Abstract

Abstract Opioid addiction and overdose are widely recognized as a contemporary “crisis” across the United States. To address rapidly increasing mortality rates related to this substance use epidemic, the Philadelphia Mayor’s Office announced in January 2018 that it would encourage the development of supervised injection sites or “Comprehensive User Engagement Sites” within city limits. Official communications cited select moments from the region’s past to frame these sites as urgent while constituting a supportive, unified public. Through remediating disidentification, a mode of rhetorical contestation and reformulation, local community members used an alternate historical framing to resist dominant ideology and revise the terms of the related public discourse. By further developing the concept of rhetorical disidentification, this essay demonstrates how the deployment of historical analogy in response to proposed public health interventions can enable the public recognition and potential address of systemic racial inequities.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2019-12-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.22.4.0533
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (122) · 2 in this index

  1. 1. “The Mayor’s Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic in Philadelphia,” City of Philadelphia, 2018, https:…
  2. 2. Sam Wood, “To Battle Deadly Overdose Epidemic, Philly Considers Safe Injection Sites,” Philadelphia Inquir…
  3. 3. Steffanie A. Strathdee and Robin A. Pollini, “A 21st-Century Lazarus: The Role of Safer Injection Sites in…
  4. 4. Unless otherwise noted, the information in this introductory paragraph is surmised from the Task Force mee…
  5. 5. “Mayor Addresses Opioid Crisis in Philadelphia/Office of the Mayor/Press Release,” City of Philadelphia, N…
Show all 122 →
  1. 6. Courtenay Harris Bond, “Kensington Forum on Opioids Packs the House, but Avoids Fiery Debate,” Billy Penn …
  2. 7. For the purposes of brevity and clarity, I refer to the loose collection of institutional stakeholders—inc…
  3. 8. Distinctions between “the city” and “the community” are of course never clear-cut. For example, while “the…
  4. 9. Michaela Winberg, “Why a North Philly Meeting about Injection Sites Erupted into a Shouting Match,” Billy …
  5. 10. Anjali Vats, “Created Differences: Rhetorics of Race and Resistance in Intellectual Property Law” (Ph.D. …
  6. 11. José Esteban Muñoz, Disidentifications: Queers of Color and the Performance of Politics (Minneapolis: Uni…
  7. 12. Muñoz, Disidentifications, 1.
  8. 13. Bond, “Kensington Forum on Opioids Packs the House, but Avoids Fiery Debate.”
  9. 14. Muñoz, Disidentifications, 12.
  10. 15. Anjali Vats, “Marking Disidentification: Race, Corporeality, and Resistance in Trademark Law,” Southern C…
  11. 16. Vats, “Marking Disidentification: Race, Corporeality, and Resistance in Trademark Law,” 238.
  12. Rhetoric Review
  13. 18. Muñoz, Disidentifications, 82.
  14. 19. Vats, “Marking Disidentification: Race, Corporeality, and Resistance in Trademark Law,” 240. For an examp…
  15. 20. Kristen De Groot, “Philadelphia Wants Safe Injection Sites to Help Opioid Fight,” Philadelphia Tribune, J…
  16. 21. “Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic to Announce Recommendations, Office of the Mayor, Press Release…
  17. 22. As of March 31, 2018, Ithaca, New York, Seattle, Washington, and San Francisco, California, had similarly…
  18. 23. Cindy Bass, “Councilwoman Cindy Bass on Safe Injection Site Announcement: ‘There are a lot of unanswered …
  19. 24. As a widespread “crisis” enveloping the entire nation, the opioid epidemic is covered by thousands of med…
  20. 25. Jenell Johnson, American Lobotomy: A Rhetorical History (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2016), 12.
  21. 26. David Zarefsky, “Four Senses of Rhetorical History,” in Doing Rhetorical History: Concepts and Cases, ed.…
  22. 27. Zarefsky, “Four Senses of Rhetorical History,” 28.
  23. 28. Turner, Doing Rhetorical History, 2.
  24. 29. The comparison between the national opioid epidemic and the AIDS epidemic is a theme that also exists wel…
  25. 30. Maurice Charland, “Constitutive Rhetoric: The Case of the Peuple Québécois,” Quarterly Journal of Speech …
  26. 31. Charland, “Constitutive Rhetoric,” 139.
  27. 32. Edward Schiappa, Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning (Carbondale: Southern Illinois…
  28. 33. Schiappa, Defining Reality, 10.
  29. 34. David Zarefsky, “Presidential Rhetoric and the Power of Definition,” Presidential Studies Quarterly 34 (2…
  30. 35. David Zarefsky, President Johnson’s War on Poverty: Rhetoric and History (Tuscaloosa: University of Alaba…
  31. 36. Charland, “Constitutive Rhetoric,” 141.
  32. 37. Jeremy Engels, “Friend or Foe? Naming the Enemy,” Rhetoric & Public Affairs 12 (2009): 54. For more on th…
  33. Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  34. 39. Mills, “The Pirate and the Sovereign,” 115.
  35. 40. Mills, “The Pirate and the Sovereign,” 129.
  36. 41. Mills articulates the relationship between differentiation and identification drawing from Ernesto Laclau…
  37. 42. Stuart Hall, “The Problem of Ideology: Marxism without Guarantees,” in Stuart Hall: Critical Dialogues in…
  38. 43. Stuart Hall, “Culture, the Media and ‘Ideological Effect‘” in Mass Communication and Society, ed. James C…
  39. 44. Stuart Hall, “The Rediscovery of ‘Ideology’: Return of the Repressed in Media Studies,” in Culture, Socie…
  40. 45. Hall, “Problem of Ideology,” 29.
  41. 46. “Mayor Addresses Opioid Crisis in Philadelphia, Office of the Mayor, Press Release.” Former Commissioner …
  42. 47. “Mayor Addresses Opioid Crisis in Philadelphia, Office of the Mayor, Press Release.” Estimates released f…
  43. 48. Mayor James F. Kenney, “The Mayor’s Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic in Philadelphia, Final Repor…
  44. 49. Kenney, “The Mayor’s Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic in Philadelphia,” 40.
  45. 50. Don Sapatkin, “Task Force: Safe Sites Worth a Shot: Group Presents Report to Fight Opioid Crisis,” Philad…
  46. 51. Studies tracking U.S. mortality rates of white non-Hispanic individuals from 1999 to 2013 have shown a re…
  47. 52. “Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic to Announce Recommendations, Office of the Mayor, Press Release.”
  48. 53. “Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic to Announce Recommendations, Office of the Mayor, Press Release.”
  49. 54. “Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic to Announce Recommendations, Office of the Mayor, Press Release.”
  50. 55. Dan Royles, “Taking It to the Streets: AIDS, Race, and Protest in Philadelphia,” Pennsylvania Legacies 16…
  51. 56. Cathy Cohen provides an in-depth analysis of the complex relationship between the AIDS epidemic of this e…
  52. 57. Royles, “Taking It to the Streets,” 27. It is worth noting that Royles’s findings conflict with the city’…
  53. 58. Royles, “Taking It to the Streets,” 27.
  54. 59. “Philadelphia Department of Public Health, AIDS Activities Coordinating Office Surveillance Report, 2017,…
  55. 60. “Philadelphia Department of Public Health, AIDS Activities Coordinating Office Surveillance Report, 2017,” 11.
  56. 61. Phillip Jackson, “Safe Injection Sites Hit a Nerve at Council,” Philadelphia Tribune, January 26, 2018, h…
  57. 62. The Philadelphia chapter of ACT UP, highlighted in Royles’s work, is still operating in the city today an…
  58. 63. Mayor Ed Rendell, “Executive Order No. 4-92” (City of Philadelphia, July 27, 1992).
  59. 64. Inciardi and Harrison, Harm Reduction, 3; and “ Frequently Asked Questions, Prevention Point.” For a comp…
  60. 65. Inciardi and Harrison, Harm Reduction, viii. The authors also note that harm reduction strategies can inc…
  61. 66. Tuukka Tammi and Toivo Hurme, “How the Harm Reduction Movement Contrasts Itself against Punitive Prohibit…
  62. 67. As Tammi and Hurme point out, using the label “harm reduction” is of rhetorical significance all on its o…
  63. 68. Though not the focus of this paper, the city has clearly stated that it will not directly fund any CUES. …
  64. 69. “City Announces Progress on Opioid Task Force Recommendations, Department of Behavioral Health and Intell…
  65. 70. “City Announces Progress on Opioid Task Force Recommendations, Department of Behavioral Health and Intell…
  66. 71. “Comprehensive User Engagement Sites (CUES),” https://dbhids.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/OTF_CUES-Fact…
  67. 72. Alfred Lubrano, Mari A. Schaefer, and Liz Navratil, “Wolf Pares Red Tape on Addiction: Disaster Declarati…
  68. 73. Kenneth Lipp, “DEA Won’t Look to Philly Injection Sites for Overdose Data in Opioid Fight,” Billy Penn (b…
  69. 74. Aubrey Whelan, “27 Years Later, Proof is in the Prevention Point,” Philadelphia Daily News, January 25, 2…
  70. 75. Aubrey Whelan, “27 Years Later, Proof is in the Prevention Point.” It is worth noting here that Krasner h…
  71. 76. Mike Newall, “Urgent Need for Safe Injection Sites,” Philadelphia Daily News, August 7, 2017, sec. Local.
  72. 77. The Inquirer Editorial Board, “Philadelphia Safe Injection Sites: The Right Move to Save Lives Now/Editor…
  73. 78. Bass, “Op-Ed.”
  74. 79. Charland, “Constitutive Rhetoric,” 141.
  75. 80. Charland, “Constitutive Rhetoric,” 143.
  76. 81. Governor Tom Wolf, “Governor Wolf Declares Heroin and Opioid Epidemic a Disaster Emergency,” Governor Tom…
  77. 82. Wolf, “Governor Wolf Declares Heroin and Opioid Epidemic a Disaster Emergency.”
  78. 83. Lubrano, Schaefer, and Navratil, “Wolf Pares Red Tape on Addiction.”
  79. 84. See Zarefsky, President Johnson’s War on Poverty, 11.
  80. 85. Craig Reinarman and Harry G. Levine, “Crack in the Rearview Mirror: Deconstructing Drug War Mythology,” S…
  81. 86. Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness (New York: New Pres…
  82. 87. Alexander points out that crack was associated with black and African American people and was concurrentl…
  83. 88. Keturah James and Ayana Jordan, “The Opioid Crisis in Black Communities,” Journal of Law, Medicine and Et…
  84. 89. James and Jordan, “The Opioid Crisis in Black Communities,” 410.
  85. 90. Alexander, The New Jim Crow, 7.
  86. 91. James Forman Jr., Locking Up Our Own: Crime and Punishment in Black America (New York: Farrar, Straus and…
  87. 92. Forman Jr., Locking Up Our Own, 162–63.
  88. 93. Julie Netherland and Helena B. Hansen, “The War on Drugs That Wasn’t: Wasted Whiteness, ‘Dirty Doctors,‘ …
  89. 94. James and Jordan, “The Opioid Crisis in Black Communities,” 413.
  90. 95. Kennett Werner, “In Effort to Combat Opioid Epidemic, Philadelphia Plans Safe Injection Sites,” NBC News,…
  91. 96. Jeremy Roebuck and Chris Palmer, "Will Trump Administration, Law Enforcement Challenge Safe Injection Sit…
  92. and Elana Gordon, "What's Next For 'Safe Injection' Sites in Philadelphia?" NPR.org, January 24, 2018, https:…
  93. 97. It is commonly assumed that the opioid epidemic largely affects white men. While statistics included in t…
  94. 98. Helen Ubinas, “Time to Stop Whitewashing Opioid Crisis,” Philadelphia Daily News, August 15, 2017, sec. O…
  95. 99. Muñoz, Disidentifications, 12.
  96. 100. Muñoz, Disidentifications, 31.
  97. 101. Solomon Jones, “No Safe Spaces for Crack Addicts of Color,” Philadelphia Daily News, January 31, 2018, s…
  98. 102. Solomon Jones, “Safe Injection Sites in Philly: More Community Discussion Needed,” Philadelphia Inquirer…
  99. 103. Solomon Jones, “City Must Right Wrongs of Crack Era,” Philadelphia Daily News, February 14, 2018, sec. E…
  100. 104. Ernest Owens, “Opinion: If Opioids Are a Public Health Crisis, Let’s Admit the Crack Epidemic Was Too,” …
  101. 105. Abraham Gutman, “Safe Injection Sites: The Right Thing to Do Now Was Right Thing to Do in ’80s,” Philly …
  102. 106. Gutman, “Safe Injection Sites in Philly.”
  103. 107. Safe Injection Sites: A Community Forum, 2018, https://soundcloud.com/solomon-jones-10/safe-injection-si…
  104. 108. Jackson, “Safe Injection Sites Hit a Nerve at Council.”
  105. 109. Aubrey Whelan, “Safe Injection Sites to Fight Opioid Overdose Deaths Get Green Light from Philadelphia O…
  106. 110. Kensington, West Kensington, and Fairhill are neighborhoods oft cited as the heart of the city’s opioid …
  107. 111. Andrew Seidman, Angela Couloumbis, and Claudia Vargas, “Philly Safe Injection Sites Could Politicize Opi…
  108. 112. Elana Gordon, “Talk of Philly Safe-Injection Site Heats up at Community Meeting,” WHYY (blog), February …
  109. 113. Bass, “Councilwoman Cindy Bass on Safe Injection Site Announcement.” For another example of those advoca…
  110. 114. Kenney, “The Mayor’s Task Force to Combat the Opioid Epidemic in Philadelphia,” 9.
  111. 115. Owens, “Opinion.”
  112. 116. Muñoz, Disidentifications, 161.
  113. 117. Jim Kenney and Larry Krasner, “Criminalizing Crack Addiction Was a Mistake: Philly’s Approach to Opioids…
  114. 118. “Mayor Kenney Delivers Third Budget Address, Office of the Mayor,” City of Philadelphia, March 1, 2018, …
  115. 119. Hall, “Problem of Ideology,” 39.
  116. 120. Muñoz, Disidentifications, 48.
  117. 121. On April 10, 2019, the city of Philadelphia uploaded a new safe injection site fact sheet entitled “Over…