Written Communication Jul 1998

The Reform Tradition in Nineteenth-Century Composition Teaching

WILLIAM F. WOODS

Abstract

Commentary: English composition as we know it began in the early nineteenth century...but why is that important? Why would we care about poorly educated grammar school pedagogues—our distant colleagues!—fingers aching with cold as they parsed sentences, heard recitations, and fed the wood stove during those long wintery terms? Very simply, because their lives, practices, and less frequently, their writings give us back ourselves. Our own problems in teaching writing have recurrently presented themselves in forms that nineteenth-century teachers easily would have recognized. Like them, we sense the ongoing need for hard basics, the primitive core of our profession. Yet like those early teachers, we also dwell within a “reform tradition” that stresses the importance of students' interests and experience and continues to see the writing task as based on what used to be called “synthetic” insights and “self-active” learning. Inspired partly by romantic educational theories from the continent, this tradition grew out of the social and educational reforms of the 1830s and 1840s and provided the basis for the early progressive teaching of the 1890s. Prominent during the 1930s, and reasserting itself powerfully in the 1960s and 1990s, this student-centered approach manifests the continuing vitality of the enlightenment ideas and values and the romantic individualism that first gave it life.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
1998-07-01
DOI
10.1177/0741088398015003004
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
writing pedagogy teacher development grammar and mechanics
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (42)

  1. Adams, C. F. (1897)
    Harvard Graduates Magazine
  2. Barnard, H.
    Pestalozzi and Pestalozzianism
  3. Blair, H.
    Lectures on rhetoric and belles letters
  4. Button, H. W.
    History of education and culture in America
  5. Campbell, G.
    The philosophy of rhetoric
Show all 42 →
  1. Commager, H. S.
    The American mind
  2. Cremin, L. A.
    The American common school: An historic conception
  3. Cremin, L. A.
    The transformation of the school: Progressivism in American education
  4. Dearborn, N. E.
    The Oswego movement in American education
  5. Downs, R. E.
    Heinrich Pestalozzi: Father of modern pedagogy
  6. Finkelstein, B. J. (1970). Governing the young: Teacher behavior in American primary sc…
  7. Frost, J.
    Easy lessons in composition
  8. Genung, J. F.
    The practical elements of rhetoric
  9. Gibbons, T.
    Rooms in the Darwin Hotel: Studies in English literary criticism and ideas 1880-1920
  10. Greene, S. S.
    An analysis of the English language
  11. Gutek, G. L.
    Pestalozzi and education
  12. Hall, G. S.
    Educational problems
  13. Hall, G. S.
    Life and confessions of a psychologist
  14. Hess, G. C. (1949). An analysis of early American rhetoric and composition textbooks. …
  15. Hopkins, E. M.
    A handbook on the teaching of English
  16. James, W.
    Talks to teachers on psychology
  17. Katz, M. B.
    The irony of early school reform: Educational innovation in midnineteenth-century Massachusetts
  18. Kuhn, A. L.
    Mother's role in childhood education: New England concepts, 1830-60
  19. Lull, H. G. (1913). Inherited tendencies of secondary instruction in the United States (University o…
  20. Lyman, R. L.
    English grammar in American schools before 1850
  21. Monroe, W. S.
    History of the Pestalozzian movement in the United States
  22. Müller, M.
    Lectures on the science of language
  23. Neef, J.
    Sketch of a plan and method of education
  24. Parker, R. C.
    Progressive exercises in English composition
  25. Parker, R. G.
    Aids to English composition
  26. Pinloche, A.
    Pestalozzi and the foundation of the modern elementary school
  27. Pinneo, T. S.
    Analytical grammar of the English language
  28. 10.1080/00335635909382357
     ↗
  29. Russell, W. H. (1856)
    American Journal of Education
  30. Silber, K.
    Pestalozzi: The man and his work
  31. Smith, R. C.
    English grammar on the productive system
  32. Sunley, R.
    Childhood in contemporary culture
  33. Tyler, A. F.
    Freedom's ferment: Phases of American social history to 1860
  34. Ward, J.
    A system of oratory
  35. Whately, R.
    Elements of rhetoric
  36. White, E. E.
    The art of teaching
  37. 10.2307/357604
     ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Journal of Response to Writing Apr 2026
    Examining Automated Writing Evaluation Error Coverage in Relation to Uptake and Retention ↗
    Mehrzad, Mohaddeseh; Rahimi, Mohammad; Link, Stephanie
    genre theory writing pedagogy teacher development revision assessment artificial intelligence multilingual writers grammar and mechanics
  2. Written Communication Jan 2026
    The Contributions of Student-Level and Classroom-Level Factors for Australian Grade 2 Students’ Writing Performance ↗
    Anabela Malpique; Mustafa Asil; Deborah Pino-Pasternak; Debora Valcan
    writing pedagogy teacher development revision grammar and mechanics literacy studies gender and writing
  3. Assessing Writing Jan 2026
    How reliable and valid is peer evaluation in adolescents’ L2 argumentative writing? ↗
    Albert W. Li; Steve Graham
    writing pedagogy teacher development argument assessment multilingual writers grammar and mechanics literacy studies
  4. The Peer Review Sep 2025
    Moving Against the Grain: Combining Writing Center Theory and In-House Editing Services to Create a Graduate Writing Center ↗
    Brian Harrell; Brook Wyers; Craig Theissen
    rhetorical criticism composition theory writing pedagogy graduate education teacher development collaborative writing writing centers peer tutoring professional writing labor and working conditions online writing instruction multilingual writers grammar and mechanics editorial matter
  5. The Peer Review Apr 2025
    Writing Center Instruction for the Age of AI: Tutors Professional Development Workshop ↗
    Alexandra Krasova; Mahmoud Othman
    rhetorical criticism first-year composition writing pedagogy teacher development collaborative writing writing centers peer tutoring professional writing artificial intelligence grammar and mechanics