Vernacular Policies of Feeling: Sensuous Presence and the Emergence of an AIDS-Era Sexual Health Ethic

Poroi Dec 2024 OA PDF

Vernacular Policies of Feeling: Sensuous Presence and the Emergence of an AIDS-Era Sexual Health Ethic

Ryan Mitchell

Abstract

Before the isolation of HIV in 1984, members of queer sex communities developed robust explanatory frameworks for not only understanding AIDS but also mitigating its possible sociopolitical consequences. These frameworks retooled political values inherited from past modes of sexual health activism to introduce flexible, future-oriented sexual health policies. This essay considers how AIDS commentators working during the first year-and-a-half of the crisis tailored their speculative arguments about appropriate AIDS-era sexual health ethics in ways that attempted to address the enigmatic epidemic’s intersecting medical, political, and sexual crises. Drawing on work that considers the embodied dimensions of Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca’s concepts of presence and communion, I argue that, in the absence of clear biomedical information about AIDS, early AIDS commentators devised what I call&nbsp;vernacular policies of feeling. Unlike traditional health policies that rely on empirical evidence, vernacular policies of feeling make present communal ways of sensing risks to stabilize biomedical controversy, induce collective action, and affirm community values. Along with demonstrating how the body serves as a rhetorical resource for those made vulnerable to illness and death, vernacular policies of feeling productively illustrate how non-expert communities construct future-oriented arguments in moments of overwhelming contingency.

Journal: Poroi
Published: 2024-12-11
DOI: 10.17077/2151-2957.33774
Open Access: OA PDF Diamond
Topics: multimodality