Robert E. Knoll, Arther S. Trace, Jr., Eugene E. Slaughter, Donald B. Engley, Ralph M. Williams, Harold B. Allen, Joseph Mersand, Edward A. Stephenson, Albert Merriman, Sheridan Baker, A. L. Soens, R. E. K., Sam Hynes, Ross Garner, Benjamun Boyce, Calhoun Winton, Alan D. McKillop, William Bleifuss, Louis Crompton, Mary A. Reilly, Robert L. Hough, Robert Harwick, Hamlin Hill, Stephen Minot, Samuel French Morse, Philip Young, John Lydenberg, J. E. M., Jr., George Ross Ridge, Bernice Slote, James R. Frakes, Books, College English, Vol. 22, No. 3 (Dec., 1960), pp. 196-217

A. Lytton Sells, Winifred Lynskey, James S. Constantine, Paul Fussell, Jr., Nathan Comfort Starr, Marvin B. Perry, Jr., Stanley Weintraub, John Lydenberg, Charles Weis, Thomas W. Wilcox, William Frost, Edwin B. Benjamin, Wayne Shumaker, Jerome H. Buckley, J. L. B., Robert B. Martin, Louis D. Rubin, Jr., Jacob Korg, James Benziger, Ralph Waterbury Condee, New Books, College English, Vol. 19, No. 2 (Nov., 1957), pp. 85-92

William W. Main, John Harold Wilson, John Lydenberg, Wylie Sypher, A. Pauline Locklin, Kenneth S. Lynn, Tristram P. Coffin, Charles Child Walcutt, David H. Greene, New Books, College English, Vol. 18, No. 8 (May, 1957), pp. 433-439

Barnet Kottler, A. Pauline Locklin, Edwin B. Benjamin, John Lydenberg, George L. Roth, Wayne Shumaker, Harry Berger, Lionel Stevenson, John C. Coleman, New Books, College English, Vol. 17, No. 6 (Mar., 1956), pp. 368-371