Crossing the Threshold with Apples, Potatoes, and Limes: Using the “Grocer’s Dilemma” to Introduce Law Students to Malleability in the Law
Abstract
The Grocer’s Dilemma is a legal writing (and thinking) assignment that can help undergraduate students interested in law school as well as first-year law students beginning their legal study better understand how legal rules are not fixed but are instead malleable—uncertain, flexible, and somewhat indeterminate. It asks students to consider, based on a grocer’s preference, where to place produce inside a grocery store. In this process, students must consider “precedents”—other produce—that contribute to the rule. Those precedents, however, do not have a fixed meaning. Instead, their meaning is malleable. Malleability is a threshold concept in the law. As such, when students become aware of and more comfortable with the concept of malleability, they can begin moving through the liminality of legal education and begin their journey across the threshold between legal novice and lawyer-expert. The Grocer’s Dilemma assignment focuses students on a nonlegal context for examining malleability, making it easier for students to focus on the complexities of reasoning about a malleable rule rather than the legal rules themselves.
- Journal
- Prompt: A Journal of Academic Writing Assignments
- Published
- 2024-07-16
- DOI
- 10.31719/pjaw.v8i2.192
- CompPile
- Search in CompPile ↗
- Open Access
- OA PDF Gold
- Topics
- Export
- BibTeX RIS
Citation Context
Cited by in this index (0)
No articles in this index cite this work.
References (0)
No references on file for this article.
Related Articles
-
Composition Forum Oct 2025
-
Written Communication Jan 2024Andrea Karsten
-
Composition Forum 2023Student to Scholar: Mentorship, Recontextualization, and the Threshold of Scholarly Publication in Rhetoric and Composition ↗Lindsey Ives and Linnea Spitzer
-
Written Communication Jul 2022Threshold Genres: A 10-Year Exploration of a Medical Writer’s Development and Social Apprenticeship Through the Patient SOAP Note ↗Dana Lynn Driscoll; Omar Yacoub
-
Composition Forum 2022Connecting Work-Integrated Learning and Writing Transfer: Possibilities and Promise for Writing Studies ↗Michael-John DePalma, Lilian W. Mina, Kara Taczak, Michelle J. Eady, Radhika Jaidev, and Ina Alexandra Machura