Beginnings and Ends of Rhetorical Theory: Ann Arbor 1900

Daniel M. Gross University of California, Irvine

Abstract

ABSTRACTGoogle Ngram metadata reveal that the English phrase “rhetorical theory” is not that old, appearing on the scene in the latter half of the nineteenth century, and then picking up dramatically with critical and literary theory in the 1960s. How do we square this with familiar arguments that rhetorical theory is much, much older? In this forum contribution I argue that the long view applies to our contemporary rhetorical theory only if we equivocate. Much of what currently falls under the heading “rhetorical theory” has little or nothing to do with the systematic conceptualization of persuasive discourse (i.e., the long view)—general, posthuman, eco-, and materialist rhetorics are the most prominent counterexamples. Instead, around 1900, Gertrude Buck develops what I call the short and sharp view that prevails to this day: rhetorical theory offers reality figured by way of its alternatives.

Journal
Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published
2020-02-21
DOI
10.5325/philrhet.53.1.0034
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (51) · 2 in this index

  1. Atwill, Janet M. 1993. “Instituting the Art of Rhetoric: Theory, Practice, and Productive Knowledge in Interp…
  2. Baca, Damián, and Victor Villanueva, eds. 2010. Rhetorics of the Americas: 3114 BCE to 2012 CE. New York: Pal…
  3. Binkley, Roberta. 2004. “Reading the Ancient Figure of Enheduanna.” In Rhetoric before and beyond the Greeks,…
  4. Black, Edwin. 1980. “A Note on Theory and Practice in Rhetorical Criticism.” Western Journal of Speech Commun…
  5. Blumenberg, Hans. [1960] 2010. Paradigms for a Metaphorology. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Show all 51 →
  1. Blumenberg, Hans. [1970] 1981. “Anthropologische Annäherung an die Aktualität der Rhetorik.” In Wirklichkeite…
  2. Blumenberg, Hans. [1970] 1987. “An Anthropological Approach to the Contemporary Significance of Rhetoric.” In…
  3. Blumenberg, Hans. [1987] 2015. The Laughter of the Thracian Woman: A Protohistory of Theory. New York: Bloomsbury.
  4. Buck, Gertrude. 1899. The Metaphor: A Study in the Psychology of Rhetoric. Vol. 5, Contributions to Rhetorica…
  5. Buck, Gertrude. [1901] 1996. “What Does ‘Rhetoric’ Mean?” In Toward a Feminist Rhetoric: The Writing of Gertr…
  6. Buck, Gertrude. 1906. “The Relations of Rhetoric and Literary Criticism.” Proceedings of the MLA, xx–xxi.
  7. Buck, Gertrude, and Harriet M. Scott. 1897. Organic Education: A Manual for Teachers in Primary and Grammar G…
  8. Butler, Judith. 2003. “Values of Difficulty.” In Just Being Difficult? Academic Writing in the Public Arena, …
  9. Campbell, JoAnn. 1996. “Introduction.” In Toward a Feminist Rhetoric: The Writing of Gertrude Buck, ed. JoAnn…
  10. Canz, Israel Gottlieb. 1739. Doctrina Rhetorica De Tropis Philologice Illustrata et Philosophice Fundata. Tüb…
  11. Chaput, Catherine. 2010. “Rhetorical Circulation in Late Capitalism: Neoliberalism and the Overdetermination …
  12. Cole, Andrew. 2014. The Birth of Theory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  13. Davis, Diane, and Michele Ballif, eds. 2014. “Extrahuman Rhetorical Relations: Addressing the Animal, the Obj…
  14. de Man, Paul. 1986. The Resistance to Theory. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
  15. Donawerth, Jane. 2002. Rhetorical Theory by Women before 1900: An Anthology. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
  16. Enoch, Jessica. 2008. Refiguring Rhetorical Education: Women Teaching African-American, Native American, and …
  17. Gilman, Sander L., Carol Blair, and David J. Parent, eds. 1989. Friedrich Nietzsche on Rhetoric and Language.…
  18. Greene, Ronald Walter. 2004. “Rhetoric and Capitalism: Rhetorical Agency as Communicative Labor.” Philosophy …
  19. Philosophy & Rhetoric
  20. Hawhee, Debra. 2009. Moving Bodies: Kenneth Burke at the Edges of Language. Columbia: University of South Carolina.
  21. Hoy, David Couzens, and Thomas McCarthy. 1994. Critical Theory. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
  22. Kahneman, Daniel, and Dale Miller. 1986. “Norm Theory: Comparing Reality to Its Alternatives.” Psychological …
  23. Kennedy, George A. 1992. “A Hoot in the Dark: The Evolution of General Rhetoric.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 25 (1…
  24. Kevelson, Roberta. 1984. “C. S. Peirce's Speculative Rhetoric.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 17 (1): 16–29.
  25. Kitzhaber, Albert R. 1990. Rhetoric in American Colleges, 1850–1900. Dallas, TX: Southern Methodist Universit…
  26. Leff, Michael C. 1980. “Interpretation and the Art of the Rhetorical Critic.” Western Journal of Speech Commu…
  27. Lin, Yuri, et al. 2012. “Syntactic Annotations for the Google Books Ngram Corpus.” In Proceedings of the ACL,…
  28. Rhetorica
  29. Michel, Jean-Baptiste, et al. 2011. “Quantitative Analysis of Culture Using Millions of Digitized Books.” Sci…
  30. Miller, J. Hillis. [1986] 1991. MLA Presidential Address “The Triumph of Theory, the Resistance to Reading, a…
  31. Nichols, Stephen G., and Nadia R. Altschul. 2012. “Digital Philology: A Journal of Medieval Cultures.” Digita…
  32. Ohio State University Press. “New Directions in Rhetoric and Materiality.” https://ohiostatepress.org/books/s…
  33. Pechenick, Eitan Adam, et al. 2015. “Characterizing the Google Books Corpus: Strong Limits to Inferences of S…
  34. Porter, James I. 1994. “Nietzsche's Rhetoric: Theory and Strategy.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 27 (3): 218–44.
  35. Poulakos, John. 1990. “Interpreting Sophistical Rhetoric: A Response to Schiappa.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 23 (…
  36. “Rhetoric.” 1859. In Encyclopaedia Britannica, 126.
  37. Riley-Mukavetz, Andrea. 2014. “Towards a Cultural Rhetorics Methodology: Making Research Matter with Multi-ge…
  38. Rubini, Rocco. 2009. “Humanism as Philosophia (Perennis): Grassi's Platonic Rhetoric between Gadamer and Kris…
  39. Rubini, Rocco. 2014. The Other Renaissance: Italian Humanism between Hegel and Heidegger. Chicago: University…
  40. Schiappa, Edward. 1999. The Beginnings of Rhetorical Theory in Classical Greece. New Haven, CT: Yale Universi…
  41. Schiappa, Edward. 2001. “Second Thoughts on the Critiques of Big Rhetoric.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 34 (3): 260–74.
  42. Schiappa, Edward. 2003. Protagoras and Logos: A Study in Greek Philosophy and Rhetoric. 2nd ed. Columbia: Uni…
  43. Struever, Nancy. 1992. Theory as Practice: Ethical Inquiry in the Renaissance. Chicago: University of Chicago…
  44. Struever, Nancy. 2005. “Alltäglichkeit, Timefulness, in the Heideggerian Program.” In Heidegger and Rhetoric,…
  45. Vico, Giambattista. 1990. On the Study Methods of Our Time. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
  46. Williams, Jeffrey J. 2009. “The Rise of the Theory Journal.” New Literary History 40 (4): 683–702.