Rhetoric Society Quarterly Jan 1992

Among men—not boys: Histories of rhetoric and the exclusion of pedagogy

Marjorie Curry Woods The University of Texas at Austin

Abstract

Almost all modern historians of rhetoric have undertaken to separate the men from the boys. But while rhetoric itself was talked about among men, it was to boys, and the handbooks that we have inherited-as well as most of those that we have lost-were intended for the instruction of the young. Feminist objections to classical rhetoric as been conducted among men-not women are consonant with this analysis, but I wish to emphasize here the ageism and academic self-hatred that we support when we accept the suppression of the pedagogical aspects of the history of our profession.' The dismissal of earlier pedagogical textbooks by both traditional and revisionist historians of rhetoric seems to me to be part of post-romantic unteachability topos, which assumes that what is most important about education is what least resembles the classroom.2 This topos is reinforced by more recent one that can be equally debilitating: the fear of teaching topos, in which having taught becomes synonymous with having oppressed.3 We can see their suppression of the pedagogical focus of classical rhetoric in the choice of rhetoric texts from earlier eras that traditional historians elevate to authoritative status. At one extreme is the modern canonization of Aristotle's Rhetoric, text that was never popular as pedagogical treatise in the ancient world, and at the other the rejection of Cicero's De invenltione and the Pseudo-Ciceronian Rhetorica ad Herenniurn. two rhetoric handbooks widely used in schools for hundreds of years. It is to the credit of traditional historians of rhetoric who are attempting to reclaim classical rhetoric as viable and important pedagogical alternative that they have been affected by this prejudice against pedagogy more in what they say than in what they do. Corbett's Handbook of Classical Rhetoric, for example, lavishly praises Aristotle's Rhetoric but, as the title reveals, presents its pedagogical material in fashion much closer to that of the Ciceronian tradition. Thomas Sloane, making passionate appeal in College English for the reclaiming of Ciceronian invention, dismisses De inventione as a famous and regrettably enduring handbook (462) before proceeding to extrapolate pedagogical content readily available in De invenhtione from the more diffuse and less pedagogically relevant De oratore.4

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
1992-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773949209390938
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy teacher development gender and writing
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (2)

  1. Fleming (2016)
    Quintilian,Progymnasmata, and Rhetorical Education Today
    Advances in the History of Rhetoric
  2. Tasker et al. (2008)
    Feminist Research Methodologies in Historic Rhetoric and Composition: An Overvi…
    Rhetoric Review

References (44) · 1 in this index

  1. Phillipe Ariès (1962)
    Centuries of Childhood: A Social History of Family Life
  2. Augustine St (1961)
    Confessions
  3. Bingham Jane (1980)
    Fifteen Centuries of Children's Literature: An Anotated Chronology of British and America…
  4. Bloom Alan David (1987)
    The Closing of the American Mind
  5. Carpenter Humphrey (1985)
    Secret Garden: A Study of the Golden Age of Children's Literature
Show all 44 →
  1. Cicero (1949)
    De inentione
  2. _____ (1986)
    On Oratory and Orators
  3. Cicero (1964)
    Ad C. Herennium De Ratione Dicendi (Rhetorica ad Herennium)
  4. Covino William A. (1988)
    The An of Wondering: A Revisionist Return to the History of Rhetoric
  5. Corbett Edward P. J. (1971)
    Classical Rhetoric for the Modern Student
  6. Dusinberre Juliet (1987)
    Alice to the Lighthouse: Children's Books and Radical Experiments in Art
  7. Ferguson Margaret W. (1986)
    Rewriting the Renaissance: The Discourses of Sexual Difference in Early Modern Europe
  8. Geoffrey of Vinsauf (1967)
    The “Poetria nova” of Geoffrey of Vinsauf
  9. Usseling Samuel (1963)
    Rhetoric and Philosophy in Conflict
  10. Jarratt Susan C. (1991)
    Rereading the Sophists: Classical Rhetoric Refigured
  11. _____
    Learning from the Rhetorics of History: Essays in honor of Winifred Bryan Horner
  12. John of Salisbury (1955)
    The Metalogicon of John of Salisbury: A Twelfth‐Century Defense of the Verbal and Logical…
  13. Johnson Nan (1983)
    Classical Rhetoric and Modern Discourse
  14. Kail (1988)
    Narratives of knowledge: Story and pedagogy in four composition texts
    Rhetoric Review
  15. Kennedy George (1980)
    Classical Rhetoric and Its Christian and Secular Tradition from Ancient to Modern Times
  16. Knoblauch C. H. (1984)
    Rhetorical Traditions and the Teaching of Writing
  17. Marcus Leah Singnoglou (1978)
    Childhood and Cultural Despair: A Theme and Variations in Seventeenth‐Century Literature
  18. _____
    Redrawing the Boundaries of Literary Studies
  19. Meyers Mitzi (1987)
    10.1353/chq.0.0499
    Children's Literature Association Quarterly  ↗
  20. Miller Susan (1991)
    The Politics of Writing instruction: Postsecondary
  21. Moon Michael (1989)
    Displacing Homophobia: Gay Male Perspectives in Literature and Culture
  22. 10.2307/358127
     ↗
  23. Murphy James J. (1989)
    Writing on the Edge
  24. _____ (1974)
    Rhetoric in the Middle Ages
  25. Ohmann Richard (1976)
    English in America: A Radical View of the Profession
  26. Owen W.J.B. (1985)
    The Fottrteen‐Book
  27. Rose Jacqueline (1984)
    The Case of Peter Pan; or The impossibility of Children's Fiction
     ↗
  28. Shaver Chester L. (1979)
    Wordsworth's Library: A Catalogue, including a List of Books Housed by Wordsworth for Col…
  29. 10.2307/378000
     ↗
  30. 10.2307/358128
     ↗
  31. Summerfield Geoffrey (1984)
    Fantasy and Reason: Children's Literature in the Eighteenth Century
  32. Townsend John Rowe (1983)
    Written for Children: An Outline of English Language Children's Literature
  33. Vickers Brian (1988)
    In Defense of Rhetoric
  34. Wallace David
    Working Papers: Center for Twentieth‐Century Studies U of Wisconsin‐Milwaukee, 1990–91
    Working paper no.11
  35. Watney Simon (1991)
    inside/Out: Lesbian Theories, Gay Theories
  36. Woods Marjorie Curry (1985)
    Chaucer Review
  37. _____ (1991)
    Rhetorica
  38. _____
    Learning from the Rhetorics of History: Essays in Honor of Winifred Bryan Horner
  39. _____ (1990)
    A Short History of Writing Instruction from Ancient Greece to Twentieth‐Century America
CrossRef global citation count: 3 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Rhetorica Jun 2021
    Weeping for Dido: The Classics in the Medieval Classroom by Marjorie Curry Woods ↗
    Jordan Loveridge
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis writing pedagogy teacher development gender and writing book reviews
  2. Advances in the History of Rhetoric Sep 2019
    The Oxford Handbook of Rhetorical Studies ↗
    Glen McClish
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism feminist rhetorics decolonial rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy graduate education teacher development argument multilingual writers gender and writing disability studies editorial matter
  3. Rhetorica Mar 2018
    Discorsi eloquenti da Ulisse a Obama e oltre di A. Pennacini ↗
    Luigi Spina
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis writing pedagogy teacher development qualitative research quantitative research grammar and mechanics race and writing gender and writing
  4. Advances in the History of Rhetoric May 2016
    An Essay on Current Quintilian Studies in English, With a Select Bibliography of Items Published Since 1990 ↗
    James J. Murphy
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy teacher development argument grammar and mechanics literacy studies gender and writing public rhetoric literary studies editorial matter
  5. Rhetorica Mar 2009
    Trust in Texts: A Different History of Rhetoric by Susan Miller ↗
    Nancy S. Struever
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis writing pedagogy teacher development gender and writing