Abstract

Abstract This essay examines the transvaginal ultrasound (TVU) debate that was ignited in the spring of 2012 by a Virginia law mandating the procedure as a prerequisite for first-trimester abortions. This debate represents a recent intensification of historical arguments grounded in how the abortion debate intersects with medical practice. By following the debate as it unfolded on pro-choice and pro-life blogs, this analysis uncovers three overarching topoi in the discourse mirrored on both sides: the medical necessity (or lack thereof) of the procedure; the importance of informed consent; and comparisons to rape. Using Foucault’s concept of the medical gaze, this essay argues that across all three topoi, both pro-choice and pro-life activists’ rhetoric relied heavily upon implicit assumptions of the superiority and necessity of medical science. The TVU debate demonstrates an argumentation strategy that both strips the issue of its political, legal, moral, and personal contexts and rhetorically positions pro-choice groups disadvantageously by obfuscating any discussion of women’s rights.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2018-12-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.21.4.0639
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (93)

  1. 1. Stuart Campbell, “A Short History of Sonography in Obstetrics and Gynaecology,” Facts, Views and Vision in…
  2. 2. Throughout this essay, I use the terms “pro-life” and “pro-choice” to designate the primary two groups of …
  3. 3. Celeste Condit, Decoding Abortion Rhetoric: Communicating Social Change (Champaign: University of Illinois…
  4. 4. See, for example, Julie Palmer, "Seeing and Knowing Ultrasound Images in the Contemporary Abortion Debate,…
  5. Carol Sanger, "Seeing and Believing: Mandatory Ultrasound and the Path to a Protected Choice," UCLA Law Revie…
Show all 93 →
  1. and Nathan Stormer, "Embodying Normal Miracles," Quarterly Journal of Speech 83 (1997): 172-91.
  2. 5. For examples of this critique, see Sanger, “Seeing and Believing”; Stormer, “Embodying Normal Miracles”; C…
  3. 6. I am using the bloggers’ own metrics for what success “looked like” in 2012. After McDonnell signed the fi…
  4. 7. I conceptualize vernacularity in concert with usage from Emily Chivers Yochim and Vesta T. Silva, "Everyda…
  5. Aaron Hess, "Democracy through the Polarized Lens of the Camcorder: Argumentation and Vernacular Spectacle on…
  6. and Kent A. Ono and John M. Sloop, "The Critique of Vernacular Discourse," Communication Monographs 62 (1995)…
  7. 8. Michel Foucault, The Birth of the Clinic (Abingdon, England: Psychology Press, 2003).
  8. 9. Foucault, The Birth of the Clinic, 241.
  9. 10. Klaus Amann and Karin Knorr Cetina, “The Fixation of Visual Evidence,” in Representation in Scientific Pr…
  10. 11. Petchesky, “Fetal Images”; and Stormer, “Embodying Normal Miracles.”
  11. 12. Valerie Hartouni, "Fetal Exposures: Abortion Politics and Optics of Allusion," in The Visible Woman: Imag…
  12. and Carol Stabile, "Shooting the Mother: Fetal Photography and the Politics of Disappearance," in The Visible…
  13. 13. Lisa M. Mitchell and Eugenia Georges, "Cross-Cultural Cyborgs: Greek and Canadian Women's Discourses on F…
  14. and Sara Rodrigues, "A Woman's 'Right to Know'? Forced Ultrasound Measures as an Intervention of Biopower," I…
  15. 14. José van Dijck, The Transparent Body: A Cultural Analysis of Medical Imaging, In Vivo (Seattle: Universit…
  16. 15. van Dijck, The Transparent Body, 7.
  17. 16. van Dijck, The Transparent Body, 8.
  18. 17. Angela Laflen, “(Re)presenting the Fetus: The Limits of Objective Vision in ‘Birthmates’ and ‘The Ultraso…
  19. 18. Laflen, “(Re)presenting the Fetus”; Lynn M. Morgan, “Strange Anatomy: Gertrude Stein and the Avant-Garde …
  20. 19. Chivers Yochim and Silva, “Everyday Expertise.”
  21. 20. Steven Epstein, “The Construction of Lay Expertise: AIDS Activism and the Forging of Credibility in the R…
  22. 21. Donna Haraway, “Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspe…
  23. 22. Chivers Yochim and Silva, “Everyday Expertise,” 411.
  24. 23. Helga Nowotny, “Democratising Expertise and Socially Robust Knowledge,” Science and Public Policy 30 (200…
  25. 24. Joanne Boucher, “Ultrasound: A Window to the Womb? Obstetric Ultrasound and the Abortion Rights Debate,” …
  26. 25. Sarah Franklin, “Science as Culture, Cultures of Science,” Annual Review of Anthropology 24 (1995): 163–84.
  27. 26. Michael Calvin McGee, “Text, Context, and the Fragmentation of Contemporary Culture,” Western Journal of …
  28. 27. Kevin Michael DeLuca and Jennifer Peeples, “From Public Sphere to Public Screen: Democracy, Activism, and…
  29. 28. Tanni Haas, “From ‘Public Journalism’ to the ‘Public’s Journalism’? Rhetoric and Reality in the Discourse…
  30. 29. Laura Gurak et al., “Introduction: Weblogs, Rhetoric, Community, and Culture,” University of Minnesota Di…
  31. 30. Hess, “In Digital Remembrance”; Daniel C. Brouwer and Aaron Hess, “Making Sense of ‘God Hates Fags’ and ‘…
  32. 31. Brouwer and Hess, “Making Sense”; and Carolyn R. Miller and Dawn Shepherd, “Blogging as Social Action: A …
  33. 32. Kurt Lindemann, “Live(s) Online: Narrative Performance, Presence, and Community in LiveJournal.com,” Text…
  34. 33. Alan G. Gross, “Evaluation after Publication: Setting the Record Straight in the Sciences,” in Science an…
  35. 34. These states are Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina…
  36. 35. Rodrigues, “A Woman’s ‘Right to Know’?”
  37. 36. Jillian Rayfield, “Vaginal Ultrasound Bills a Smokescreen, Say Pro-Choice Groups,” TPM (blog), February 2…
  38. 37. Kathy Byron, “Virginia Ultrasound Bill,” Pub. L. No. 462, § 18.2–76, 4 Va. Code Ann. (2012).
  39. 38. Andy Kopsa, “State-Sanctioned Rape: Trans-Vaginal Ultrasound Laws in Virginia, Texas, and Iowa,” Reproduc…
  40. 39. Kopsa, para. 19.
  41. 40. Andy Kopsa, “State Senator Coleman on Alabama’s Mandated Ultrasound Bill: ‘It’s Rape,’” Reproductive Heal…
  42. 41. Reticula, “I’m Serious. Stay out of My Vagina, Virginia,” BlogHer, February 21, 2012, para. 4, http://www…
  43. 42. Kelsey Anne Green, “Humiliation, Degradation, Penetration: What Legislatively Required Pre-Abortion Trans…
  44. 43. Molly Cummins, “Reproductive Surveillance: The Making of Pregnant Docile Bodies,” Kaleidoscope: A Graduat…
  45. 44. Iris Marion Young, “Throwing Like a Girl: A Phenomenology of Feminine Bodily Comportment, Motility, and S…
  46. 45. “Planned Parenthood Routinely Performs Vaginal Ultrasounds: Why Are Pro-Aborts Calling Them ‘Rape’?” Life…
  47. 46. Edward Schiappa, Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning (Carbondale: Southern Illinois…
  48. 47. Jill Stanek, “Abortion Proponents Equate Vaginal Ultrasound—Not Abortion—with Rape?” Jill Stanek (blog), …
  49. 48. Tyler James, “Opponents Villainize Va. Ultrasound Bill as ‘Gov’t Rape’,” CBN News (blog), February 23, 20…
  50. 49. James, “Opponents Villainize,” para. 3.
  51. 50. “Planned Parenthood Routinely Performs Vaginal Ultrasounds,” para. 5.
  52. 51. Elaine Gale Gerber, “Deconstructing Pregnancy: RU486, Seeing ‘Eggs,’ and the Ambiguity of Very Early Conc…
  53. 52. Rodrigues, “A Woman’s ‘Right to Know’?” 60.
  54. 53. Reticula, “I’m Serious,” para. 3.
  55. 54. Seddio, “War on Women,” para. 5.
  56. 55. Mary Gatter et al., “Relationship between Ultrasound Viewing and Proceeding to Abortion,” Obstetrics and …
  57. 56. Kopsa, “State Senator Coleman,” para. 8.
  58. 57. Mukhopadhyay, “McDonnell Signs Virginia Ultrasound Bill,” para. 2.
  59. 58. Susan Bordo, Unbearable Weight: Feminism, Western Culture, and the Body (Berkeley: University of Californ…
  60. 59. Bordo, Unbearable Weight, 79.
  61. 60. Jill Stanek, “The Feminists Who Cried Rape,” Jill Stanek (blog), March 7, 2012, para. 3, http://www.jills…
  62. 61. John Jalsevac, “Pro-Aborts ‘Completely Made Up’ Vaginal Ultrasound Requirement in Virginia Bill,” LifeSit…
  63. 62. Peter Conrad, “Medicalization and Social Control,” Annual Review of Sociology 18 (1992): 209–32; and Maur…
  64. 63. Conrad, “Medicalization and Social Control”; Robert Crawford, “Healthism and the Medicalization of Everyd…
  65. 64. Mitchell and Georges, “Cross-Cultural Cyborgs”; and Barbara Duden, Disembodying Women: Perspectives on Pr…
  66. 65. Jill Stanek, “The Ramifications of McDonnell’s Retreat on Virginia’s Ultrasound Bill,” Jill Stanek (blog)…
  67. 66. Stanek, “Abortion Proponents Equate Vaginal Ultrasound,” para. 9.
  68. 67. For example, in the Court opinion legalizing abortion, Justice Harry Blackmun emphasized the importance o…
  69. 68. The abortion-related mortality rate in the United States is about 0.7 per 100,000 abortions, whereas the …
  70. Elizabeth G. Raymond and David A. Grimes, "The Comparative Safety of Legal Induced Abortion and Childbirth in…
  71. Iqbal Shah and Elisabeth Åhman, "Unsafe Abortion: Global and Regional Incidence, Trends, Consequences, and Ch…
  72. and Lisa B. Haddad and Nawal M. Nour, "Unsafe Abortion: Unnecessary Maternal Mortality," Reviews in Obstetric…
  73. 69. This risk is disproportionately carried by women of color, poor women, and women living in rural areas du…
  74. 70. Condit, Decoding Abortion Rhetoric.
  75. 71. Condit, Decoding Abortion Rhetoric.
  76. 72. Reticula, “I’m Serious,” para. 12, 4, and 9.
  77. 73. Katie Halper, “At Least the Republicans Are Consistent: They Are for Probing Women’s Vaginas and against …
  78. 74. WomanInWashington, “From Your Navel To Your Knees,” BlogHer, March 2, 2012, para. 3, http://www.blogher.c…
  79. 75. Casey, “What I Learned in Virginia Today,” para. 4.
  80. 76. Patricia Geist and Jennifer Dreyer, “The Demise of Dialogue: A Critique of Medical Encounter Ideology,” W…
  81. 77. It should be noted here that one does not need a medical degree to perform an abortion safely, only the p…
  82. 78. Halper, “Shorter VA Governor,” para. 4.
  83. 79. “State Policies in Brief: Requirements for Ultrasound,” Guttmacher Institute, January 1, 2018, https://ww…
  84. 80. Caitlin Gibson, “The Abortion Rights Movement Is Bolder than It’s Been in Years. That’s Cecile Richards’s…
  85. 81. "State Policies in Brief: Requirements for Ultrasound."
  86. 82. “Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers,” Guttmacher Institute, January 1, 2018, https://www.guttmache…
  87. 83. "Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers."
  88. 84. "Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers."