Argumentation Mar 2023 Open Access

Twitter Activists’ Argumentation Through Subdiscussions: Theory, Method and Illustration of the Controversy Surrounding Sustainable Fashion

Sara Greco Università della Svizzera italiana

Abstract

Abstract“Why are millions of dollars worth of orders being left unpaid?”. With tweets like this questioning brands’ policies, activists advocating for sustainable fashion re-discuss material starting points that are assumed by fashion brands, who argue that they are sustainable because they care about their workers’ conditions. This paper argues that activists use tweets to open subdiscussions on material starting points to engage citizens and consumers, re-discussing factual data that brands take for granted, such as the fact that they provide fair conditions for their garment workers. Activists justify their opening of subdiscussions, often through an argumentative pattern that includes an argument based on the locus from effects to cause. They argue that if there are negative effects, the brand cannot claim to care about the conditions of its workers. In discussing how subdiscussions are used by fashion activists, this paper also introduces a conceptualization of Twitter argumentation as a discussion that is not isolated, but is part of a polylogical argumentation that takes place in different venues. For this reason, the argumentation used in tweets is reconstructed as a response to a fashion brand’s communication campaigns around sustainability, which extend beyond the confines of Twitter. As an empirical illustration, this paper is based on the campaign targeting fashion retailer Primark; the dataset includes the brand’s website as well as activists’ tweets.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2023-03-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-022-09579-1
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
argument social media editorial matter
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (2)

  1. Jackson (2025)
    Studying Controversies: A Path for Expansion of Argumentation Theory
    Argumentation
  2. Musi (2024)
    Framing to Make an Argument: The Case of the Genocide Hashtag in the Russia-Ukr…
    Argumentation

References (47) · 4 in this index

  1. Aakhus et al. (2017)
    Advancing Polylogical Analysis of Large-Scale Argumentation: Disagreement Manag…
    Argumentation
  2. W Ahmed (2017)
    The ethics of online research. Advances in research ethics and integrity
     ↗
  3. Bakhtin, M. M. 1981. The dialogic imagination. Four essays. Edited by M. Holquist. Austin: University of Texa…
  4. E Balabanova (2020)
    Balabanova, E., and R. Palmieri. 2020. Talking at cross-purpose? ASOS, twitter and the fast-fashion backlash.…
     ↗
  5. P Balsiger (2014)
    The fight for ethical fashion. The origins and interactions of the clean clothes campaign
Show all 47 →
  1. E Brambilla (2019)
    Argumentation in actual practice. Topical studies about argumentative discourse in context
     ↗
  2. Clean Clothes. 2021. Breaking point: Wage theft, violence and excessive workloads are pushing garment workers…
  3. L Dach (2014)
    Dach, L., and K. Allmendiger. 2014. Sustainability in corporate communications and its influence on consumer …
    Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences  ↗
  4. Dascal, M. 1989/2003. Understanding controversies. Reprinted in Dascal, M. 2003. Interpretation and understan…
     ↗
  5. O De Castro (2021)
    Loved clothes last. How the joy of rewearing and repairing your clothes can be a revoluti…
  6. K Elliott-Maksymowicz (2021)
    Elliott-Maksymowicz, K., A. Nikolaev, and D. Porpora. 2021. How much can you say in a tweet? An approach to p…
    Humanities and Social Sciences Communications  ↗
  7. Fashion Revolution (2021). Fashion Transparency Index 2021. Available at: https://issuu.com/fashionrevolution…
  8. A Foderaro (2022)
    Foderaro, A., and D.G. Lorentzen. 2022. Argumentative practices and patterns in debating climate change on Tw…
    Aslib Journal of Information Management  ↗
  9. F Giglietto (2012)
    Giglietto, F., L. Rossi, and D. Bennato. 2012. The open laboratory: Limits and possibilities of using Faceboo…
    Journal of Technology in Human Services  ↗
  10. J Goodwin (2020)
    Goodwin, J. 2020. Should climate scientists fly? A case study of arguments at the system level. Informal Logi…
    Informal Logic  ↗
  11. S Greco (2021)
    Greco, S., and B. De Cock. 2021. Argumentative misalignments in the controversy surrounding fashion sustainab…
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  12. S Greco (2021)
    Greco, S., C. Mercuri, and B. De Cock. 2021. Victims or agents for change? The representation and self-repres…
    Babylonia  ↗
  13. A Gregory (2010)
    Planning and managing public relations campaigns. A strategic approach
  14. L Groarke (2019)
    Informal logic: A “Canadian” approach to argument
  15. S Jackson (2019)
    Jackson, S. 2019. Reason-giving and the natural normativity of argumentation. Topoi 38(4): 631–643. https://d…
    Topoi  ↗
  16. O Karamalak (2021)
    Fashion communication
     ↗
  17. O Karamalak (2021)
    Karamalak, O., N. Kalbaska, and L. Cantoni. 2021. What do hashtags afford in digital fashion communication? A…
    Semiotica  ↗
  18. C Kerbrat-Orecchioni (2004)
    Kerbrat-Orecchioni, C. (2004) Introducing polylogue. Journal of Pragmatics 36(1): 1–24. https://doi.org/10.10…
    Journal of Pragmatics  ↗
  19. ECW Krabbe (2003)
    Anyone who has a view: Theoretical contributions to the study of argumentation
     ↗
  20. Lewiński et al. (2014)
    Argumentative Polylogues in a Dialectical Framework: A Methodological Inquiry
    Argumentation
  21. Mercuri, C. in preparation. Conflicting frames and argumentation in controversies over fashion sustainability…
  22. D Mohammed (2019)
    Proceedings of the ninth conference of the international society for the study of argumentation
  23. Musi et al. (2018)
    Discovering Argumentative Patterns in Energy Polylogues: A Macroscope for Argum…
    Argumentation
  24. J Orminski (2021)
    Orminski, J., E.C. Tandoc Jr., and B.H. Detenber. 2021. #sustainablefashion—A conceptual framework for sustai…
    Environmental Communication  ↗
  25. Palmieri et al. (2016)
    Multiple Audiences as Text Stakeholders: A Conceptual Framework for Analyzing C…
    Argumentation
  26. E Rigotti (2019)
    Inference in argumentation: A topics-based approach to argument schemes
     ↗
  27. FR Rinaldi (2019)
    Fashion industry 2030: Reshaping the future through sustainability and responsible innovation
  28. S Roginsky (2015)
    Roginsky, S., and B. De Cock. 2015. Faire campagne sur Twitter. Modalités d’énonciation et mises en récit des…
    Les Cahiers Du Numérique  ↗
  29. R Schaefer (2021)
    Schaefer, R., and M. Stede. 2021. Argument mining on Twitter: A survey. Information Technology 63(1): 45–58. …
    Information Technology  ↗
  30. R Schär (2017)
    Schär, R. 2017. Definitional arguments in children’s speech. L’analisi Linguistica e Letteraria 15: 173–192.
    L’analisi Linguistica e Letteraria
  31. R Schär (2021)
    An argumentative analysis of the emergence of issues in adult–children discussions
  32. W Sinnott-Armstrong (2015)
    Understanding arguments: An introduction to informal logic
  33. L Sluiter (2009)
    Clean clothes. A global movement to end sweatshops
  34. A Tseronis (2020)
    Proceedings of the 3rd European conference on argumentation
  35. Tuite, A. 2018. Communicating material characteristics in a digital age: Three case studies in independent fa…
     ↗
  36. FH van Eemeren (2017)
    Prototypical argumentative patterns. Exploring the relationship between argumentative dis…
     ↗
  37. FH van Eemeren (2018)
    Argumentation theory: A pragma-dialectical perspective
     ↗
  38. FH van Eemeren (2004)
    A systematic theory of argumentation: The pragma-dialectical approach
  39. FH van Eemeren (1993)
    Reconstructing argumentative discourse
  40. van Laar, J. A. 2003. The dialectic of ambiguity: A contribution to the study of argumentation. PhD dissertat…
  41. SR Wallinger (2015)
    Routledge handbook of sustainability and fashion
  42. M Zappavigna (2018)
    Searchable talk. Hashtags and social media metadiscourse
CrossRef global citation count: 16 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Philosophy & Rhetoric Apr 2025
    Introduction: On the Desirability of Speaking to Others ↗
    Nirvana Tanoukhi; Nicholas Dunn
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument social media race and writing gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric literary studies editorial matter
  2. Philosophy & Rhetoric Sep 2024
    Where’s the Rhetoric? Imagining a Unified Field ↗
    Joshua Hanan
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism composition theory genre theory discourse analysis cultural rhetorics argument qualitative research quantitative research digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric affect and writing body and rhetoric editorial matter
  3. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Sep 2024
    Populist Rhetorics Case Studies and a Minimalist Definition ↗
    Arthur E. Walzer
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument digital rhetoric social media disability studies public rhetoric editorial matter
  4. The Peer Review Sep 2024
    Honor Consultant Safety: A Community Contract for Better Writing Center Ethics ↗
    Liz A. W. Thomae; Aleena A. Jacob
    rhetorical criticism decolonial rhetorics writing pedagogy argument collaborative writing writing centers peer tutoring archival research social media race and writing gender and writing disability studies affect and writing literary studies editorial matter
  5. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Jun 2024
    Organs for Sale: Bioethics, Neoliberalism, and Public Moral Deliberation ↗
    Sam Shear
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument social media disability studies public rhetoric editorial matter