Rhetoric Society Quarterly Aug 2021

Graphed into the Conversation: Conspiracy, Controversy, and Climategate’s Visual Style

Dustin A. Greenwalt Russian State Agrarian Correspondence University ; Atilla Hallsby Schlumberger (Ireland)

Abstract

This essay reads the 2009 Climategate blogosphere through the rubric of visual style. We argue that Climategate bloggers used the stolen e-mails between prominent climate scientists to leverage claims about the proper perspective for seeing data, imitate institutional forms of climatological inquiry, and posit transparency as a moral imperative in many online forums. Rather than attacking science tout court, these appeals to visibility operated on the grounds of visuality and proof established by institutional forms of scientific inquiry, thus alleging climate change-denying bloggers were the “actual” scientists. By forwarding alternative visualizations of global temperature data and characterizing institutional climatology as secretive, Climategate bloggers significantly shaped public understandings of global warming. Ultimately, our purpose is to show how a visual style is an ambivalent form of rhetoric that scientific experts may also deploy in public science communication.

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
2021-08-08
DOI
10.1080/02773945.2021.1947515
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism scientific writing digital rhetoric
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (1)

  1. Shaw (2023)
    Toxic Contamination and Land-Body Relations: Storytelling, Metaphor, and Topoi …
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly

References (78) · 4 in this index

  1. 10.1080/00335630109384319
     ↗
  2. Banning Marlia E. (2009)
    10.1080/14791420903049736
    Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies  ↗
  3. Barthes Roland (1972)
    Mythologies
  4. 10.1080/10417941003642403
     ↗
  5. 10.1093/aristotelian/55.1.273
     ↗
Show all 78 →
  1. 10.1080/10510974.2012.749294
     ↗
  2. Burke Kenneth (1945)
    A Grammar of Motives
  3. ——— (1935)
    Permanence and Change: An Anatomy of Purpose
  4. Cacciari Cristina (2008)
    “Crossing the Senses in Metaphorical Language.” The Cambridge Handbook of Metaphor and Th…
  5. Camper Martin (2018)
    Arguing over Texts: The Rhetoric of Interpretation
  6. 10.1353/rap.2010.0222
     ↗
  7. Collins Luke C. (2016)
    10.1177/0963662515579626
    Public Understanding of Science  ↗
  8. Courrielche, Patrick. “Peer-to-Peer Review: How ‘Climategate’ Marks the Maturing of a New Science Movement, P…
  9. Crick et al. (2010)
    The Conduit Between Lifeworld and System: Habermas and the Rhetoric of Public S…
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  10. Douglass, David H., and John R. Christy. “A Climatology Conspiracy?” American Thinker, 20 Dec. 2009, https://…
  11. Eamon William (1985)
    10.1007/BF01096442
    Minerva  ↗
  12. 10.1016/j.futures.2010.12.004
     ↗
  13. Fritch John (2006)
    10.1080/00028533.2006.11821654
    Argumentation and Advocacy  ↗
  14. Galison Peter (1999)
    Agnotology: The Making and Unmaking of Ignorance
  15. Goodnight G. Thomas (1982)
    Journal of the American Forensic Association
  16. 10.1080/10570318109374052
     ↗
  17. Gronbeck Bruce E. (1993)
    Rhetorical Memory and Delivery: Classical Concepts for Contemporary Composition and Commu…
  18. Gross Alan G. (2006)
    Starring the Text: The Place of Rhetoric in Science Studies
  19. Gross Alan G. (2016)
    The Internet Revolution in the Sciences and Humanities
     ↗
  20. Grundmann Reiner (2011)
    10.1177/0162243911432318
    Science, Technology & Human Values  ↗
  21. Hagan (2007)
    Visual/Verbal Collaboration in Print: Complementary Differences, Necessary Ties…
    Written Communication
  22. Hawhee (2011)
    Looking Into Aristotle's Eyes: Toward a Theory of Rhetorical Vision
    Advances in the History of Rhetoric
  23. Jasanoff Sheila (2006)
    Law and Contemporary Problems
  24. 10.1177/1075547012459274
     ↗
  25. Jay Martin (1994)
    Downcast Eyes: The Denigration of Vision in Twentieth-Century French Thought
  26. Jeff ID. “Douglass and Christy on Climategate.” Air Vent, 20 Dec. 2009, https://noconsensus.wordpress.com/200…
     ↗
  27. ———. “GHCN Antarctic, 8X Actual Trend – Uses Single Warmest Station.” Air Vent, 13 Dec. 2009, https://noconse…
  28. ———. “Hidden in Plain Sight—A Criticism of Media Coverage.” Air Vent, 25 Nov. 2009, https://noconsensus.wordp…
  29. ———. “The Hockey Stick Peer Review Gauntlet.” Air Vent, 24 Nov. 2009, https://noconsensus.wordpress.com/2009/…
  30. ———. “Would You Believe.” Air Vent, 6 Jan. 2010, https://noconsensus.wordpress.com/2010/01/06/285693/. Access…
  31. Knight Peter (2008)
    10.1215/0094033X-2007-024
    New German Critique  ↗
  32. @MichaelEMann (Michael E. Mann) (2020)
    Twitter
  33. 10.7312/columbia/9780231152556.001.0001
     ↗
  34. McIntyre, Steven. “The ‘Climategate’ Hockey Stick.” Climate Audit, 28 Nov. 2009, https://climateaudit.org/200…
  35. ———. “Climategatekeeping: Jones Reviews Mann.” Climate Audit, 23 Dec. 2009, https://climateaudit.org/2009/12/…
  36. ———. “Climategatekeeping: Schmidt 2009.” Climate Audit, 22 Dec. 2009. https://climateaudit.org/2009/12/22/Cli…
  37. ———. “Climategatekeeping: Wikipedia.” Climate Audit, 19 Dec. 2009, https://climateaudit.org/2009/12/19/climat…
  38. ———. “FOI Myth #1: USA.” Climate Audit, 28 Dec. 2009, https://climateaudit.org/2009/12/28/foi-myth-1-usa/. Ac…
  39. ———. “‘Sent Loads of Station Data to Scott.” Climate Audit, 1 Jan. 2010, https://climateaudit.org/2010/01/01/…
  40. ———. “Willis Eschenbach’s FOI Request.” Climate Audit, 25 Nov. 2009, https://climateaudit.org/2009/11/25/will…
  41. McIntyre Steven (2003)
    10.1260/095830503322793632
    Energy & Environment  ↗
  42. 10.5130/csr.v9i1.3587
     ↗
  43. Montford, Andrew W. “The Code.” Bishop Hill. 23 Nov. 2009, http://bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/11/23/…
  44. ———. “Met Office Code.” Bishop Hill, 22 Dec. 2009, http://bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/12/22/met-offi…
  45. ———. “More Evidence of Gatekeeping.” Bishop Hill, 17 Dec. 2009, http://bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/1…
  46. ———. “What Do You Make of This?” Bishop Hill, 22 Nov. 2009, http://bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/11/22…
  47. Mumford, Lewis. Technics and Civilization. Harcourt Brace Jovanovitch, 1934, pp. 138–41.
  48. 10.3197/096327110X531543
     ↗
  49. Neville-Shepard Ryan (2018)
    Southern Communication Journal
  50. 10.1353/par.2005.0009
     ↗
  51. Paliewicz Nicholas S. (2017)
    10.1080/00028533.2017.1375738
    Argumentation and Advocacy  ↗
  52. 10.1080/00335630902842053
     ↗
  53. Pearce, Fred. “Climate Change E-mails between Scientists Reveal Flaws in Peer Review.” Guardian, 2 Feb. 2010.…
  54. 10.1080/14791420.2013.806161
     ↗
  55. 10.5325/j.ctv8j4cn
     ↗
  56. Pittman, John F. “Common Sense and Prosecutor’s Fallacy(s).” Air Vent, 21 Dec. 2009. https://noconsensus.word…
  57. 10.1016/j.futures.2010.10.003
     ↗
  58. 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2014.03.003
     ↗
  59. 10.1177/0963662516632453
     ↗
  60. Sheppard, Kate. “Climategate: What Really Happened?” Mother Jones, 21 Apr. 2011, https://www.motherjones.com/…
  61. Smith, Wesley, J. “Climategate: Mark Steyn Asks, “‘who Peer Reviews the Peer Reviewers?’” First Things, 29 No…
  62. ———. “The New Inquisition: Ideology’s Corruption of Science,” First Things, 28 Nov 2009, https://www.firstthi…
  63. Steiner Rudolf (2000)
    Nature’s Open Secret: Introductions to Goethe’s Scientific Writings
  64. Steyn, Mark. “CRU’s Tree-Ring Circus,” National Review, 28 Nov. 2009. https://www.nationalreview.com/2009/11/…
  65. Stormer Nathan (1997)
    10.1080/00335639709384179
    Quarterly Journal of Speech  ↗
  66. Taylor Charles Alan (1996)
    Defining Science: A Rhetoric of Demarcation
  67. Tietge (1998)
    The Role of Burke's Four Master Tropes in Scientific Expression
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  68. Walsh, Lynda. “‘Tricks,’ Hockey Sticks, and the Myth of Natural Inscription: How the Visual Rhetoric of Clima…
     ↗
  69. ——— (2015)
    10.1002/wcc.342
    WIREs Climate Change  ↗
  70. Watts, Anthony. “Climategate: Hide the Decline—Codified.” Watts Up With That? 25 Nov. 2009, https://wattsupwi…
  71. ———. “McIntyre: The Deleted Data from the ‘Hide the Decline’ Trick.” Watts Up With That? 26 Nov. 2009c, https…
  72. ———. “Pielke Senior: Revkin Perpetuates a Myth about the Surface Temperature Record.” Watts Up With That? 30 …
  73. ———. “Release of CRU Files Forges a New Hockey Stick Reconstruction.” Watts Up With That? 20 Nov. 2009, https…
CrossRef global citation count: 2 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Rhetoric Review Jul 2015
    The Public Address and the Rhetoric of Science: Henry Rowland, Epideictic Speech, and Nineteenth-Century American Science ↗
    Gabriel Cutrufello
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism genre theory argument scientific writing digital rhetoric public rhetoric editorial matter
  2. College Composition and Communication Jun 2004
    Review: The Rhetoric and Ideology of Genre: Strategies for Stability and Change ↗
    Mary M. Juzwik
    rhetorical criticism genre theory scientific writing digital rhetoric literacy studies book reviews
  3. IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication Mar 1999
    Using genre theory to teach students engineering lab report writing: a collaborative approach ↗
    K. Walker
    rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis writing pedagogy writing across the curriculum collaborative writing writing centers professional writing scientific writing digital rhetoric
  4. Computers and Composition Jun 2026
    Legacies, commitments, and new challenges: The Sweetland Digital Rhetoric Collaborative interviews three generations of Computers and Composition editors ↗
    Ali Alalem; Alyse Campbell; Thais Rodrigues Cons; Funmilola Fadairo; Nicole Koyuki Golden
    rhetorical criticism collaborative writing digital rhetoric
  5. Res Rhetorica Jan 2026
    Review/Recenzja: Nancy Organ. 2024. Data Visualization for People of All Ages. Oxon: CRC Press; and Jen Christiansen. 2023. Building Science Graphics: An Illustrated Guide to Communicating Science Through Diagrams and Visualizations. Oxon: CRC Press ↗
    Ewa Modrzejewska
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis digital rhetoric multimodality grammar and mechanics race and writing book reviews