Foregoing Charity in the Classroom

Kamil Lemanek Maria Curie-Skłodowska University

Abstract

Abstract This work advocates for an alternative to the principle of charity when teaching critical thinking or informal logic. It provides a brief reconstruction of the principle in the context of argumentation before moving to demonstrate some of the shortcomings associated with different approaches to it in the literature. It argues for placing emphasis not on charity but on the interpretative competence that underlies charity. Doing so avoids the difficulties associated with the principle as such while still fostering the conditions for exploring the kinds of advanced interpretations the pursuit of charity typically yields.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2025-09-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-025-09665-0
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (50) · 1 in this index

  1. Adler, J. 1981. Why be charitable?? Informal Logic 4(2):15–16. https://doi.org/10.22329/il.v4i2.2769
    Informal Logic  
  2. Adler, J. 1996. Charity, interpretation, fallacy. Philosophy and Rhetoric 29(4):329–343.
    Philosophy and Rhetoric
  3. Bailin, S., and M. Battersby. 2016a. Fostering the virtues of inquiry. Topoi 35(2):367–374. https://doi.org/1…
    Topoi  
  4. Bailin, S., and M. Battersby. 2016b. Reason in the balance: An inquiry approach to critical thinking, ed. M. …
  5. Argumentation
Show all 50 →
  1. Behar-Horenstein, L. S., and L. Niu. 2011. Teaching critical thinking skills in higher education: A review of…
  2. Browne, M., and S. Keeley. 2007. Asking the right questions: A guide to critical thinking. Pearson Education.
  3. Cohen, D. H. 1995. Argument is war… and war is hell: Philosophy, education, and metaphors for argumentation. …
    Informal Logic  
  4. Chernev, I. 1998. Logical chess: Move by move. Batsford.
  5. Davidson, D. 1965. Theories of meaning and learnable languages. In Y. Bar-Hillel (Ed.), Proceedings of the In…
  6. Davidson, D. 1967. Truth and meaning. Synthese 17(3):304–323.
    Synthese  
  7. Davidson, D. 1973. On the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme. Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philoso…
  8. Dutilh Novaes, C. 2020. The role of trust in argumentation. Informal Logic 40(2):205–236. https://doi.org/10.…
    Informal Logic  
  9. Dyrendal, A., and D. Jolley. 2020. Conspiracy theories in the classroom: Problems and potential solutions. Re…
    Religions  
  10. Ennis, R. H. 1987. A taxonomy of critical thinking dispositions and abilities. In Teaching thinking skills: T…
  11. Ennis, R. H. 1996. Critical thinking dispositions: Their nature and assessability. Informal Logic 18(2). http…
  12. Epstein, R. 2005. Critical thinking. 3rd ed. Wadsworth Publishing Company.
  13. Gauker, C. 1986. The principle of charity. Synthese 69(1):1–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01988284
    Synthese  
  14. Govier, T. 1981. Uncharitable thoughts about charity. Informal Logic 4(1):4–5. https://doi.org/10.22329/il.v4…
    Informal Logic  
  15. Govier, T. 1984. Who says there are no fallacies? Informal Logic 5(1):2–10.
    Informal Logic  
  16. Govier, T. 2013. A practical study of argument, enhanced edition. Cengage Learning.
  17. Govier, T. 2018. Problems in argument analysis and evaluation. University of Windsor.
  18. Grice, P. 1975. Logic and conversation. In Syntax and semantics 3: Speech acts, ed. P. Cole, and J. J. Morgan…
  19. Grice, P. 1989. Studies in the way of words. Harvard University Press.
  20. Hamby, B. 2013. Libri ad nauseam: The critical thinking textbook Glut. Philosophical Inquiry in Education, 21…
  21. Hamby, B. 2015. Willingness to Inquire: The Cardinal Critical Thinking Virtue. In M. Davies & R. Barnett (Eds…
  22. Hemming, H. E. 2000. encouraging critical thinking: but. what does that mean? McGill Journal of Education / R…
  23. Hinton, M. 2021. Evaluating the Language of Argument (Vol. 37). Springer International Publishing. https://do…
  24. Hundleby, C. 2010. The authority of the fallacies approach to argument evaluation. Informal Logic 30(3):279–3…
    Informal Logic  
  25. Johnson, R. 1980. Charity begins at home. Informal Logic 3(3):4–9.
    Informal Logic
  26. Kenyon, T. 2007. Clear thinking in a blurry world. Thomson Nelson.
  27. Lavery, J., and W. Hughes. 2008. Critical thinking, fifth edition: An introduction to the basic skills. Broadview.
  28. Lemanek, K. 2020. An unlikely source of (Absurd and Effective) case studies for introductory informal logic. …
    Informal Logic  
  29. Lewiński, M. 2012. The paradox of charity. Informal Logic 32(4):403. https://doi.org/10.22329/il.v32i4.3620
    Informal Logic  
  30. Lewis, D. 1974. Radical interpretation. Synthese 27(3/4):331–344.
    Synthese  
  31. Neale, S. 1992. Paul Grice and the philosophy of Language. Linguistics and Philosophy 15(5):509–559.
    Linguistics and Philosophy  
  32. Oswald, S. 2023. Pragmatics for argumentation. Journal of Pragmatics 203:144–156. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.p…
    Journal of Pragmatics  
  33. Quine, W. 1960. Word and object. MIT Press.
  34. Scriven, M. 1976. Reasoning. McGraw-Hill.
  35. Siegel, H. 1988. Educating reason. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315001722
  36. Snyder, L. G., and M. J. Snyder. 2008. Teaching critical thinking and problem solving skills. Delta Pi Epsilo…
    Delta Pi Epsilon Journal
  37. Sorensen, R. 1988. Blindspots. Oxford University Press.
  38. Sorensen, R. 2004. Charity implies Meta-Charity. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 68(2):290–315. http…
    Philosophy and Phenomenological Research  
  39. Stevens, K. 2020. Principle of Charity as a Moral Requirement in Non-Institutionalized Argumentation. OSSA Co…
  40. Stevens, K. 2021. Charity for moral reasons?– A defense of the principle of charity in argumentation. Argumen…
    Argumentation and Advocacy  
  41. Thagard, P., and R. E. Nisbett. 1983. Rationality and charity. Philosophy of Science 50(2):250–267. https://d…
    Philosophy of Science  
  42. Walton, D. 1993. The normative structure of case study argumentation. Metaphilosophy 24(3):207–226. https://d…
    Metaphilosophy  
  43. Walton, D. 2000. Problems and useful techniques: My experiences in teaching courses in argumentation, informa…
  44. Watson, J. C., R. Arp, and S. King. 2024. Critical Thinking: An Introduction to Reasoning Well (3rd ed.). Blo…
  45. Wilson, N. L. 1959. Substances without substrata. The Review of Metaphysics 12(4):521–539.
    The Review of Metaphysics