Pathos in Natural Language Argumentation: Emotional Appeals and Reactions

Barbara Konat Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań ; Ewelina Gajewska Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań ; Wiktoria Rossa Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań

Abstract

AbstractIn this paper, we present a model of pathos, delineate its operationalisation, and demonstrate its utility through an analysis of natural language argumentation. We understand pathos as an interactional persuasive process in which speakers are performing pathos appeals and the audience experiences emotional reactions. We analyse two strategies of such appeals in pre-election debates: pathotic Argument Schemes based on the taxonomy proposed by Walton et al. (Argumentation schemes, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2008), and emotion-eliciting language based on psychological lexicons of emotive words (Wierzba in Behav Res Methods 54:2146–2161, 2021). In order to match the appeals with possible reactions, we collect real-time social media reactions to the debates and apply sentiment analysis (Alswaidan and Menai in Knowl Inf Syst 62:2937–2987, 2020) method to observe emotion expressed in language. The results point to the importance of pathos analysis in modern discourse: speakers in political debates refer to emotions in most of their arguments, and the audience in social media reacts to those appeals using emotion-expressing language. Our results show that pathos is a common strategy in natural language argumentation which can be analysed with the support of computational methods.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2024-09-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-024-09631-2
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (76) · 7 in this index

  1. Abercrombie, G., V. Basile, S. Tonelli, V. Rieser, and A. Uma. 2022. Proceedings of the 1st workshop on persp…
  2. Alessia, D., F. Ferri, P. Grifoni, and T. Guzzo. 2015. Approaches, tools and applications for sentiment analy…
    International Journal of Computer Applications  
  3. Alsaedi, A., P. Brooker, F. Grasso, and S. Thomason. 2022. Improving social emotion prediction with reader …
  4. Alswaidan, N., and M.E.B. Menai. 2020. A survey of state-of-the-art approaches for emotion recognition in tex…
    Knowledge and Information Systems  
  5. Rhetoric (W. R. Roberts, Trans.)
Show all 76 →
  1. Artetxe, M., and H. Schwenk. 2019. Massively multilingual sentence embeddings for zero-shot cross-lingual tra…
    Transactions of the Association for Computational Linguistics  
  2. How to do things with words
  3. Barbieri, F., L.E. Anke, and J. Camacho-Collados. 2021. XLM-T: A multilingual language model toolkit for Twit…
  4. Berengueres, J., and D. Castro. 2017. Differences in emoji sentiment perception between readers and writers. …
  5. Boucher, J., and C.E. Osgood. 1969. The Pollyanna hypothesis. Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior …
    Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior  
  6. Bourse, S. 2019. Conjuring up terror and tears: the evocative and persuasive power of loaded words in the pol…
    Lexis. Journal in English Lexicology  
  7. Argumentation
  8. Budzynska, K., and C. Reed. 2011a. Speech acts of argumentation: inference anchors and peripheral cues in dia…
  9. Whence inference
  10. Buechel, S., and U. Hahn. 2017. EmoBank: Studying the impact of annotation perspective and representation for…
  11. Cabrio, E., and S. Villata. 2018. The SEEMPAD dataset for emphatic and persuasive argumentation. In E. Cabrio…
  12. Chatterjee, A., K.N. Narahari, M. Joshi, and P. Agrawal. 2019. SemEval-2019 task 3: EmoContext contextual emo…
  13. Cigada, S. 2019. Emotions in argumentative narration: the case of the Charlie Hebdo attack. Informal Logic 39…
    Informal Logic  
  14. Demszky, D., D. Movshovitz-Attias, J. Ko, A. Cowen, G. Nemade, and S. Ravi. 2020. GoEmotions: a dataset of fi…
  15. Devlin, J., M.-W. Chang, K. Lee, and K. Toutanova. 2019. BERT: pre-training of deep bidirectional transforme…
  16. Diakopoulos, N.A., and D.A Shamma. 2010. Characterizing debate performance via aggregated Twitter sentiment. …
  17. Argumentation theory: a pragma-dialectical perspective
  18. Handbook of cognition and emotion
  19. Eugenio, B.D., and M. Glass. 2004. The kappa statistic: a second look. Computational linguistics 30 (1): 95–101.
    Computational linguistics  
  20. Gilbert, M.A. 2004. Emotion, argumentation and informal logic. Informal Logic. https://doi.org/10.22329/il.v2…
    Informal Logic  
  21. Gordon, M.L., K. Zhou, K. Patel, T. Hashimoto, and M.S. Bernstein. 2021. The disagreement deconvolution: brin…
  22. Greco, S., S. Cigada, and C. Jermini-Martinez Soria. 2022. The naming of emotions in dispute mediators’ strat…
    Text & Talk  
  23. Herman, T., and D. Serafis. 2019. Emotions, argumentation and argumentativity: Insights from an analysis of n…
    Informal Logic
  24. Hidey, C., E. Musi, A. Hwang, S. Muresan, and K. McKeown. 2017. Analyzing the semantic types of claims and p…
  25. Hinton, M., and A. Budzyńska-Daca. 2019. A comparative study of political communication in televised pre-elec…
    Research in Language  
  26. Computational models of argument
  27. Jose, R., and V.S Chooralil. 2015. Prediction of election result by enhanced sentiment analysis on Twitter da…
  28. Kissler, J., R. Assadollahi, and C. Herbert. 2006. Emotional and semantic networks in visual word processing:…
    Progress in brain research  
  29. Kocoń, J., A. Figas, M. Gruza, D. Puchalska, T. Kajdanowicz, and P. Kazienko. 2021. Offensive, aggressive, an…
    Information Processing & Management  
  30. Konat, B., J. Lawrence, J. Park, K. Budzynska, and C. Reed. 2016. A corpus of argument networks: using graph…
  31. Argumentation
  32. Computational models of argument
  33. Lindahl, A., L. Borin, and J. Rouces. 2019. Towards assessing argumentation annotation-a first step. In Proc…
  34. Liu, H., S. Li, G. Zhou, C.-R. Huang, and P. Li. 2013. Joint modeling of news reader’s and comment writer’s e…
  35. Lukin, S., P. Anand, M. Walker, and S. Whittaker. 2017. Argument strength is in the eye of the beholder: Aud…
  36. Maďarová, Z. 2015. Love and fear argumentative strategies against gender equality in Slovakia. Anti-Gender mo…
    Anti-Gender movements on the rise
  37. Argumentation
  38. Argumentation
  39. Argumentation
  40. Miłkowski, P., M. Gruza, K. Kanclerz, P. Kazienko, D. Grimling, and J. Kocoń. 2021. Personal bias in predicti…
  41. Mohammad, S., F. Bravo-Marquez, M. Salameh, and S. Kiritchenko. 2018. Semeval-2018 task 1: affect in tweets. …
  42. Mohammad, S., and P. Turney. 2010. Emotions evoked by common words and phrases: using mechanical turk to crea…
  43. Plantin, C. 2019. Tense arguments: questions, exclamations, emotions. Informal Logic 39 (4): 347–371.
    Informal Logic  
  44. Plutchik, R. 2001. The nature of emotions: human emotions have deep evolutionary roots, a fact that may expla…
    American Scientist  
  45. Emotions and life: perspectives from psychology, biology, and evolution
  46. Russell, J.A. 1980. A circumplex model of affect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 39 (6): 1161.
    Journal of Personality and Social Psychology  
  47. Saganowski, S., Komoszyńska, J., M. Behnke, B. Perz, D. Kunc, B. Klich, and P. Kazienko. 2022. Emognition da…
    Scientific Data  
  48. Santibáñez, C. 2010. Metaphors and argumentation: the case of Chilean parliamentarian media participation. Jo…
    Journal of Pragmatics  
  49. Saravia, E., H.-C.T. Liu, Y.-H. Huang, J. Wu, and Y.-S Chen. 2018. Carer: contextualized affect representa…
  50. Expression and meaning: studies in the theory of speech acts
  51. Stede, M. 2020. Automatic argumentation mining and the role of stance and sentiment. Journal of Argumentation…
    Journal of Argumentation in Context  
  52. Taboada, M., J. Brooke, M. Tofiloski, K. Voll, and M. Stede. 2011. Lexicon-based methods for sentiment analys…
    Computational Linguistics  
  53. Tang, Y.-J., and H.-H Chen. 2011. Emotion modeling from writer/reader perspectives using a microblog dataset.…
  54. Tang, Y.-J., and H.-H Chen. 2012. Mining sentiment words from microblogs for predicting writer-reader emotion…
  55. Van Haaften, T. 2019. Argumentative strategies and stylistic devices. Informal Logic 39 (4): 301–328.
    Informal Logic  
  56. Villata, S., E. Cabrio, I. Jraidi, S. Benlamine, M. Chaouachi, C. Frasson, and F. Gandon. 2017. Emotions and …
    Argument & Computation  
  57. Visser, J., B. Konat, R. Duthie, M. Koszowy, K. Budzynska, and C. Reed. 2020. Argumentation in the 2016 US pr…
    Language Resources and Evaluation  
  58. Argumentation
  59. The place of emotion in argument
  60. Argumentation
  61. Walton, D. 2007. Evaluating practical reasoning. Synthese 157 (2): 197–240.
    Synthese  
  62. Media argumentation: dialectic, persuasion and rhetoric
  63. Walton, D. 2010. The structure of argumentation in health product messages. Argument & Computation 1 (3): 179–198.
    Argument & Computation  
  64. Scare tactics: arguments that appeal to fear and threats
  65. Argumentation schemes
  66. Wang, X., W. Jiang, and Z. Luo. 2016. Combination of convolutional and recurrent neural network for sentiment…
  67. Warriner, A.B., and V. Kuperman. 2015. Affective biases in English are bi-dimensional. Cognition and Emotion …
    Cognition and Emotion  
  68. Wierzba, M., M. Riegel, J. Kocoń, P. Milkowski, A. Janz, K. Klessa, et al. 2021. Emotion norms for 6000 Polis…
    Behavior Research Methods  
  69. Wierzba, M., M. Riegel, M. Wypych, K. Jednoróg, P. Turnau, A. Grabowska, and A. Marchewka. 2015. Basic emotio…
    PLOS ONE  
  70. Wolf, T., L. Debut, V. Sanh, J. Chaumond, C. Delangue, A. Moi, and A.M. Rush. 2020. Transformers: State-of-th…
  71. Yang, C., K.H.-Y. Lin, and H.-H. Chen. 2009. Writer meets reader: emotion analysis of social media from both …