Arguing controversies through civic discourse

Peter Smagorinsky Universidad Univer

Abstract

This article draws on Toulmin’s model of argumentation to propose a way of engaging with controversial topics in ways that require not only the assertion of a point of view, but attentive listening to contrasting beliefs. Given the paucity of models of respectful listening in public discourse, school becomes a place where teachers can provide opportunities for contentious discussions to be conducted through civic discourse. The article begins with an outline of Toulmin’s model, with an emphasis on warranting examples so that they serve as evidence for a claim, and engages with opposing viewpoints for a reasoned rebuttal and synthesis. The article then suggests that the topic of school dress codes would be a fruitful topic of student inquiry and argumentation, given the ideological basis of a dress code and the many differences of opinion surrounding them. Such instruction is illustrated through a method that relies on inductive reasoning and discussion as the basis for generating ideas in argumentative writing. The article concludes with a view of writing pedagogy that promotes responsible argumentation in light of critical responses that lead to a synthesis and extension of learning.

Journal
Writing and Pedagogy
Published
2023-05-04
DOI
10.1558/wap.23638
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (46) · 4 in this index

  1. Allen, W. (Dir.) (1971). Bananas. United Artists.
  2. Applebee, A. N. (1986). Problems in process approaches: Toward a reconceptualization of process instruction. …
  3. Braddock, R., Lloyd-Jones, R. & Schoer, L. (1963). Research in written composition. National Council of Teach…
  4. Crusan, D. & Ruecker, T. (2019). Standardized testing pressures and the temptation of the five-paragraph essa…
  5. Dale, H. (1994). Collaborative writing interactions in one ninth-grade classroom. The Journal of Educational …
Show all 46 →
  1. Downey, M. (2022, August 15). Opinion: Sexist dress codes erode school pledges of equity, excellence. Get Sch…
  2. Written Communication
  3. Fournier-Sylvester, N. (2013). Daring to debate: Strategies for teaching controversial issues in the classroo…
  4. Goodlad, J. I. (1984). A place called school: Prospects for the future. McGraw-Hill.
  5. Haidt, J. (2012). The righteous mind: Why good people are divided by politics and religion. Vintage.
  6. Hillocks, G. (1986). Research on written composition: New directions for teaching. National Conference on Res…
  7. Hillocks, G. (1995). Teaching writing as reflective practice. Teachers College Press.
  8. Hillocks, G. (2002). The testing trap: How state writing assessments control learning. Teachers College Press.
  9. Hillocks, G. (2011). Teaching argument writing, grades 6–12: Supporting claims with relevant evidence and cle…
  10. Johannessen, L. R., Kahn, E. A. & Walter, C. C. (2009). Writing about literature, 2nd ed. National Council of…
  11. Johnson, T. S., Smagorinsky, P., Thompson, L. & Fry, P. G. (2003). Learning to teach the five-paragraph theme…
  12. Kleinfeld, R. (2021). The rise of political violence in the United States. Journal of Democracy, 32(4), 160–1…
  13. Kumar, D. (2022, April 19). DeSantis signs bill limiting tenure at Florida public universities. Tampa Bay Tim…
  14. Labaree, D. (2019). The five-paragraph fetish. Aeon. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/David-Labaree/publi…
  15. Lee, C. D., White, G. & Dong, D. (Eds.). (2021). Executive summary. Educating for civic reasoning and discour…
  16. Lewinski, M. & Mohammed, D. (2016). Argumentation theory. In K. B. Jensen, R. T. Craig, J. D. Pooley, & E. W.…
  17. Argumentation
  18. Macagno, F. (2014). Manipulating emotions: Value-based reasoning and emotive language. Argumentation and Advo…
  19. MacKuen, M., Wolak, J., Keele, L. & Marcus, G. E. (2010). Civic engagements: Resolute partisanship or reflect…
  20. Majors, Y. J. (2015). Shoptalk: Lessons in teaching from an African American hair salon. Teacher’s College Press.
  21. Nossel, S. (2023, February 23). Opinion: Ron DeSantis abandons former First Amendment defense. CNN. https://w…
  22. Nunnally, T. E. (1991). Breaking the five-paragraph-theme barrier. English Journal, 80(1), 67–71. https://doi…
  23. Pendharker, E. (2022, December 27). School dress code debates, explained. Education Week. https://www.edweek.…
  24. Perry, A. (2020, February 5). Dress codes are the new ‘whites only’ signs. The Hechinger Report. https://hech…
  25. Rasmussen, R., Levari, D. E., Akhtar, M., Crittle, C. S., Gately, M., Pagan, J., Brennen, A., Cashman, D., Wu…
  26. Roberts-Miller, P. (2004). Deliberate conflict: Argument, political theory, and composition classes. Southern…
  27. Russell-Brown, K. (2022). ‘The Stop WOKE Act’: HB 7, race, and Florida’s 21st century anti-literacy campaign.…
  28. Schnitker, S. A. & Emmons, R. A. (2013). Hegel’s thesis-antithesis-synthesis model. In A. L. C. Runehov & L. …
  29. Scollon, R. & Scollon, S. B. (1981). Narrative, literacy and face in interethnic communication. Ablex.
  30. Slater, G. B. & Griggs, C. B. (2015). Standardization and subjection: An autonomist critique of neoliberal sc…
  31. Written Communication
  32. Smagorinsky, P. (2002). Teaching English through principled practice. Merrill/Prentice Hall.
  33. Smagorinsky, P. (2018). Emotion, reason, and argument: Teaching persuasive writing in tense times. English Jo…
  34. Smagorinsky, P. (2023). Talking and listening for civic engagement. English Journal, 112(3), 57–63. https://d…
  35. Smagorinsky, P., Johannessen, L. R., Kahn, E. A. & McCann, T. M. (2010). The dynamics of writing instruction:…
  36. Tanno, S. (2022, August 17). Clear backpacks rule introduced in Texas schools in wake of Uvalde shooting. The…
  37. Toulmin, S. (1958). The uses of argument. Cambridge University Press.
  38. Walton, D. (2010). The place of emotion in argument. The Pennsylvania State University Press.
  39. Will, G. F. (2023, March 8). Opinion: Woke word-policing is now beyond satire. The Washington Post. https://w…
  40. Research in the Teaching of English
  41. Yagelski, R. P. (2009). A thousand writers writing: Seeking change through the radical practice of writing as…