Rhetoric & Public Affairs Jan 2020

Defending Cyberspace: Reexamining Security Metaphors in the Internet Era

Yang

Abstract

This essay examines the image-schemas and metaphors that leaders and critics employ in international debates about the internet. As Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton delivered the first speech by a senior American official articulating a strategy for incorporating internet freedom into American foreign policy in 2010, but international leaders have been concerned with the implications of the internet since its inception. Situating Clinton’s speech in the history of internet governance, I employ security image-schemas first developed by Paul Chilton to demonstrate how policymakers employ the internet to reinforce realist foreign policy narratives. To support alternative conceptions of the internet, I propose a “space” image-schema drawing from the work of critical geographer Doreen Massey. While the internet is often depicted as a force for freedom, a more productive framework may be understanding its relationship with space.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2020-01-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.23.4.0707
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (100) · 2 in this index

  1. 1. Grant Schneider, “President Trump Unveils America’s First Cybersecurity Strategy in 15 Years,” The White H…
  2. 2. Hillary Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom,” (speech, The Newseum, Washington D.C., January 21, 2010), …
  3. 3. G. Thomas Goodnight, “The Metapolitics of the 2002 Iraq Debate: Public Policy and the Network Imaginary,” …
     ↗
  4. 4. Francis A. Beer and Robert Hariman, “Realism and Rhetoric in International Relations,” in Post-Realism: Th…
  5. 5. Beer and Hariman, “Realism and Rhetoric in International Relations,” 21.
Show all 100 →
  1. 6. Paul Chilton, “The Meaning of Security,” in Post-Realism: The Rhetorical Turn in International Relations, …
  2. 7. Timothy Barney, "Diagnosing the Third World: The 'Map Doctor' and the Spatialized Discourses of Disease an…
     ↗
  3. Zoë Hess Carney and Allison M. Prasch, "'A Journey for Peace': Spatial Metaphors in Nixon's 1972 'Opening to …
     ↗
  4. William Flanik, "'Bringing FPA Back Home:' Cognition, Constructivism, and Conceptual Metaphor: Bringing FPA B…
     ↗
  5. Hamilton Bean, "'A Complicated and Frustrating Dance': National Security Reform, the Limits of Parrhesia, and…
     ↗
  6. Mary Manjikian, "Diagnosis, Intervention, and Cure: The Illness Narrative in the Discourse of the Failed Stat…
     ↗
  7. 8. Brendon M. H. Larson, Brigitte Nerlich, and Patrick Wallis, “Metaphors and Biorisks: The War on Infectious…
     ↗
  8. 9. Amber Davisson, "Beyond the Borders of Red and Blue States: Google Maps As a Site of Rhetorical Invention …
     ↗
  9. Poirot (2015)
    Gendered Geographies of Memory: Place, Violence, and Exigency at the Birmingham…
    Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  10. Choi (2016)
    Can a Memorial Communicate Embodied Trauma? Reenacting Civilian Bodies in the N…
    Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  11. 10. Doreen Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility in the Midst of Global Inequality,” Erdkunde 2, …
     ↗
  12. 11. Chilton, “The Meaning of Security,” 212.
  13. 12. Mark Landler, “Clinton Urges Global Response to Internet Attacks,” The New York Times, January 21, 2010, …
  14. 13. Shawn M. Powers and Michael Jablonski, The Real Cyber War: The Political Economy of Internet Freedom (Uni…
     ↗
  15. 14. Arvind Ganesan, “US: A Big Step Toward Online Freedom,” Human Rights Watch, January 22, 2010, https://www…
  16. 15. Peter Ford, “Clinton Bluntly Condemns China on Internet Censorship,” The Christian Science Monitor, Janua…
  17. 16. Daniel Nasaw, “Beijing Warns U.S. Over $6bn Taiwan Arms Sale: ‘Very Serious Problem’ says Chinese officia…
  18. 17. “Commentary: Don’t Impose Double Standards on “Internet Freedom,” Xinhua Economic News Service, January 2…
  19. 18. George Lakoff, “Cognitive Semantics,” in Meaning and Mental Representations, eds. Umberto Eco, Marco Sant…
  20. 19. Lakoff, “Cognitive Semantics,” 141.
  21. 20. Mark Johnson, The Body in the Mind: The Bodily Basis of Meaning, Imagination, and Reason (Chicago: Univer…
  22. 21. Chilton, “The Meaning of Security,” 195.
  23. 22. Chilton, “The Meaning of Security,” 200.
  24. 23. Chilton, “The Meaning of Security,” 199.
  25. 24. Doreen Massey, For Space (Los Angeles: SAGE, 2005), 81.
  26. 25. Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility,” 90.
  27. 26. Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility,” 90.
  28. 27. Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility,” 91.
  29. 28. Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility,” 92.
  30. 29. Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility,” 91.
  31. 30. Chilton believed that the container was the controlling metaphor of realist approaches to national securi…
  32. 31. Landler, “Clinton Urges Global Response to Internet Attacks.”
  33. 32. Johnson, The Body in the Mind, 55.
  34. 33. Larry Diamond, “Liberation Technology,” Journal of Democracy 21, no. 3 (July 2010): 69-83.
     ↗
  35. 34. Rebecca MacKinnon, Consent of the Networked: The Worldwide Struggle For Internet Freedom (New York, NY, U…
  36. 35. David Hoogland Noon, “Operation Enduring Analogy: World War II, the War on Terror, and the Uses of Histor…
     ↗
  37. 36. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  38. 37. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  39. 38. Hillary Clinton, Hard Choices (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2014), 550.
  40. 39. Anne-Marie Slaughter, “America’s Edge: Power in the Networked Century,” Foreign Affairs 88, no. 1 (Januar…
  41. 40. Slaughter, “America’s Edge,” 99.
  42. 41. Powers and Jablonski, The Real Cyber War, 2.
  43. 42. Powers and Jablonski, The Real Cyber War, 208.
  44. 43. Beer and Hariman, “Realism and Rhetoric in International Relations,” 3.
  45. 44. 44Powers] and Jablonski, The Real Cyber War, 3.
  46. 45. Victor Pickard, “Neoliberal Visions and Revisions in Global Communications Policy From NWICO to WSIS,” Jo…
     ↗
  47. 46. Vindu Goel, “India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet Giants,” The New York Times, Augus…
  48. 47. Milton Mueller, Networks and States: The Global Politics of Internet Governance (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Pr…
     ↗
  49. 48. David D. Sanger, David D. Kirkpatrick, and Nicole Perlroth, “The World Once Laughed at North Korean Cyber…
  50. 49. Pickard, “Neoliberal Visions,” 122.
  51. 50. Many Voices One World, Contents.
  52. 51. Pickard, “Neoliberal Visions,” 123.
  53. 52. Pickard, “Neoliberal Visions,” 131; Ibid., 127.
  54. 53. Andrew Butfoy, “American Exceptionalism and President Obama’s Call for Abolition of Nuclear Weapons,” Con…
     ↗
  55. 54. Powers and Jablonski, The Real Cyber War, 7.
  56. 55. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  57. 56. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  58. 57. Luke Glanville, Sovereignty and the Responsibility to Protect: A New History (Chicago: University of Chic…
     ↗
  59. 58. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  60. 59. Glanville, Sovereignty and the Responsibility to Protect, 133.
  61. 60. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  62. 61. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  63. 62. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  64. 63. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  65. 64. Eric Schmidt and Jared Cohen, “The Digital Disruption: Connectivity and the Diffusion of Power,” Foreign …
  66. 65. Schmidt and Cohen, “The Digital Disruption,” 76.
  67. 66. Schmidt and Cohen, “The Digital Disruption,” 80.
  68. 67. Massey, For Space, 82.
  69. 68. Davisson, “Beyond the Borders,” 119.
  70. 69. Jayne Rodgers, “Doreen Massey: Space, Relations, Communications,” Information, Communication & Society 7,…
     ↗
  71. 70. Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility,” 90.
  72. 71. Panayotis A. Yannakogeorgos, “Internet Governance and National Security.” Strategic Studies Quarterly 6, …
  73. 72. Doreen Massey qtd. in Rodgers, “Doreen Massey,” 283.
  74. 73. Nisha Shah, “From Global Village to Global Marketplace: Metaphorical Descriptions of the Global Internet,…
     ↗
  75. 74. Rodgers, “Doreen Massey,” 288.
  76. 75. Massey, For Space, 81.
  77. 76. Massey qtd. in Rodgers, “Doreen Massey,” 287.
  78. 77. Clay Shirky, "The Political Power of Social Media: Technology, the Public Sphere, and Political Change," …
  79. Ian Bremmer, "Democracy in Cyberspace: What Information Technology Can and Cannot Do," Foreign Affairs 89, no…
  80. 78. Rodgers, “Doreen Massey,” 286.
  81. 79. Rodgers, “Doreen Massey,” 287.
  82. 80. “Changing the Narrative,” Liberty in North Korea, http://www.libertyinnorthkorea.org/changing-the-narrative/.
  83. 81. In The Human Condition, Hannah Arendt argued that violence is a pre-political act.
  84. 82. “People Over Politics,” Liberty in North Korea, https://www.libertyinnorthkorea.org/people-over-politics/.
  85. 83. “People Over Politics,” Liberty in North Korea.
  86. 84. Chery Dieu-Nalio, “Eight Years Later, Haiti Still Recovering From Devastating Earthquake,” CTV News Montr…
  87. 85. “NTIA Announces Intent to Transition Key Internet Domain Name Functions,” NTIA, March 14, 2014, https://w…
  88. 86. Kieren McCarthy, “US Govt Mulls Snatching Back Full Control of the Internet’s Domain Name and IP Address …
  89. 87. Wenban-Smith, “Can Any Government?”
  90. 88. “The IANA Stewardship Transition: What You Need to Know,” ICANN, https://www.icann.org/iana-transition-fa…
  91. 89. Emily Taylor, “The Internet is Run by an Unaccountable Private Company. This is a Problem,” The Guardian,…
  92. 90. Aram Sinnreich, Nathan Graham, and Aaron Trammell, “Weaving a New ’Net: A Mesh-Based Solution,” The Infor…
     ↗
  93. 91. Massey, “Space, Time and Political Responsibility,” 90.
  94. 92. Clinton, “Remarks on Internet Freedom.”
  95. 93. Chilton, “The Meaning of Security,” 202.
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →