura; Michael-John DePalma; Michelle J. Eady; Kara Taczak
    rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis first-year composition writing pedagogy transfer
  3. Pedagogy Jan 2024
    The Radical Role of Student Writing in Composition ↗
    Jessica Masterson
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis cultural rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy graduate education teacher development argument collaborative writing professional writing grammar and mechanics literacy studies race and writing gender and writing
  4. Rhetoric Society Quarterly May 2022
    Full Disclosure: Black Rhetoric, Writing Assessment, and Afrocentric Rubrics ↗
    Wonderful Faison
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis african american rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy argument assessment race and writing
  5. Pedagogy Jan 2022
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis african american rhetorics decolonial rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing writing across the curriculum graduate education teacher development argument collaborative writing transfer assessment portfolios writing program administration writing centers peer tutoring technical communication professional writing archival research digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics literacy studies race and writing gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric community literacy literary studies editorial matter