Written Communication Jan 1992

Planning Text Together: The Role of Critical Reflection in Student Collaboration

LORRAINE HIGGINS ; LINDA FLOWER ; JOSEPH PETRAGLIA

Abstract

Writing instructors often assign collaborative writing activities as a way to foster reflective thinking; many assume that the very act of explaining and defending ideas in the presence of a responsive audience actually forces writers to take critical positions on their own ideas. This article questions this assumption by examining the role of critical reflection in one particular writing context—that of collaborative planning. The authors' observations address three questions: (a) When students collaborate on plans for a paper do they necessarily reflect critically on their own ideas and processes, as many advocates of collaboration might expect? (b) If and when students engage in reflection, does it make a qualitative difference in their writing plans? And finally, (c) how do student writers engage in and use reflection as they develop plans? Twenty-two college freshmen audio-taped themselves as they planned course papers with a peer. Transcripts were coded for reflective comments and were holistically rated for quality. The analysis revealed a significant correlation between amount of reflective conversation and the quality of students' plans. Students used reflection to identify problems, to search for and evaluate alternative plans, and to elaborate ideas through the process of justification. This problem solving was most effective when reflection was sustained over many conversational turns. Collaboration did not guarantee reflection, however. Some sessions contained no reflective comments and some students used collaboration in a way that undermined reflective thinking. This study suggests that how students represented collaboration and the writing assignment itself determined whether and how they reflected on their own ideas.

Journal
Written Communication
Published
1992-01-01
DOI
10.1177/0741088392009001002
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
writing pedagogy collaborative writing
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (3)

  1. Angeli (2015)
    Three Types of Memory in Emergency Medical Services Communication
    Written Communication
  2. Tatzl et al. (2012)
    The Development of a Project-Based Collaborative Technical Writing Model Founde…
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  3. SPERLING (1995)
    Uncovering the Role of Role in Writing and Learning to Write: One Day in an Inn…
    Written Communication

References (43) · 4 in this index

  1. Applebee, A.
    Writing in the secondary school (Research Monograph No. 21)
  2. Applebee, A.
    Contexts for learning to write
  3. Bandura, A.
    Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory
     ↗
  4. 10.1037/0003-066X.44.9.1175
     ↗
  5. Bitzer, L. (1968)
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
Show all 43 →
  1. Bransford, J.
    Human cognition: Learning, understanding and remembering
  2. 10.1037/0003-066X.41.10.1078
     ↗
  3. Brown, A.
    Theoretical models and processes of reading
  4. 10.3102/0013189X010002014
     ↗
  5. Bruffee (1984)
    Collaborative Learning and the "Conversation of Mankind"
    College English
  6. Burtis, P.
    Exploration in the development of writing
  7. Carey, L.
    Differences in writers' initial task representations
  8. Curtin, E. (1988). The research paper in high school writing programs: Examining connec…
  9. Dewey, J.
    How we think: A restatement of the relation of reflective thinking to the educative process
  10. 10.1037/0022-0663.80.4.419
     ↗
  11. DURST (1989)
    Monitoring Processes in Analytic and Summary Writing
    Written Communication
  12. Farb, P.
    Word play: What happens when people talk
  13. 10.1037/0003-066X.34.10.906
     ↗
  14. Flower, L.
    Classroom inquiry in collaborative planning
  15. 10.2307/356600
     ↗
  16. Flower, L.
    Collaborative planning and the construction of meaning
  17. Flower, L.
    Planning in writing: The cognition of a constructive process
  18. Flower, L.
    Reading-to-write: Exploring a cognitive and social process
     ↗
  19. Forman, E. (1981). The role of collaboration in problem-solving in children. …
  20. Forman, E.
    Culture, communication and cognition: Vygotskian perspectives
  21. Freedman, S.
    Peer response groups in two ninth grade classrooms
  22. Garner, R.
    Metacognition and reading comprehension
  23. Higgins, L.
    1989 Conference on College Composition and Communication
  24. 10.3102/00346543049001051
     ↗
  25. Krashen, S.
    Second language acquisition and foreign language learning
  26. Lunsford et al. (1986)
    Why write . . . together: A research update∗
    Rhetoric Review
  27. Nystrand, M.
    The structure of written communication: Studies in the reciprocity of writers and readers
     ↗
  28. 10.1207/s1532690xci0102_1
     ↗
  29. Paris, S.
    Handbook of reading research
  30. Paris, S.
    annual meeting of the American Educational Researchers Association
  31. Perkins, D.
    The mind's best work
  32. Perret-Clermont, A.
    Social interaction and cognitive development in children
  33. Petraglia, J.
    Uncovering conceptions of purpose at work in the composition classroom
  34. Rose (1980)
    Rigid Rules, Inflexible Plans, and the Stifling of Language: A Cognitivist Anal…
    College Composition and Communication
  35. Scardamalia, M.
    Advances in applied linguistics
  36. Smit, D. (1989)
    Journal of Advanced Composition
  37. Vygotsky, L.
    Thought and language
  38. 10.1037/0022-0663.81.3.329
     ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 27 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Journal of Writing Research Feb 2026
    Can ChatGPT do the same? ChatGPT and professional editors compared ↗
    Daniël Janssen; Henri Raven; Lisanne Van Weelden; Yohannes Den Hertog
    writing pedagogy argument collaborative writing professional writing quantitative research artificial intelligence
  2. Prompt: A Journal of Academic Writing Assignments Jan 2026
    A Murder Most Technical: Gamification, AI, and Rhetorical Genre Studies in the Technical Writing Classroom ↗
    Justin Cook
    genre theory writing pedagogy service learning teacher development argument collaborative writing technical communication professional writing
  3. Pedagogy Jan 2026
    “Not a Detour from Rigor” ↗
    Krysten Stein; Kishonna Gray
    writing pedagogy teacher development collaborative writing assessment gender and writing
  4. Journal of Academic Writing Dec 2025
    Toward an Eductive Pedagogy for Academic Writing in Doctoral Education ↗
    Steve Tu
    writing pedagogy graduate education collaborative writing
  5. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Dec 2025
    Design Thinking in Business and Professional Communication Pedagogy: A Review of Pedagogical Studies, 2014–2024 ↗
    Jason Tham
    writing pedagogy collaborative writing assessment professional writing book reviews