Wittgenstein and Toulmin’s Model of Argument: The Riddle Explained Away

Tomasz Zarębski

doi:10.1007/s10503-024-09637-w

Argumentation Dec 2024 Open Access

Wittgenstein and Toulmin’s Model of Argument: The Riddle Explained Away

Tomasz Zarębski DSW University of Lower Silesia

Abstract

AbstractThe article undertakes the problem of a Wittgensteinian background of Toulmin’s model of argument. While appreciating the original character of the investigations set out by Toulmin in The Uses of Argument, Wittgenstein’s ideas taken to be forerunners of both Toulmin’s philosophical method and the particular elements of the model of substantial argument are traced backward, to Toulmin’s earlier books: The Philosophy of Science (Toulmin, The philosophy of science. An introduction, Hutchinson University Library, London, 1953) and An Examination of the Place of Reason in Ethics (Toulmin, An examination of the place of reason in ethics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1950). The technique of pinpointing the constituents of that model in the books preceding The Uses of Argument is superposing the layout of Toulmin’s model on the crucial arguments concerning the earlier books: the scientific one based on Newtonian optics and the moral one concerning keeping promises. Such a procedure allows identifying backing for warrants and argument fields with the methods of representation in The Philosophy of Science and with modes of reasoning in An Examination of the Place of Reason in Ethics. The former is traced to passages 6.3 ff of Wittgenstein’s Tractatus, while the latter—to the concept of word-games (the later Wittgenstein’s language games). The claim regarding Wittgenstein’s background is that in Toulmin’s view of Wittgenstein, some parts of Tractatus concerning representing are in line with Wittgenstein’s later reflections on language games; as well as that the overall method of The Uses of Argument goes along with Wittgenstein’s therapeutic approach to philosophical problems that have to be placed in the context of their ordinary use.

Journal: Argumentation
Published: 2024-12-01
DOI: 10.1007/s10503-024-09637-w
CompPile
Open Access: OA PDF Hybrid
Topics: argument
Export: BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (34) · 1 in this index

Botting (2017)

Toulmin’s Logical Types

Argumentation
Canavan, T.F. (2012). Between logic and rhetoric: Toulmin’s theory of argumentation. [Doctoral dissertation, …
Godden, D.M. (2003). On Toulmin’s fields and Wittgenstein’s later views on logic. In: F.H. van Eemeren, J.A. …
OW Holmes Jr (1881)

The common law
A Janik (1996)

Wittgenstein’s Vienna

Show all 34 →

RH Johnson (2010)

Johnson, R.H. 2010. Wittgenstein’s influence on the development of informal logic. Cogency 2 (2): 81–104.

Cogency
C Kock (2006)

Arguing on Toulmin’s model. New essays on argumentation analysis and evaluation
R Monk (1990)

Ludwig Wittgenstein: the duty of genius
DJ O’Connor (1959)

O’Connor, D.J. 1959. The uses of argument. By Stephen Edelston Toulmin (Cambridge University Press, 1958). Ph…

Philosophy ↗
RJ O’Hara (2006)

O’Hara, R.J. 2006. Publications of Stephen Toulmin: a working bibliography. SSRN Journal. https://doi.org/10.…

SSRN Journal ↗
Piekarski, M. (2014). Logika – gramatyka – pragmatyka. Ewolucja Wittgensteinowskiej koncepcji związku języka …
JM Preston (2017)

A companion to Wittgenstein
R Rhees (2007)

The blue and brown books
HJ Ribeiro (2024)

Ribeiro, H.J. 2024. Wittgenstein’s ignorance of argumentation theory and Toulmin’s rehabilitation of Wittgens…

Philosophy International Journal ↗
Tore, N. (1979). Moral reasoning: a study in the moral philosophy of S. E. Toulmin. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
SE Toulmin (1950)

An examination of the place of reason in ethics
SE Toulmin (1953)

The philosophy of science. An introduction
SE Toulmin (1958)

The uses of argument
SE Toulmin (1969)

Toulmin, S.E. 1969. Ludwig Wittgenstein. Encounter 32 (1): 58–71.

Encounter
SE Toulmin (1972)

Human understanding. Volume 1: the collective use and development of concepts
SE Toulmin (1990)

Cosmopolis. The hidden agenda of modernity
SE Toulmin (2001)

Return to reason
SE Toulmin (2006)

Arguing on Toulmin’s model. New essays on argumentation analysis and evaluation
SE Toulmin (1979)

An introduction to reasoning
Toulmin, S.E. (1990b). Wittgenstein and the death of philosophy. In R. Haller, J. Brandl, Wittgenstein - Towa…
L Wittgenstein (1922)

Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Trans. C.K. Ogden
L Wittgenstein (1963)

Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Trans. D.F. Pears, B.F. McGuinness
L Wittgenstein (1964)

Remarks on the foundations of mathematics, Trans. G.E.M. Anscombe
L Wittgenstein (1986)

Philosophical Investigations, Trans C.K. Ogden
L Wittgenstein (2007)

The blue and brown books
Wittgenstein L. (1976). Wittgenstein’s lectures on the foundations of mathematics, Cambridge 1939. Ed. C. Dia…
Wittgenstein, L. (1988). Wittgenstein lectures on the philosophical psychology 1946–47. Ed. P. Geach. Chicago…
T Zarębski (2009)

Zarębski, T. 2009. Toulmin’s model of argument and the “logic” of scientific discovery. Studies in Logic, Gra…

Studies in Logic, Grammar and Rhetoric
T Zarębski (2023)

Zarębski, T., and A. Janik. 2023. 50 years after Wittgenstein’s Vienna. On Wittgenstein, Toulmin and philosop…

Nordic Wittgenstein Review ↗

CrossRef global citation count: 1 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Wittgenstein and Toulmin’s Model of Argument: The Riddle Explained Away

Abstract

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

References (34) · 1 in this index

Related Articles