What Do We Mean by ‘That’s a Fallacious Narrative’?

Paula Olmos

doi:10.1007/s10503-023-09599-5

Argumentation Jun 2023 Open Access

What Do We Mean by ‘That’s a Fallacious Narrative’?

Paula Olmos Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

Abstract

AbstractThis paper tries to offer a descriptive account of the normative workings of evaluative fallacy charges directed to narratives. In order to do that, I first defend the continuity and mutual dependence, as based on a dynamical conception of argument, between the ‘belief conception’ and the ‘argumentative conception’ of fallacy. Then, I construe a catalogue of ‘fallacy charges’ based on both such a continuity and the variety of counterarguments explored by the theoretical framework of Argument Dialectics. And finally, I apply these ideas and distinctions in the analysis of four examples of published texts in which the charge of ‘fallacious narrative’ is issued by a discursive agent against other discursive agents’ either full-fledged narratives or narrative assumptions. The analyses confirm some of the characteristics mentioned in the catalogue as well as the argumentative nature of fallacy charges, even when the censored discourse does not exactly or explicitly contain an argument. The analyses also help understand the distinction between a rather concrete ‘linguistic’ use of the term narrative and a more abstract and elusive ‘discursive’ one, in which the difficulties of both identifying the object of censorship and the exact meaning of the fallacy charge multiply.

Journal: Argumentation
Published: 2023-06-01
DOI: 10.1007/s10503-023-09599-5
CompPile
Open Access: OA PDF Hybrid
Topics: discourse analysis
Export: BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (6)

Gonzalez, C. 2016. Racial Inequality: A ‘fallacious narrative.’ Panthernow: Florida International University …
Keefe, A. L. 2021. The Fallacious Narrative of Free Market Capitalism. TheRedPen-news: https://medium.com/the…
Monroe, I. 2014. African-American Sisters Aging With HIV and Co-Morbidities. Huffpost, August 1, 2014. https:…
Russell, J. 1680. A Brief Narrative of Some Considerable Passages… Boston. EEBO-TCP, 2011, http://name.umdl.u…
L Warren-Jeanpiere (2014)

Warren-Jeanpiere, L., H. Dillaway, P. Hamilton, M. Young, and L. Goparaju. 2014. Taking It One Day at a Time:…

AIDS Patient Care and STDs ↗

Show all 6 →

Willard, S. 1681. Ne Sutor Ultra Crepidam, or, Brief Animadversions… Boston. EEBO-TCP, 2011, http://name.umdl…

CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

What Do We Mean by ‘That’s a Fallacious Narrative’?

Abstract

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

References (6)

Related Articles