“I’m Not Surprised, But . . .”: Knowingness and Moral Judgment

Philosophy & Rhetoric Dec 2024

“I’m Not Surprised, But . . .”: Knowingness and Moral Judgment

Ben Roth Emerson College

Abstract

ABSTRACT What pattern of mind is revealed by the increasingly common turn of phrase “I’m not surprised, but I am disappointed”? Three thinkers who though very influential elsewhere have little cache in contemporary ethical theory—Richard Rorty, Peter Sloterdijk, and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick—suggest that what they call (respectively) knowingness, cynicism, and paranoid interpretation are endemic to our times. Building on their work, this article argues that knowing confirmation that the (terrible) way things are trending is what we expected all along has a deleterious effect on moral judgment. A knowing lack of surprise, which positions the speaker as savvy, weakens the judgment that follows. If what happened was expected, then the sense that something else could have happened is undercut. Against this mindset, the article synthesizes Rorty’s emphasis on hope with Sedgwick’s on affect, discussing political hope as a virtue with a significant affective dimension to be fostered.

Journal: Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published: 2024-12-31
DOI: 10.5325/philrhet.57.4.0367
Open Access: Closed
Topics: affect and writing

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

Cites in this index (1)

(2018)

Virtue Ethics

Rhetoric Review

Also cites 15 works outside this index ↓

(1999)

“The Value of Hope.”

Philosophy and Phenomenological Research ↗
(2005)

“‘A Monkish Kind of Virtue?’ For and Against Humility.”

Political Theory ↗
(2001)

Virtue Epistemology

↗
(2000)

“Aristotle on Hope.”

Journal of the History of Philosophy ↗
(2023)

“The Primacy of Hope for Human Flourishing.”

The Monist ↗
(2015)

“The Virtue of Hope.”

Ethical Theory and Moral Practice ↗
(2016)

“Aquinas on the Virtues of Hope: Theological and Democratic.”

Journal of Religious Ethics ↗
(2004)

“The Art of Good Hope.”

Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science ↗
(2020)

“Discovering the Virtue of Hope.”

European Journal of Philosophy ↗
(2020)

Historical and Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Hope

↗
(2006)

“Hope as a Political Virtue.”

Philosophical Papers ↗
(2018)

“It’s Not What You Do, but What Everyone Else Does.”

Journal of Experimental Social Psychology ↗
(1971)

“The Absurd.”

Journal of Philosophy ↗
(2003)

Touching, Feeling

↗
(2018)

“Hope as a Democratic Civic Virtue.”

Metaphilosophy ↗

CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network →