Rhetoric & Public Affairs Sep 2019

Hacked: Defining the 2016 Presidential Election in the Liberal Media

Jacob W. Justice ; Brett J. Bricker

Abstract

Abstract Despite consensus that Russia’s interference in the 2016 election did not extend to actual hacking of voting technology, Russian efforts to intervene on behalf of the Trump campaign have been defined as “hacking” by elements of the liberal media. This definition is broadly accepted in liberal circles, and there is now a widespread misperception that Russia tampered with voting technology to alter the outcome of the election. In this essay, we trace the emergence of this definition of Russia’s role in the 2016 election and explain the factors that led to its acceptance, arguing that the debate over Russia’s “hacking” illustrates that definitional arguments may operate differently than scholars have previously conceived. Traditional studies of definition emphasize the role of political leaders in crafting salient definitions, adopting a top-down approach. We argue that definitions also emerge from the bottom up, moving from media sources toward institutional centers of power. Our findings both illustrate the dangers of efforts to define Russia’s influence campaign as “hacking” and extend previous scholarship on definitional argument.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2019-09-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.22.3.0389
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
argument
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (145) · 2 in this index

  1. 1. Zeke Miller, “Donald Trump’s Team Keeps Changing Their Russia Stories,” Time, July 11, 2017, http://time.c…
  2. 2. Mark Mazzetti and Katie Benner, “12 Russian Agents Indicted in Mueller Investigation,” New York Times, Jul…
  3. 3. Mark Landler, Michael D. Shear, and Maggie Haberman, “A One-Two Punch Puts Trump Back on His Heels,” New Y…
  4. 4. “The Unchecked Threat from Russia,” Washington Post Editorial Board, December 16, 2017, https://www.washin…
  5. 5. Intelligence Community Assessment, “Assessing Russian Activities and Intentions in Recent US Elections,” O…
Show all 145 →
  1. 6. Intelligence Community Assessment, “Assessing Russian Activities,” ii-iii.
  2. 7. Scott J. Shackelford, Michael Sulmeyer, Amanda N. Craig Deckard, Ben Buchanan, and Brian Micic, “From Russ…
  3. 8. Shackelford et al., “From Russia with Love,” 323.
  4. 9. Jonathan Masters, “Russia, Trump, and the 2016 U.S. Election,” Council on Foreign Relations, last modified…
  5. 10. Tom McCarthy, “How Russia Used Social Media to Divide Americans,” Guardian, October 14, 2017, https://www…
  6. 11. McCarthy, “How Russia Used Social Media.”
  7. 12. Alexis C. Madrigal, “Russia’s Troll Operation Was Not That Sophisticated,” Atlantic, February 19, 2018, h…
  8. 13. Adrian Chen, Twitter post, February 20, 2018, 6:53 AM, https://twitter.com/AdrianChen/status/965962680161…
  9. 14. Samanth Subramanian, “Inside the Macedonian Fake-News Complex,” Wired, February 15, 2017, https://www.wir…
  10. 15. Cynthia McFadden, William M. Arkin, and Kevin Monahan, “Russians Penetrated U.S. Voter Systems, Top U.S. …
  11. 16. McFadden, Arkin, and Monahan, “Russians Penetrated U.S. Voter Systems.”
  12. 17. Intelligence Community Assessment, “Assessing Russian Activities,” iii.
  13. 18. Eric Manpearl, “Securing U.S. Election Systems: Designating U.S. Election Systems as Critical Infrastruct…
  14. 19. Emefa Agawu, “How Can an Election Be Hacked?” Pacific Standard Magazine, November 16, 2017, https://psmag…
  15. 20. Bruce Schneier, “Cyberconflicts and National Security,” UN Chronicle 50 (2013), https://unchronicle.un.or…
     ↗
  16. 21. Amy Mitchell, Jocelyn Kiley, Jeffrey Gottfried, and Katerina Eva Matsa, “Political Polarization and Media…
  17. 22. Kathleen Hall Jamieson and Joseph N. Cappella, Echo Chamber: Rush Limbaugh and the Conservative Media Est…
  18. 23. Jonathan Chait, “Why Are So Many Leftists Skeptical of the Russia Investigation?” New York Magazine, July…
  19. 24. B. Scott Titsworth. "An Ideological Basis for Definition in Public Argument: A Case Study of the Individu…
     ↗
  20. and Brian McGee, "The Argument from Definition Revisited: Race and Definition in the Progressive Era," Argume…
     ↗
  21. 25. John Lynch, What Are Stem Cells? Definitions at the Intersection of Science and Politics (Tuscaloosa: Uni…
  22. 26. Kenneth Burke, Permanence and Change: An Anatomy of Purpose (New York: New Republic, 1935), 55.
  23. Zarefsky (2007)
    Strategic Maneuvering through Persuasive Definitions: Implications for Dialecti…
    Argumentation
  24. 28. Edward Schiappa, Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning (Carbondale: Southern Illinois…
  25. 29. Kenneth T. Broda-Bahm, “Finding Protection in Definitions: The Quest for Environmental Security,” Argumen…
     ↗
  26. 30. Titsworth, “Ideological Definition,” 171.
  27. 31. Zarefsky, “Strategic Maneuvering,” 409.
  28. 32. Broda-Bahm, “Finding Protection,” 161.
  29. 33. Titsworth, “Ideological Definition,” 181.
  30. 34. Zarefsky, “Strategic Maneuvering,” 405.
  31. 35. David Zarefsky, Rhetorical Perspectives on Argumentation (New York: Springer, 2014), 122.
     ↗
  32. 36. Zarefsky, “Strategic Maneuvering,” 405.
  33. 37. Lynch, Stem Cells, 6.
  34. 38. Lynch, Stem Cells, 9.
  35. 39. Schiappa, Defining Reality, 112-25.
  36. 40. Titsworth, “Ideological Definition,” 171.
  37. 41. Broda-Bahm, “Finding Protection,” 162.
  38. Jones et al. (2015)
    Redefining the Proper Role of Government: Ultimate Definition in Reagan’s First…
    Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  39. and Robert C. Rowland and John M. Jones, "Reagan at the Brandenburg Gate: Moral Clarity Tempered by Pragmatis…
     ↗
  40. 43. David Zarefsky, Carol Miller-Tutzauer, and Frank Tutzauer, “Reagan’s Safety Net for the Truly Needy: The …
     ↗
  41. 44. Zarefsky, “Strategic Maneuvering,” 405; and Zarefsky, Rhetorical Perspectives, 117.
  42. 45. Matt Taibbi, “Something about This Russia Story Stinks,” Rolling Stone, December 30, 2016, https://www.ro…
  43. 46. Becket Adams, “Reminder: ‘Hack the Election’ Is Garbage Shorthand for Russia’s Alleged Meddling,” Washing…
  44. 47. “Grand Jury Indicts 12 Russian Intelligence Officers for Hacking Offenses Related to the 2016 Election,” …
  45. 48. Zack Beauchamp, “Democrats Are Falling for Fake News about Russia,” Vox, May 19, 2017, https://www.vox.co…
  46. 49. Michael W. Kearney, “rtweet: Collecting Twitter Data,” rtweet: Collecting Twitter Data. R package version…
  47. 50. “Wall Street Journals Best-Selling Books Week Ended February 19th,” Lubbock Avalanche-Journal, February 2…
  48. 51. Lawrence Swaim, “Russia-Gate in the Age of Cyberwar,” Napa Valley Register, August 1, 2017, https://napav…
  49. 52. Chauncey DeVega, “Intelligence Expert Malcolm Nance on Trump Scandal: ‘As Close to Benedict Arnold as We’…
  50. 53. Malcolm Nance, The Plot to Hack America (New York: Skyhorse Publishing, 2016), 58.
  51. 54. Nance, The Plot to Hack America, 6.
  52. 55. Nance, The Plot to Hack America, xvii.
  53. 56. Nance, The Plot to Hack America, 108.
  54. 57. Nance, The Plot to Hack America, 84.
  55. 58. Nance, The Plot to Hack America, 84-85.
  56. 59. Rachel Maddow, The Rachel Maddow Show, transcript 10/10/2016, http://www.msnbc.com/transcripts/rachel-mad…
  57. 60. Aaron Maté, “MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow Sees a “Russia Connection” Lurking Around Every Corner,” Intercept, Ap…
  58. 61. Maté, “MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow.”
  59. 62. Maté, “MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow.”
  60. 63. Maté, “MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow.”
  61. 64. Maddow, The Rachel Maddow Show, transcript 10/10/2016.
  62. 65. Rachel Maddow, The Rachel Maddow Show, transcript 10/31/2016, http://www.msnbc.com/transcripts/rachel-mad…
  63. 66. Kearney, “rtweet: Collecting Twitter Data.”
  64. 67. See David Corn, “The NSA Chief Says Russia Hacked the 2016 Election. Congress Must Investigate,” Mother J…
  65. 68. See Joy Reid, Twitter post, December 27, 2016, 2:46 PM, https://twitter.com/JoyAnnReid/status/81387862859…
  66. 69. See Nancy Pelosi, Twitter post, December 12, 2016, 10:35 AM, https://twitter.com/nancypelosi/status/80837…
  67. Scott Neuman, "Russian Spy Chief Reportedly Met with U.S. Intelligence Officials Despite Sanctions," National…
  68. Amy Harder, Twitter post, April 24, 2018, 5:38 AM, https://twitter.com/AmyAHarder/status/988759128641335299
  69. Elizabeth Warren, Twitter post, July 16, 2017, 6:36 AM, https://twitter.com/senwarren/status/886580331310088193
  70. Kirsten Gillibrand, Twitter post, March 2, 2017, 8:43 AM, https://twitter.com/sengillibrand/status/8373426975…
  71. Adam Schiff, Twitter post, December 7, 2016, 11:44 AM, https://twitter.com/repadamschiff/status/8065851733746…
  72. Keith Ellison, Twitter post, January 30, 2018, 6:35 AM, https://twitter.com/keithellison/status/9583479474896…
  73. Ted Lieu, Twitter post, November 12, 2017, 1:27 PM, https://twitter.com/tedlieu/status/929823016233533440
  74. Ted Deutch, Twitter post, May 1, 2018, 10:18 AM https://twitter.com/RepTedDeutch/status/991366376798515200
  75. and Martin Heinrich, Twitter post, February 8, 2018, 7:16 AM, https://twitter.com/MartinHeinrich/status/96161…
  76. 70. E. J. Dionne Jr., “Will the GOP Be the Pro-Putin Party?” Washington Post, December 18, 2016, https://www.…
  77. 71. Lindsey Graham, Twitter post, December 14, 2016, 3:18 PM, https://twitter.com/LindseyGrahamSC/status/8091…
  78. 72. Jennifer Rubin, Twitter post, December 15, 2016, 9:04 AM, https://twitter.com/JRubinBlogger/status/809444…
  79. 73. David Corn, “How Republicans Are Jumping on the New Steele Scoop to Distract from the Trump-Russia Scanda…
  80. 74. Corn, “How Republicans Are Jumping.”
  81. 75. Kathy Frankovic, “Belief in Conspiracies Largely Depends on Political Identity,” YouGov, December 27, 201…
  82. 76. “Trump-Putin Summit Is Over. The Head-Scratching? Not So Much,” New York Times, July 16, 2018, https://ww…
  83. 77. Rush Limbaugh, "This Is How Fake News Becomes the Narrative: 'Russia Hacked the Election'," The Rush Limb…
  84. and Joel B. Pollak, "10 Ways the CIA's 'Russian Hacking' Story Is Left-Wing 'Fake News'," Breitbart, December…
  85. 78. Tucker Carlson, Twitter Post, April 3 2017, 6:56 PM, https://twitter.com/TuckerCarlson/status/84907830486…
  86. 79. Kearney, “rtweet: Collecting Twitter Data.”
  87. 80. Tom Cotton, “Hearing to Receive Testimony on Foreign Cyber Threats to the United States,” United States S…
  88. 81. Matt Flegenheimer and Scott Shane, “Countering Trump, Bipartisan Voices Strongly Affirm Findings on Russi…
  89. 82. See Hayes Brown, “How Russia Hacked Obama’s Legacy,” BuzzFeed, April 13, 2017, https://www.buzzfeed.com/h…
  90. 83. David Zarefsky, “Presidential Rhetoric and the Power of Definition,” Presidential Studies Quarterly 34 (2…
     ↗
  91. 84. Justin Kirk, “Mitt Romney in Denver: ‘Obamacare’ as Ideological Enthymeme,” Journal of Argumentation in C…
     ↗
  92. 85. Frankovic, “Belief in Conspiracies.”
  93. 86. Kathy Frankovic, “Russia’s Impact on the Election Seen through Partisan Eyes,” YouGov, March 9, 2018, htt…
  94. 87. David Rothschild, “Democrats Have Basic Fact Problem,” PredictWise, February 2, 2017, https://predictwise…
  95. 88. Adam Badawy, Emilio Ferrara, and Kristina Lerman, “Analyzing the Digital Traces of Political Manipulation…
     ↗
  96. 89. Sarah Alkhateeb, “Cyber Crimes,” International Journal of Scientific and Engineering Research 7 (2016): 923.
  97. 90. Adam Penenberg, “The Real Meaning of ‘Hack’,” Reuters, July 26, 2011, http://blogs.reuters.com/mediafile/…
  98. 91. Penenberg, “The Real Meaning of ‘Hack’.”
  99. 92. Penenberg, “The Real Meaning of ‘Hack’.”
  100. 93. Max Fisher, “Q and A: What We Know about Russia’s Role in the U.S. Election,” Seattle Times, December 12,…
  101. 94. Intelligence Community Assessment, “Assessing Russian Activities,” 6.
  102. 95. Andrew Prokop, “The Hacked Emails at the Center of Mueller’s Russia Investigation, Explained,” Vox, last …
  103. 96. G. Thomas Goodnight, “The Personal, Technical, and Public Spheres of Argument: A Speculative Inquiry into…
     ↗
  104. 97. Ben Yagoda, “A Short History of Hack,” New Yorker, March 6, 2014, https://www.newyorker.com/tech/elements…
  105. 98. Douglas Thomas, Hacker Culture (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2002), 55.
  106. 99. Paul Taylor, Hackers: Crime in the Digital Sublime (London: Routledge, 1999), 10.
  107. 100. Mark Rolfe, The Reinvention of Populist Rhetoric in the Digital Age (Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan, 2016…
     ↗
  108. 101. Heather Murren, “On Cybersecurity, Nevada Has the Will but Will It Find a Way?” Nevada Independent, Febr…
  109. 102. Sherry Turkle, The Second Self: Computers and the Human Spirit (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2005), 189.
     ↗
  110. 103. Lynch, Stem Cells,7.
  111. 104. Ron Sanders, interview by Danielle A. Kingsbury, “The Psychology of Cyber Wargaming,” Cybersecpsych, Jun…
  112. 105. Beauchamp, “Democrats Are Falling for Fake News about Russia.”
  113. 106. Beauchamp, “Democrats Are Falling for Fake News about Russia.”
  114. 107. Steven Waldman and Charles Sennott, “The Crisis in Local Journalism Has Become a Crisis of Democracy,” W…
  115. 108. Mitchell et al., “Political Polarization and Media Habits.”
  116. 109. Reid Skibell, “The Myth of the Computer Hacker,” Information, Communication, and Society 5 (2002): 336.
     ↗
  117. 110. Nicholas Kristof, “President Trump, if You’re Innocent, Why Act So Guilty?” New York Times, February 7, …
  118. 111. Brian Beutler, “Fighting the Battle for Truth to a Draw,” Crooked, October 4, 2017, https://crooked.com/…
  119. 112. Chris Mooney, “Reality Bites,” American Prospect, June 6, 2011, http://prospect.org/article/reality-bites.
  120. 113. Beauchamp, “Democrats Are Falling for Fake News about Russia.”
  121. 114. Beauchamp, “Democrats are Falling for Fake News about Russia.”
  122. 115. Niloofar Razi Howe, “Opinion: No, Russia Didn’t Hack the Election,” Christian Science Monitor, March 1, …
  123. 116. Howe, “No, Russia Didn’t Hack the Election.”
  124. 117. Herb Lin, “Election Hacking, as We Understand It Today, Is Not a Cybersecurity Issue,” Lawfare, January …
  125. 118. Lin, “Election Hacking.”
  126. 119. Ryan Cooper, “Why Liberals Need to Get a Grip on Russia,” Week, January 3, 2017, http://theweek.com/arti…
  127. 120. Lin, “Election Hacking.”
  128. 121. Lin, “Election Hacking.”
  129. 122. Mark Hertling and Molly K. McKew, “Putin’s Attack on the U.S. Is Our Pearl Harbor,” Politico, July 16, 2…
  130. 123. Jim Waterson, “Hillary Clinton Suggests Russian Interference in US Election Was a ‘Cyber 9/11‘,” BuzzFee…
  131. 124. Morgan Chalfant, "Democrats Step Up Calls that Russian Hack Was Act of War," The Hill, March 26, 2017, h…
  132. Alex Lockie, "DICK CHENEY: 'No question' Russia Meddled in the US Election, and It Could be 'an Act of War',"…
  133. and Daniel Chaitin, "John McCain: Russian Cyberattacks 'an Act of War'," Washington Examiner, December 30, 20…
  134. 125. Herb Lin, “What Would Be a Sufficiently Strong Response to Russian Hacking of the U.S. Election?,” Lawfa…
  135. 126. Andrew Kirell, Twitter post, July 13, 2017, 9:45 AM, https://twitter.com/AndrewKirell/status/88554061355…
  136. 127. Myriam Dunn Cavelty, “The Militarisation of Cyber Security as a Source of Global Tension,” in Strategic …
  137. 128. Jeet Heer, “The Democrats’ Dangerous ‘War’ Rhetoric on Russia,” New Republic, July 17, 2017, https://new…
  138. 129. Paul Musgrave, “If You’re Even Asking if Russia Hacked the Election, Russia Got What It Wanted,” Washing…
  139. 130. Clint Watts, “Why Russia Wants the U.S. to Believe the Election Was Hacked,” PBS, October 26, 2016, http…
  140. 131. Matthew Gertz, “I’ve Studied the Trump-Fox Feedback Loop for Months. It’s Crazier than You Think,” Polit…
CrossRef global citation count: 3 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly Apr 2026
    Book Review: Environmental Preservation and the Grey Cliffs Conflict: Negotiating Common Narratives, Values, and Ethos PickeringK. (2024). Environmental Preservation and the Grey Cliffs Conflict: Negotiating Common Narratives, Values, and Ethos. Utah State University Press, 268 pp. ↗
    Mia Twomey
    argument book reviews
  2. Res Rhetorica Apr 2026
    Logos in ancient Greek discourse on rhetoric: An overview ↗
    Arkadiusz Sokolnicki
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument
  3. Assessing Writing Apr 2026
    Associations of adolescents’ argumentative writing scores and growth when evaluated by different human raters and artificial intelligence models ↗
    Deborah K. Reed; Sterett Mercer
    argument artificial intelligence
  4. Rhetoric of Health and Medicine Apr 2026
    Psyche or Soma?: An Analysis of the Medical Debates Over the Diagnosis and Treatment of “Transsexualism” ↗
    Samantha Rippetoe
    rhetorical criticism argument archival research
  5. Argumentation Mar 2026
    The Recursive Argument Structure Reconsidered ↗
    Shiyang Yu
    argument