Rhetoric Society Quarterly Jan 2023

Feminist Witnessing from the Bench: A Study of Judge Aquilina’s Epideictic Rhetoric in the Nassar Sentencing Hearing

Shari J. Stenberg Schlumberger (Ireland)

Abstract

ABSTRACTDuring a 2018 sentencing hearing of former Olympics and Michigan State University doctor Larry Nassar, 156 survivors offered Victim Impact Statements, and Judge Rosemarie Aquilina made national headlines for her impassioned responses to each survivor. This essay shows how Aquilina’s responses use epideictic rhetoric to make audible a judicial practice of feminist witnessing of assault testimony. In so doing, Aquilina challenges the way blame “sticks” to survivors and casts a scrutinizing gaze on a culture that silences survivors; praises the individual act of testimony and constitutes a collective of “sister survivors,” thereby fostering connection and potential for coalition building; and reframes sexual assault testimony as a public act with socially transformative effects.KEYWORDS: Epideictic rhetoricfeminist judicial theoryfeminist witnessingsexual assault Disclosure StatementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 I rely on the VIS reproduced on the website In Our Own Words, a resource created by Heartland Independent Film Forum and sponsored by the Michigan Daily Newspaper, MSU’s student paper. Because the statements were published with survivors’ permission on inourwords.org as an educational resource, I have used the survivor’s name if it was released. In cases where it was not, I use the number or symbols that appear on inourwords.org.2 The VIS followed Nassar’s guilty plea to seven counts of sexual misconduct. Although the plea deal meant there would be no public criminal trial during which survivors could testify, Aquilina invited any survivor impacted by Nassar’s abuse, including parents, to offer a statement.3 Aquilina’s vengeance-focused comments also received criticism from feminists, even as they often acknowledged them as an understandable response to Nassar’s abhorrent acts (Gruber; Press). Her comments, in this moment, demonstrate the limitations of what Elizabeth Bernstein calls carceral feminism, wherein criminal prosecution is viewed as a solution to gender violence, without attention to the ways criminal law is entrenched in “masculinism, racism and cruelty” (Gruber).

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
2023-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773945.2022.2078871
CompPile
Open Access
Closed
Topics
classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism race and writing gender and writing editorial matter
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (40) · 2 in this index

  1. Ahmed Sara. (2015)
    The Cultural Politics of Emotion
  2. 10.2307/1341478
     ↗
  3. 10.1017/S0143814X98000038
     ↗
  4. Cacciola, Scott. “Victims in Larry Nassar Abuse Case Find a Fierce Advocate: The Judge.” The New York Times, …
  5. Chamallas Martha (2013)
    Introduction to Feminist Legal Theory
Show all 40 →
  1. Charmaz Kathy (2014)
    Constructing Grounded Theory
  2. CNN Staff. “Read Judge Rosemarie Aquilina’s Powerful Statement to Larry Nassar.” CNN, Cable News Network, 25 …
  3. Connor Tracy (2018)
    NBCUniversal News Group
  4. Crawford Bridget J. (2018)
    University of Baltimore Law Review
  5. 10.1080/00335630.2015.999985
     ↗
  6. Freyd Jennifer (2008)
    Encyclopedia of Psychological Trauma
  7. Freyd Jennifer J. (2013)
    Blind to Betrayal: Why We Fool Ourselves We Aren’t Being Fooled
  8. 10.1080/07491409.2020.1839991
     ↗
  9. Gilmore Leigh (2018)
    Robert E. Knoll Lecture Series
  10. Gilmore Leigh (2018)
    Tainted Witness: Why We Doubt What Women Say about Their Lives
  11. Gruber, Amy. “In the Fight for Gender Justice, Criminal Law Should Be a Last Resort: Aeon Essays.” Aeon, 22 J…
  12. Hunter Rosemary C (2010)
    Feminist Judgments: From Theory to Practice
  13. In Our Own Words. Inourownwords.us. 2018.
  14. Johnny Saldaña (2016)
    The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers
  15. Joseph Elizabeth.
    CNN
  16. Kaufman Gina (2018)
    USA Today, Gannett Satellite Information Network
  17. Kozlowski Kim.
    The Detroit News
  18. 10.7560/768208
     ↗
  19. Macur, Juliet, and Michael Levenson. “Inspector General Says F.B.I. Botched Nassar Abuse Investigation.” The …
  20. Marshall Rachel (2018)
    Vox
  21. North Anna (2018)
    Vox
  22. 10.1007/s10691-020-09421-7
     ↗
  23. Press Alex (2018)
    Vox
  24. Propen et al. (2010)
    Understanding Genre through the Lens of Advocacy: The Rhetorical Work of the Vi…
    Written Communication
  25. Reinstein Julia (2018)
    BuzzFeed News
  26. 10.1177/026975800401000302
     ↗
  27. Schuster Mary (2019)
    Victim’s Voice in the Sexual Misconduct Crisis: Identity, Credibility, and Proof
  28. 10.1177/1743872109349104
     ↗
  29. 10.2307/378414
     ↗
  30. “Statistics.” National Sexual Violence Resource Center. www.nsvrc.org/statistics.
  31. Swenson, Kyle. “Gymnastics Victims’ Champion or Avenger? Nassar Judge Rosemarie Aquilina Stirs Controversy.” …
  32. 10.1177/026975800601300301
     ↗
  33. Waimberg, Joshua. “The Supreme Court’s Utah V. Strieff Decision and the Fourth Amendment.” The National Const…
  34. 10.1080/10570310500076817
     ↗
  35. Wright (2019)
    “The Caprices of an Undisciplined Fancy”: Using Blame to Negotiate the “between…
    Rhetoric Review
CrossRef global citation count: 1 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Philosophy & Rhetoric Sep 2024
    Style: A Queer Cosmology ↗
    Joe Edward Hatfield
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism teacher development race and writing gender and writing literary studies editorial matter
  2. Rhetoric Review Jul 2023
    Imagining Protection from Domestic Gun Violence ↗
    Craig Rood
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism race and writing gender and writing editorial matter
  3. Philosophy & Rhetoric Jul 2013
    The State of Speech ↗
    Kathleen Lamp
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis argument archival research race and writing gender and writing public rhetoric editorial matter
  4. Philosophy & Rhetoric Jun 2012
    Introduction ↗
    Stephen Howard Browne
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis writing pedagogy revision argument archival research qualitative research race and writing gender and writing public rhetoric editorial matter
  5. Pedagogy Jan 2026
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism genre theory writing pedagogy graduate education two-year college teacher development social media race and writing gender and writing affect and writing literary studies editorial matter