Advances in the History of Rhetoric Jan 2009

Plenary Rhetoric in Indian Country: TheLone Wolf v. HitchcockCase and the Codification of a Weakened Native Character

Jason Edward Black

Abstract

AbstractThe U.S. Congress passed the General Allotment (Dawes) Act of 1887 as a part of its assimilationist plan to remake American Indians in the image of the U.S. nation. The act helped constitute a changed Native identity as it contracted reservation lines and forced an agricultural economy onto Native reservations. The Supreme Court case Lone Wolf v. Hitchcock (1903) resulted from American Indian protests of the Dawes Act, including the argument that the assimilationist plan had been implemented against Natives' will. The resulting decision granted Congress the ultimate “plenary” power to abrogate treaties without any limits because American Indians were wards. Through an analysis of the case and Indian Commissioner reports addressing plenary power, I argue that the Lone Wolf holding served as an imperial discourse that maligned American Indian identities through a parent-child relationship. This denigration manifested through Lone Wolf's construction of American Indians as cultural wards, its reduction of Native property to commodity through a westernized economic plan, and its assimilation of Native communities into dominant U.S. culture. In addition, I contend that the Lone Wolf case solidified a wider U.S. nationalism by emboldening federal power over indigenous communities through a familial rhetorical strategy.

Journal
Advances in the History of Rhetoric
Published
2009-01-01
DOI
10.1080/15362426.2009.10597380
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism discourse analysis
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (63)

  1. (1902)
    Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs to the Secretary of the Interior for …
  2. Beasley (2004)
    You the People: American National Identity in Presidential Rhetoric
  3. Black (2005)
    “Authoritarian Fatherhood: Andrew Jackson's Early Familial Lectures to America's ‘Red Chi…
    Journal of Family History  ↗
  4. Brown (2000)
    Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee: An Indian History of the American West
  5. Charland (1987)
    “Constitutive Rhetoric: The Case of the Peuple Quebecois.“
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
Show all 63 →
  1. (1831)
    Cherokee Nation v. State of Georgia
  2. Cheyfitz (1993)
    Cultures of United States Imperialism
  3. Clark (1994)
    Lone Wolf v. Hitchcock: Treaty Rights and Indian Law at the End of the Nineteenth Century
  4. Cleveland (1997)
    The Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents
  5. Constitution of the United States of America (2002)
    A Documentary History of the United States
  6. Cook-Lynn (2001)
    Anti-Indianism in Modern America: A Voice from Tatekeya's Earth
  7. DeJong (1993)
    Promises of the Past: A History of Indian Education
  8. Deloria (1988)
    Custer Died for Your Sins: An Indian Manifesto
  9. Estin (1984)
    The Aggressions of Civilization: Federal Indian Policy Since the 1880s
  10. Frickey (1993)
    “Marshalling Past and Present: Colonialism, Constitutionalism, and Interpretation in Fede…
    Harvard Law Review  ↗
  11. Garroutte (2003)
    Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America
     ↗
  12. Horseman (1981)
    Race and Manifest Destiny: The Origins of American Racial Anglo-Saxonism
     ↗
  13. Hoxie (2001)
    A Final Promise: The Campaign to Assimilate the Indians, 1880–1920
  14. Jarding (2004)
    “Tribal-State Relations Involving Land and Resources in the Self-Determination Era.”
    Political Research Quarterly  ↗
  15. Jasinski (1998)
    Doing Rhetorical History: Concepts and Cases
  16. Jehlen (1993)
    Cultures of United States Imperialism
  17. (1823)
    Johnson and Graham v. McIntosh
  18. Kaplan (2002)
    Anarchy of Empire in the Making of U.S. Culture
  19. Langston (2003)
    The Native American World
  20. Leupp (1909)
    “Indian Lands.”
    Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science
  21. (1901)
  22. (1902)
  23. (1903)
  24. Lopez (1996)
    White by Law. Legal Construction of Race
  25. Miller (1999)
    “Indians, Braves and Redskins: A Performance Struggle for Control of an Image.”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
  26. Morris (1997)
    “Educating Savages.”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
  27. Nabokov (1999)
    Native American Testimony: A Chronicle of Indian-White Relations From Prophecy to the Pre…
  28. Olken (2000)
    “Chief Justice John Marshall and the Course of American Constitutional History.”
    John Marshall Law Review
  29. Ono (2001)
    “Deciphering Pocahontas: Unpackaging the Commodification of an American Indian Woman.”
    Critical Studies in Media Communication  ↗
  30. Osborn (2000)
    The Wild Frontier: Atrocities During the American-Indian War from Jamestown Colony to Wou…
  31. Otis (1973)
    The Dawes Act and the Allotment of Indian Lands
  32. Pease (1993)
    Cultures of United States Imperialism
  33. Kappler
    Indian Affairs: Laws and Treaties
  34. Pratt (1892)
    “The Advantages of Mingling Indians with Whites.”
  36. Prucha (1984)
    The Great Father: The United States Government and the American Indians, 2 vol
  37. Prucha (1988)
    The Indians in American Society: From the Revolutionary War to the Present
  38. Washburn (1973)
    The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History—Volume I
  39. Washburn (1973)
    The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History—Volume I
  40. Washburn (1973)
    The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History—Volume I
  41. Washburn (1973)
    The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History—Volume I
  42. Rogin (1975)
    Fathers and Children: Andrew Jackson and The Subjugation of the American Indian
  43. Roosevelt (1904)
    Indian Affairs: Laws and Treaties
  44. Skinner (1973)
    The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History—Volume III
  45. Stephanson (1995)
    Manifest Destiny: American Expansionism and the Empire of Right
  46. Stuckey (2001)
    “By Any Other Name: Rhetorical Colonialism in North America.”
    American Indian Culture and Research Journal  ↗
  47. Takaki (1979)
    Iron Cages: Race and Culture in Nineteenth-Century America
  48. Todorov (1972)
    Conquest of America: The Question of the Other
  49. Treaty of Medicine Lodge (1904)
    Indian Affairs: Treaties and Laws
  50. Turner (1894)
    In Annual Report of the American Historical Association for the Year 1893
  51. Utley (1984)
    The Indian Frontier of the American West, 1846–1890
  52. Wald (2000)
    Cultures of United States Imperialism
  53. Wallace (1993)
    The Long, Bitter Trail: Andrew Jackson and the Indians
  54. Washburn (1973)
    The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History
  55. Weaver (1973)
    The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History, vol. 4
  56. Wildenthal (2003)
    Native American Sovereignty on Trial: A Handbook with Cases, Laws and Documents
  57. Wilkins (1997)
    American Indian Sovereignty and the Supreme Court: The Masking of Justice
     ↗
  58. (1832)
    Worcester v. State of Georgia., 31 U.S. 515. of Georgia
CrossRef global citation count: 2 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Res Rhetorica Apr 2026
    Logos in ancient Greek discourse on rhetoric: An overview ↗
    Arkadiusz Sokolnicki
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  2. Rhetoric of Health and Medicine Apr 2026
    What to Expect When You’re Not Expecting: Pregnancy, Miscarriage, and Constructing Risk at Advanced Maternal Age ↗
    Melissa Carrion
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis
  3. Poroi Feb 2026
    Multi-Methodological, Multiply Ontological: Pivoting Methodologies in Rhetorical Analysis of Medical Aid in Dying (MAiD) ↗
    Paige Welsh; S. Scott Graham
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis
  4. Poroi Feb 2026
    Using Stasis Theory as a Heuristic for Examining Epistemological Dilemmas in a Post-Truth Landscape ↗
    Bruce Bowles
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  5. Written Communication Feb 2026
    Rhetoric and Affect: The Role of Faith in Student Writers’ Wayfinding ↗
    Amy D. Williams; Jonathan Ostenson
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis empirical research affect and writing