Abstract

Abstract Jürgen Habermas supports his transhistorical conception of violence as a form of instrumental reason to be rejected from the ideal polity with a historical narrative that recounts the rejection of Machiavellian and Hobbesian instrumental violence by the Enlightenment philosophes. This article provides a revised narrative, which emphasizes the persistence of a rhetorical conception of violence from Machiavelli's princely violence to a line of Anglo-American republican thinkers who shifted the locus of sovereign rhetorical violence to the people's armed militia. The narrative culminates with Madison's exegesis of the Second Amendment and sketches how this Madisonian conception harmonizes with Habermasian norms and law.

Journal
Philosophy & Rhetoric
Published
2016-05-15
DOI
10.5325/philrhet.49.2.0125
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (51)

  1. Abizadeh, Arash. 2001. “Banishing the Particular: Rousseau on Rhetoric, Patrie, and the Passions.” Political …
  2. Burgh, James. 1971. Political Disquisitions: An Enquiry into Public Errors, Defects, and Abuses. New York: Da…
  3. Cornell, Saul. 2006. A Well-Regulated Militia: The Founding Fathers and the Origins of Gun Control in America…
  4. Fletcher, Andrew. 1698. A Discourse of Government with Relation to Militias. Edinburgh: n.p.
  5. Fletcher, Andrew. 1997. Political Works. Ed. John Robertson. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Show all 51 →
  1. Foley, Megan. 2013. “Of Violence and Rhetoric: An Ethical Aporia.” Quarterly Journal of Speech 99 (2): 191–99.
  2. Garsten, Bryan. 2006. Saving Persuasion: A Defense of Rhetoric and Judgement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Universi…
  3. Garver, Eugene. 1987. Machiavelli and the History of Prudence. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
  4. Habermas, Jürgen. 1973. Theory and Practice. Trans. John Viertel. Boston: Beacon Press.
  5. Habermas, Jürgen. 1979. “Legitimation Problems in the Modern State.” In Communication and the Evolution of So…
  6. Habermas, Jürgen. 1984. Reason and the Rationalization of Society. Vol. 1 of The Theory of Communicative Acti…
  7. Habermas, Jürgen. 1987. Lifeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason. Vol. 2 of The Theory of Com…
  8. Habermas, Jürgen. 1991. The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into a Category of Bou…
  9. Habermas, Jürgen. 1996. Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy. Tr…
  10. Halbrook, Stephen P. 1984. That Every Man Be Armed: The Evolution of a Constitutional Right. Albuquerque: Uni…
  11. Hamilton, Alexander, James Madison, and John Jay. 1987. The Federalist; or, The New Constitution. Ed. Max Bel…
  12. Handlin, Oscar, and Mary Handlin. 1961. “James Burgh and American Revolutionary Theory.” Proceedings of the M…
  13. Hobbes, Thomas. 1996. Leviathan. Ed. Richard Tuck. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  14. Ivison, Duncan. 2003. “Locke, Liberalism, and Empire.” In The Philosophy of John Locke: New Perspectives, ed.…
  15. Kahn, Victoria. 1985. Rhetoric, Prudence, and Skepticism in the Renaissance. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
  16. Kahn, Victoria. 1994. Machiavellian Rhetoric: From the Counter-Reformation to Milton. Princeton, NJ: Princeto…
  17. Kennedy, George A. 1994. A New History of Classical Rhetoric. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
  18. Kopel, David B., and Christopher C. Little. 1997. “Communitarians, Neorepublicans, and Guns: Assessing the Ca…
  19. Levinson, Sanford. 1989. “The Embarrassing Second Amendment.” Yale Law Journal 99 (3): 637–59.
  20. Locke, John. 1988. Two Treatises of Government. Ed. Peter Laslett. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  21. Machiavelli, Niccolò. 1992. The Prince. Trans. N. H. Thomson. New York: Dover.
  22. Machiavelli, Niccolò. 2005. The Art of War. Trans. and ed. Christopher Lynch. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  23. Madison, James. 2006. Selected Writings of James Madison. Ed. Ralph Ketcham. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett.
  24. Maier, Pauline. 1974. From Resistance to Revolution: Colonial Radicals and the Development of American Opposi…
  25. Malcolm, Joyce. 1994. To Keep and Bear Arms: The Origins of an Anglo-American Right. Cambridge, MA: Harvard U…
  26. Mattern, David B., ed. 1997. James Madison's “Advice to my Country.” Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia.
  27. Nedham, Marchamont. 1757. The Excellencie of a Free State. London: Printed for A. Millar and T. Cadell, G. Ke…
  28. Nedham, Marchamont. 1969. The Case of the Commonwealth of England, Stated. Ed. P. A. Knachel. Charlottesville…
  29. Pocock, J. G. A. 2003. The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tra…
  30. Rahe, Paul A., ed. 2006. Machiavelli's Liberal Republican Legacy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  31. Rebhorn, Wayne A. 1995. The Emperor of Men's Minds: Literature and the Renaissance Discourse of Rhetoric. Ith…
  32. Scalia, Antonin, et al. 2008. District of Columbia v. Heller. 128 S. Ct. 2783, 2789.
  33. Shalhope, Robert E. 1982. “The Ideological Origins of the Second Amendment.” Journal of American History 69 (…
  34. Sidney, Algernon. 1996. Discourses Concerning Government. Ed. T. G. West. Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Fund.
  35. Skinner, Quentin. 1996. Reason and Rhetoric in the Philosophy of Hobbes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  36. Story, Joseph. 1833. Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States. Boston: Hilliard, Gray.
  37. Sullivan, Vickie B. 2004. Machiavelli, Hobbes, and the Formation of a Liberal Republicanism in England. Cambr…
  38. Trenchard, John, and Thomas Gordon. 1995. Cato's Letters; or, Essays on Liberty, Civil and Religious, and Oth…
  39. Trenchard, John, and Walter Moyle. 1697. An Argument Shewing, That a Standing Army Is Inconsistent with a Fre…
  40. Uviller, H. Richard, and William G. Merkel. 2002. The Militia and the Right to Arms; or, How the Second Amend…
  41. Viroli, Maurizio. 1998. Machiavelli. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  42. Vogt, Philip. 2008. John Locke and the Rhetoric of Modernity. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
  43. Walker, William. 1994. Locke, Literary Criticism, and Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  44. Williams, David C. 1991. “Civic Republicanism and the Citizen Militia: The Terrifying Second Amendment.” Yale…
  45. Williams, David C.. 2003. The Mythic Meanings of the Second Amendment: Taming Political Violence in a Constit…
  46. Young, David E., ed. 1995. The Origin of the Second Amendment: A Documentary History of the Bill of Rights, 1…