Abstract This article presents a prereading activity for Shakespeare's history plays, 2 Henry VI in particular. The activity involves students in carefully studying an anonymized family tree extending from Edward III through Richard III, choosing whom they believe to be the rightful heir, and posing arguments in support of their claim. The exploration of rhetoric and rule introduces students to key figures in the plays as well as the central theme of right rule. This problem-solving approach to early modern matters of succession has the further effect of introducing students to the idea that all claims to rule should be subjected to careful scrutiny.