Philosophy & Rhetoric Dec 2024

“I’m Not Surprised, But . . .”: Knowingness and Moral Judgment

Ben Roth Emerson College

Abstract

ABSTRACT What pattern of mind is revealed by the increasingly common turn of phrase “I’m not surprised, but I am disappointed”? Three thinkers who though very influential elsewhere have little cache in contemporary ethical theory—Richard Rorty, Peter Sloterdijk, and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick—suggest that what they call (respectively) knowingness, cynicism, and paranoid interpretation are endemic to our times. Building on their work, this article argues that knowing confirmation that the (terrible) way things are trending is what we expected all along has a deleterious effect on moral judgment. A knowing lack of surprise, which positions the speaker as savvy, weakens the judgment that follows. If what happened was expected, then the sense that something else could have happened is undercut. Against this mindset, the article synthesizes Rorty’s emphasis on hope with Sedgwick’s on affect, discussing political hope as a virtue with a significant affective dimension to be fostered.

Journal
Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published
2024-12-31
DOI
10.5325/philrhet.57.4.0367
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
affect and writing
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (70) · 1 in this index

  1. (2017)
    Critique and Postcritique
  2. Aristotle (1984)
    The Complete Works of Aristotle
  3. (1999)
    Nicomachean Ethics
  4. (2021)
    “What Makes Something Surprising?”
    Philosophy and Phenomenological Research
  5. (2001)
    “Evidential Preemption.”
    Philosophy and Phenomenological Research
Show all 70 →
  1. (2001)
    The Enchantment of Modern Life
  2. (2001)
    The Politics of Moralizing
  3. (1994)
    Foregone Conclusions
  4. Bommarito, Nicolas. 2018. “Modesty and Humility.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.s…
  5. (1999)
    “The Value of Hope.”
    Philosophy and Phenomenological Research  ↗
  6. (2018)
    The Routledge Handbook of Virtue Epistemology
  7. (1998)
    “Achieving Richard Rorty.”
    Weekly Standard
  8. _______. 2023. “What if We’re the Bad Guys Here?”New York Times, 2Aug.https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/02/opin…
  9. (2005)
    “‘A Monkish Kind of Virtue?’ For and Against Humility.”
    Political Theory  ↗
  10. (2017)
    The Practices of Hope
  11. (2023)
    The Experience Machine: How Our Minds Predict and Shape Reality
  12. (2021)
    A Defense of Judgment
  13. (2010)
    Democracy and Rhetoric
  14. (2015)
    Defending Rorty
  15. (2015)
    Building a Social Democracy
  16. (1992)
    Beyond the Brillo Box
  17. (1991)
    Consciousness Explained
  18. Desjardins, Lisa, and DanielBush. 2017. “We Asked Every Senator for Their Reaction to Trump’s Anti-Muslim Ret…
  19. Downen, Robert. 2020. “Faith Leaders Say Trump’s Refusal to Denounce White Supremacists Will Fuel Hate, Viole…
  20. (2018)
    Virtue Ethics
    Rhetoric Review
  21. (1990)
    The Ideology of the Aesthetic
  22. (2001)
    Virtue Epistemology
     ↗
  23. (1993)
    Norms of Rhetorical Culture
  24. (2015)
    The Limits of Critique
  25. French, David. 2017. “Disgrace: Obama Commutes Bradley Manning’s Sentence.”National Review, 17Jan.https://www…
  26. (2004)
    Truth and Method
  27. (2000)
    “Aristotle on Hope.”
    Journal of the History of Philosophy  ↗
  28. (1962)
    Being and Time
  29. (1885)
    The Art of Fiction
  30. (2023)
    “The Primacy of Hope for Human Flourishing.”
    The Monist  ↗
  31. (2015)
    “The Virtue of Hope.”
    Ethical Theory and Moral Practice  ↗
  32. (2007)
    The Shock Doctrine
  33. (2009)
    Pragmatism as Transition
  34. (2016)
    “Aquinas on the Virtues of Hope: Theological and Democratic.”
    Journal of Religious Ethics  ↗
  35. (2023)
    The Force of Truth
  36. (2017)
    Rhetoric’s Pragmatism
  37. (2014)
    How We Hope
  38. (2004)
    “The Art of Good Hope.”
    Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science  ↗
  39. (2020)
    “Discovering the Virtue of Hope.”
    European Journal of Philosophy  ↗
  40. (2020)
    Historical and Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Hope
     ↗
  41. (2006)
    “Hope as a Political Virtue.”
    Philosophical Papers  ↗
  42. (2018)
    “It’s Not What You Do, but What Everyone Else Does.”
    Journal of Experimental Social Psychology  ↗
  43. (1999)
    Existentialists and Mystics
  44. (2021)
    “Imagine the Worst.”
  45. (1971)
    “The Absurd.”
    Journal of Philosophy  ↗
  46. (2021)
    On Freedom
  47. (1989)
    Beyond Good and Evil
  48. (2022)
    “Deleuze and Rorty on Hope.”
    Educational Philosophy and Theory
  49. (1990)
    Time and Narrative
  50. (2003)
    Intellectual Virtue
  51. (1982)
    Consequences of Pragmatism
  52. (1989)
    Contingency, Irony, Solidarity
  53. (1998)
    Achieving Our Country: Leftist Thought in Twentieth-Century America
  54. (2000)
    Philosophy and Social Hope
  55. (2022)
    What Can We Hope For?
  56. (2022)
    The Ethics of Richard Rorty
  57. (2003)
    Touching, Feeling
     ↗
  58. (2001)
    Habits of Hope
  59. (2003)
    Intellectual Virtue
  60. (1987)
    The Critique of Cynical Reason
  61. (2018)
    “Hope as a Democratic Civic Virtue.”
    Metaphilosophy  ↗
  62. (2016)
    Hope in the Dark
  63. (1966)
    Against Interpretation and Other Essays
  64. (1962)
    “Freedom and Resentment.”
    Proceedings of the British Academy
  65. (1996)
    Virtues of the Mind
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Journal of Business and Technical Communication Mar 2026
    Terms of Service and Community Guidelines as “Value-Laden” Documents: An (Adapted) Corpus-Assisted Discourse Analysis of “Sexual Content” ↗
    Rachael Jordan
    discourse analysis social media affect and writing
  2. Written Communication Feb 2026
    Rhetoric and Affect: The Role of Faith in Student Writers’ Wayfinding ↗
    Amy D. Williams; Jonathan Ostenson
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis empirical research affect and writing
  3. Argumentation Feb 2026
    When Emmanuel Macron Goes Social: Using Social Media Influencers as a Rhetorical Strategy ↗
    Keren Sadoun-Kerber
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument collaborative writing social media affect and writing
  4. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Jan 2026
    Assessing Soft Skills Requirement in Entry-Level Career Success in the Malaysian Logistics Industry ↗
    Jessica Hai Liaw Ong; Priy Brat Dwivedi
    service learning affect and writing
  5. Pedagogy Jan 2026
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism genre theory writing pedagogy graduate education two-year college teacher development social media race and writing gender and writing affect and writing literary studies editorial matter