Abstract

AbstractSocratic irony can be understood independently of the immortal heroics of Plato’s Socrates. We need a systematic account and criticism of it both as a debate-winning strategy of argumentation and teaching method. The Speaker introduces an issue pretending to be at a lower intellectual level than her co-debaters, or Participants. An Audience looks over and evaluates the results. How is it possible that the Speaker like Socrates is, consistently, in the winning position? The situation is ironic because the Participants fight from a losing position but realize it too late. Socratic irony compares with divine irony: divine irony is a subtype of Socratic irony since you lose when you challenge gods. Socratic irony is also, prima facie, a subtype of dramatic irony when the Audience knows more than the Participants on the stage.We must distinguish between the ideal and realistic elements of Socratic Irony. The very idea of Socratic irony looks idealized, or it is an ideal case, which explains the Speaker’s consistently winning position. In real life, the debate must be rigged, or the Dutch Book argument applies to the Participants, if the Speaker is so successful.

Journal
Argumentation
Published
2022-03-01
DOI
10.1007/s10503-021-09556-0
CompPile
Open Access
OA PDF Hybrid
Topics
Export

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (51) · 1 in this index

  1. Aikin, S. 2008. Perelmanian universal audience and the epistemic aspirations of argument. Philosophy & Rhetor…
    Philosophy & Rhetoric  
  2. Airaksinen, Timo. 2021. Socrates meets the crocodile, or the ironies of Brecht’s and Wuolijoki’s Herr Puntila…
    Finnish-German Yearbook of Political Economy
  3. Aristophanes, Clouds. Tr. by “The Atticist.” 2021 (https://aristophanes-clouds.gr/).
  4. Aristotle, The art of rhetoric. Tr. by Robin Waterfield. 2018. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  5. Recovering bishop Berkeley.
Show all 51 →
  1. Broadie, Alexander. 1968. The practical syllogism. Analysis 29: 26–28.
    Analysis  
  2. Chappell, Timothy. 2005. Reading Plato's Theaetetus. Indianapolis: Hackett.
  3. Philosophy & Rhetoric
  4. American heritage dictionary (https://www.ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=irony). Accessed 8.9.2021.
  5. Dynel, Marta. 2017. The irony of irony: Irony based on truthfulness. Corpus Pragmatics 1: 3–36.
    Corpus Pragmatics  
  6. Euripides, Bacchae. Tr. Ian Johnston. 2020. (http://johnstoniatexts.x10host.com/).
  7. Ferrari, G.R.F. 2008. Socratic irony as pretense. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 34: 1–33.
    Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy
  8. Fine, Gail. 2008. Does Socrates claim to know that he knows nothing? Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 35:…
    Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy  
  9. Firth, Roderick. 1951. Ethical absolutism and the ideal observer. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 12…
    Philosophy and Phenomenological Research  
  10. Frigerio, Aldo, and Ciro Florio. 2015. Two omnipotent beings? Philosophia 43: 309–324.
    Philosophia
  11. Gettier, Edmund. 1963. Is justified true belief knowledge. Analysis 23: 121–123.
    Analysis  
  12. Goldie, Peter, “Dramatic irony, narrative, and the external perspective.” Royal Institute of Philosophy Suppl…
  13. Gottlieb, Paula. 1992. The complexity of Socratic irony: A note on professor Vlastos’ account. Classical Quar…
    Classical Quarterly  
  14. The blackwell guide to Aristotle's nicomachean ethics
  15. Scepticism and the possibility of knowledge
  16. Divine irony
  17. Squaring the circle. The war between Hobbes and Wallis
  18. Lewis, David. 1979. Attitudes de dicto and de se. Philosophical Review 88: 513–543.
    Philosophical Review  
  19. Magrini, James Michael. 2014. Dialectic and dialogue in Plato: Refuting the model of Socrates-as-teacher in t…
    Educational Philosophy and Theory  
  20. Miller, Leonard G. 1957. Descartes, mathematics, and God. Philosophical Review 66: 451–465.
    Philosophical Review  
  21. Mintz, Avi I. 2014. Why did Socrates deny that he was a teacher? Locating Socrates among the new educators an…
    Educational Philosophy and Theory  
  22. Scepticism
  23. Nathan, Daniel. 1992. Irony, metaphor, and the problem of intention. In Intention and Interpretation, ed. Gar…
  24. The new rhetoric
  25. Piering, Julie. 2010. Irony and shame in Socratic ethics. International Philosophical Quarterly 50: 473–488.
    International Philosophical Quarterly  
  26. Plato, Meno. Tr. by Sophie Grace Chappell. https://www.academia.edu/13448466/Platos_Meno_a_new_translation. (…
  27. Plato, Theaetetus. Tr. by John McDowell. 2014. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  28. Potter, Garry. 2010. Power and knowledge. A dialectical contradiction. Journal of Critical Realism 9: 133–154.
    Journal of Critical Realism  
  29. Rapp, Christof. Aristotle's rhetoric. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2010 Edition), Edward N…
  30. Aporetics: Rational deliberation in the face of inconsistency
  31. Contingency, irony, and solidarity
  32. The concept of mind
  33. Shea, Mark. 2010. Divine irony. National Catholic Register (http://www.mark-shea.com/di.html).
  34. Siitonen, Arto. 1989. Problems of aporetics. Helsinki: Annales Academiae Scientiarum Fennicae.
  35. Solomon, Robert C. 2003. On fate and fatalism. Philosophy East and West 53: 435–454.
    Philosophy East and West  
  36. Plato’s use of fallacy: A study of the euthydemus and some other dialogues
  37. Stone, Mark A. 2012. Denying the antecedent: Its effective use in argumentation. Informal Logic 32: 327–356.
    Informal Logic  
  38. Reasons and knowledge
  39. Rhetorical argumentation: Principles of theory and practice
  40. Vasiliou, Iakovos. 1999. Conditional irony in the Socratic dialogues. Classical Quarterly 49: 456–472.
    Classical Quarterly  
  41. Aiming at virtue in plato
  42. The bloomsbury companion to socrates
  43. Vlastos, Gregory. 1987. Socratic irony. Classical Quarterly 37: 79–96.
    Classical Quarterly  
  44. Wengert, R.G. 1988. The paradox of the midwife. History of Philosophy Quarterly 5: 3–10.
    History of Philosophy Quarterly
  45. Xenophon. Apology of Socrates. In Xenophon in Seven Volumes, 4. Tr. by O. J. Todd. 1979. Cambridge, MA: Harva…
  46. Zyskind, Harold, and R. Sternfeld. 1976. Plato’s Meno 89 C: Virtue is knowledge. A hypothesis? Phronesis 21: …
    Phronesis