Abstract

Abstract On November 18, 1999, Texas A&M University (TAMU) experienced profound tragedy when the famed Aggie Bonfire collapsed, killing 12 students and injuring 27 others. This essay examines the rhetorical dynamics of the TAMU Bonfire Memorial and explores how it navigates the tension created when a constitutive symbol is implicated in a moment of tragedy. Specifically, we use this case to explore how memorials help shape perceptions of victim agency in commemorative form. As we argue, the memorial taps into resonant modes of public reasoning—including temporal metaphors, Christian theology, and campus tradition—to imply the tragic outcome of the 1999 collapse had cause beyond human or institutional control. Our analysis of the Bonfire Memorial illustrates the importance of commemorative agency and, in particular, how eliding victim agency can limit epideictic encounters that might foster a sense of present and future engagement on unreconciled issues.

Journal
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Published
2018-03-01
DOI
10.14321/rhetpublaffa.21.1.0075
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Rhetoric & Public Affairs

References (148)

  1. “Injured Students in Search of Answers, Look Back on Events,”
  2. “Ring of Fire,”
  3. “Bonfire Collapse Texas A&M University,”
  4. “Tragedy at Texas A&M,”
  5. “The Aggie Bonfire Tragedy,”
Show all 148 →
  1. “Aggies, Shaken by Accident, Cling to Pride and Tradition,”
  2. “as many as 2,000 more scattered around on the ground.”
  3. “Bonfire Collapse,”
  4. “Bonfire: Tragedy and Tradition,”
  5. “Statement on the Texas A&M University Bonfire Tower Tragedy,”
  6. “Traditions”
  7. “A Crushing Wave of Wood,”
  8. A Centennial History of Texas A&M University
  9. “11/26/99,”
  10. “Design for Disaster?”
  11. “students blamed drinking as a contributing factor for bonfire related injuries. Because …
  12. “The Aggie Bonfire Tragedy,”
  13. “Bonfire Collapse,”
  14. “A Good Time Goes Bad,”
  15. “We Go Forward’: University Struggles to Find Means to Move On,”
  16. “Investigating Commission Felt ‘Call to Duty,’”
  17. “Picking up the Pieces,”
  18. “It is ironic that at a university as conservative as Texas A&M, many would like to set a…
  19. Monuments: America’s History in Art and Memory
  20. “capture the Aggie Spirit and the teamwork the Bonfire tradition has shown over the past …
  21. “The Vietnam Veterans Memorial,”
  22. “The Texas Aggie Bonfire: A Conservative Reading of Regional Narratives, Traditional Prac…
    Annals of the Association of American Geographers  
  23. “teacher of civic virtue.”
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  24. “The Function of Epideictic: The Boston Massacre Orations as Exemplar,”
    Communication Quarterly
  25. “The Practical Celebration of Epideictic,”
  26. “The Wall, the Screen, and the Image: The Vietnam Veterans Memorial,”
    Representations
  27. “Rhetorics of Display,”
  28. “Rhetorical Performative Discourse: A New Theory of Epideictic,”
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  29. “Aristotle on Epideictic,”
  30. “A Pentadic Analysis of Senator Edward Kennedy’s Chappaquiddick Address to the People of …
  31. “Agency: Promiscuous and Protean,”
    Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies
  32. “What Can Automation Tell Us about Agency?”
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  33. “What Is Agency?”
    American Journal of Sociology  
  34. “What Is Agency?”
  35. Lies Across America: What Our Historic Sites Get Wrong
  36. “The Presence of the Present: Hijacking ‘the Good War’?”
    Western Journal of Communication
  37. “The Vietnam Veterans Memorial: An Invitation to Argument,”
    Argumentation and Advocacy
  38. “Remembering and Forgetting the ‘Final Solution’: A Rhetorical Pilgrimage through the U.S…
    Critical Studies in Media Communication
  39. “In giving freedom to the slave, we assure freedom to the free—honorable alike in what we…
  40. “forever link the tradition to the tragedy of Nov. 18, 1999”
  41. “Granite Monument,”
  42. “the ‘real memorial’ would be a granite circle that marked the spot of the Bonfire’s cent…
  43. “Memorial Planners Say Site to Be ‘Uplifting,’”
  44. “The Aggie Bonfire Tragedy,”
  45. “Bonfire: Tragedy and Tradition,”
  46. The Texas Aggie Bonfire
  47. Footsteps: A Guided Tour of the Texas A&M University Campus
  48. A Centennial History of Texas A&M University
  49. Footsteps
  50. “Home of the 12th Man”
  51. “The Texas Aggie Bonfire,”
  52. “center-pole,”
  53. “Granite Monument,”
  54. “Thinking beyond Buildings: Monuments and Cemetery Stones as Visual Epideictic,”
  55. Monuments
  56. “Memorial Planners Say Site to Be ‘Uplifting.’”
  57. “Gone, but Not Forgotten: Bonfire Memorial Honors History of Bonfire, Fallen Aggies,”
  58. “Aggie Muster.”
  59. “Firm Says Memorial Gives Glimpses.”
  60. “Aggie Muster.”
  61. Monuments
  62. “Firm Says Memorial Gives Glimpses.”
  63. “12 perfect standing rectangles that loo[m] like open doorways … all leaving behind disti…
    Callaloo
  64. “Gone, but Not Forgotten.”
  65. “Granite Monument.”
  66. “the key to the project was to say what needed to be said and say no more.”
  67. “The Vietnam Veterans Memorial,”
  68. “all memory-sites as memorials,”
  69. Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience
  70. “individuals and societies endow their lives and actions with meaning.”
  71. “Temporal Metaphors,”
  72. “North.”
    Oxford English Dictionary
  73. “anteriority often signifies inferiority while posteriority implies superiority.”
  74. “Temporal Metaphors,”
  75. “images of full roundness help us to collect ourselves, permit us to confer an initial co…
  76. “Designing Memories … of What? Reading the Landscape of the Astronauts Memorial,”
  77. “What Is Agency?”
  78. “Public Memorializing in Postmodernity: The Vietnam Veterans Memorial as Prototype,”
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  
  79. “Reproducing Civil Rights Tactics: The Rhetorical Performances of the Civil Rights Memorial,”
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  80. “Memorial Planners Say Site to Be ‘Uplifting.’”
  81. “Memory and Reconciliation in the Birmingham Civil Rights Institute,”
    Rhetoric & Public Affairs
  82. “The Last Corps Trip”
  83. “The Texas A&M Bonfire Memorial, as Told by an Aggie,”
  84. Symbolism and Belief
  85. Symbolism and Belief
  86. Symbolism and Belief
  87. “Eternity,”
    Journal of Philosophy
  88. “A Memory in Progress,”
  89. “Bonfire Collapse,”
  90. “Granite Monument”
  91. “Bryan A. McClain ′02,”
  92. “Miranda Denise Adams ′02,”
  93. “Jamie Lynn Hand ′03,”
  94. “Michael Stephen Ebanks ′03,”
  95. “Jerry Don Self ′01,”
  96. “Nathan Scott West ′02,”
  97. “Miranda Denise Adams.”
  98. “Bryan A. McClain.”
  99. “Christopher Lee Heard ′03,”
  100. “Michael Stephen Ebanks.”
  101. “Timothy Doran Kerlee, Jr. ′03,”
  102. “Nathan Scott West.”
  103. “Jeremy Richard Frampton ′99,”
  104. “Michael Stephen Ebanks.”
  105. “Flying without Michael,”
  106. “Recent Work on Divine Foreknowledge and Free Will,”
  107. “On Ockham’s Way Out,”
  108. “The Aggie Bonfire Tragedy,”
  109. “Return of Bonfire Best Memorial to Deceased,”
  110. “Remember Loved Ones Left Behind,”
  111. “Remember Loved Ones Left Behind.”
  112. The Pride of Aggieland
  113. The Pride of Aggieland
  114. Angels on the Bonfire
  115. “Firm Says Memorial Gives Insight.”
  116. “Spirit”
  117. “Christ is often referred to as the ‘door to heaven.’”
  118. Stories in Stone
  119. Space and Place
  120. “hometown”
  121. “connect the viewer to the origins of the lives lost that November night.”
  122. “God is timeless and God’s beliefs are timeless as well.”
  123. “Recent Work on Divine Foreknowledge and Free Will,”
  124. “Other education”
  125. “It shouldn’t be about bonfire. It should be about these 12. The less said about bonfire,…
  126. “10 Year Remembrances May Be Last Ones Set Up by A&M,”
  127. “Buried by Bonfire,”
  128. “usefulness”
  129. “Agency,”
  130. “projectivity”
  131. “You hear people say, ‘We’ve been building Bonfire for ninety years, and this is the firs…
  132. “a marble reflecting pool placed next to an eternal flame,”
  133. “Memorial to Honor Fallen Ags,”
  134. “Comment: Guns and Terror,”
  135. “The Dilemma of Determinism,”
  136. “Public Memorializing in Postmodernity.”
  137. “what to think”
  138. “Rhetoric/Memory/Place,”
  139. “an encounter with what you don’t know, what you haven’t thought of, what you couldn’t co…