Robert E. Knoll, Arther S. Trace, Jr., Eugene E. Slaughter, Donald B. Engley, Ralph M. Williams, Harold B. Allen, Joseph Mersand, Edward A. Stephenson, Albert Merriman, Sheridan Baker, A. L. Soens, R. E. K., Sam Hynes, Ross Garner, Benjamun Boyce, Calhoun Winton, Alan D. McKillop, William Bleifuss, Louis Crompton, Mary A. Reilly, Robert L. Hough, Robert Harwick, Hamlin Hill, Stephen Minot, Samuel French Morse, Philip Young, John Lydenberg, J. E. M., Jr., George Ross Ridge, Bernice Slote, James R. Frakes, Books, College English, Vol. 22, No. 3 (Dec., 1960), pp. 196-217

Morse Peckham, Edward A. Stephenson, Barnett Kottler, Joseph L. Blotner, Harry R. Warfel, William Carlos Williams, Harold B. Allen, Walter B. Rideout, Ralph M. Williams, Richard B. Sewall, Maurice Johnson, David H. Greene, Reginald L. Cook, Thomas P. Harrison, Fred E. Pamp, Jr., Robert C. Roby, Calhoun Wilton, P. M. Zall, Lew Girdler, Books, College English, Vol. 20, No. 1 (Oct., 1958), pp. 49-60

Louis F. Peck, Paul Fussell, Jr., Bruce Dearing, Marshall Waingrow, Robert W. Rogers, Walter H. Ellis, Jr., C. Grant Loomis, Philip A. Shelly, Charles A. Herring, Anne Gwynn, Edward A. Stephenson, William M. Murphy, George S. Wykoff, John C. Coleman, New Books, College English, Vol. 17, No. 7 (Apr., 1956), pp. 419-426