Can ethics be technologized? Lessons from Challenger, philosophy, and rhetoric

P.M. Dombrowski

doi:10.1109/47.406727

IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication Jan 1995

Can ethics be technologized? Lessons from Challenger, philosophy, and rhetoric

P.M. Dombrowski

Abstract

Technology informs many aspects of our lives. Many critics perceive technology as a system of values, seeing it as an incomplete "ethic". I explore the converse. Using Ellul's (1990) technique (translated as "technologism"), I ask, "Can ethics be technologized?" I show how the Challenger disaster delimits the range of technologism with regard to ethics. Collecting additional technical information cannot of itself prevent ethical lapses. Furthermore, the investigations implicitly show the assumption that technologism can apply to ethics in their call for additional procedures. The recognition that procedures already in place were adequate, however, shows this assumption to be fallacious. I also show that trying to technologize ethics is a recent instance of an old reductive fallacy. The ancient sophists were criticized for trying to technologize both rhetoric and ethics. In recent philosophy, too, many critics insist that ethics cannot be reduced, systematized or technologized. Ethics then is innately problematic, so ethical choices must always be continually deliberated among people in an indeterminate way.< <ETX xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">></ETX>

Journal: IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
Published: 1995-01-01
DOI: 10.1109/47.406727
CompPile
Open Access: Closed
Topics: rhetorical criticism
Export: BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (13)

Pietrucci et al. (2019)

Scientist Citizens: Rhetoric and Responsibility in L’Aquila

Rhetoric & Public Affairs
Pflugfelder (2018)

Failure Matters: Conflicting Practices in a High-Tech Case

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Dombrowski (2011)

Practicing “Safe” Technical Communication

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Ward (2010)

The Ethic of Exigence: Information Design, Postmodern Ethics, and the Holocaust

Journal of Business and Technical Communication
Dombrowski (2007)

The Evolving Face of Ethics in Technical and Professional Communication: Challe…

IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication

Show all 13 →

Malone (2007)

Historical Studies of Technical Communication in the United States and England:…

IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
Dombrowski (2006)

The Two Shuttle Accident Reports: Context and Culture in Technical Communication

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Dombrowski (2002)

Language and Empiricism

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Faber (2001)

Gen/Ethics? Organizational Ethics and Student and Instructor Conflicts in Workp…

Technical Communication Quarterly
Dombrowski (2001)

Plastic Language for Plastic Science: The Rhetoric of Comrade Lysenko

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Dombrowski (2000)

Ethics and Technical Communication: The Past Quarter Century

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Dombrowski (2000)

Ethics and Technical Communication: The Past Quarter Century

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Dragga (1997)

A Question of Ethics: Lessons from Technical Communicators on the Job

Technical Communication Quarterly

References (28) · 9 in this index

Markel (1991)

A Basic Unit on Ethics for Technical Communicators

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
Clark (1987)

Ethics in technical communication: A rhetorical perspective

IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
10.1177/002194368502200103

↗
johannesen (1990)

Ethics in Human Communication
(1994)

Humanistic Aspects of Technical Communication

Show all 28 →

Buchholtz (1989)

Deciphering professional codes of ethics

IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
Sturges (1992)

Overcoming the ethical dilemma: communication decisions in the ethic ecosystem

IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
Dombrowski (1992)

Challengerand the social contingency of meaning: Two lessons for the technical …

Technical Communication Quarterly
Winsor (1990)

The Construction of Knowledge in Organizations: Asking the Right Questions abou…

Journal of Business and Technical Communication
Pace (1988)

Technical Communication, Group Differentiation, and the Decision to Launch the …

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
levinas (1990)

Collected Philosophical Papers
marx (1988)

The Pilot and the Passenger Essays on Literature Technology and Culture in the United States
grene (1984)

Introduction to Existentialism
winner (1986)

The Whale and the Reactor A Search for Limits in an Age of High Technology
keller (1989)

Feminism & Science
harding (1986)

The Science Question in Feminism
miller (1989)

Technical Writing Theory and Practice
sullivan (1990)

Political-ethical implications of defining technical communication as a practice

J Adv Composition
monsma (1986)

Responsible Technology A Christian Perspective
10.2307/378062

↗
ellul (1990)

The Technological Bluff
MOORE (1992)

When Politeness is Fatal: Technical Communication and the Challenger Accident

Journal of Business and Technical Communication
(1987)

Investigation of the Challenger Accident Report of the Committee on Science and Technology
Dombrowski (1991)

The lessons of the Challenger investigations

IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication
kerferd (1981)

The Sophistic Movement
(1986)

Report to the President by the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident
10.1061/(ASCE)1052-3928(1997)123:1(23)

↗
guthrie (1971)

10.1017/CBO9780511627385

The Sophists ↗

CrossRef global citation count: 17 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Can ethics be technologized? Lessons from Challenger, philosophy, and rhetoric

Abstract

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (13)

References (28) · 9 in this index

Related Articles