Rhetoric Society Quarterly Jan 1993

Apologies and accommodations: Imitation and the writing process

Frank M. Fanner East Carolina University ; Phillip K. Arrington

Abstract

Imitation has long been a method and theoretical basis for rhetorical instruction. It has also enjoyed a complex, if not always glorious, history-a lineage which extends from the apprenticeship of sophists in Plato's Greece to the moral education of orators in Quintilian's Rome; from the nurturing of abundant expression in a Renaissance text by Erasmus to the cultivation of taste in an Enlightenment text by Hugh Blair. In the last few decades, however, we have witnessed dramatic changes in how we look upon imitation-changes largely influenced, we think, by the process movement, with its various emphases on invention and revision, expression and discovery, cognition and collaboration. In the wake of shifting so much of our attention to writing processes, we might well expect imitation to have been pronounced as dead as Nietzche's God was a century ago. But if the literature reviewed here is any indication, rumors of imitation's death have been greatly exaggerated. Most of the studies in our survey are favorablyand surprisingly-disposed to imitation's continued practice. Such studies typically call for a revised understanding of imitation, a novel approach which reveals the proponent's understanding of the need to somehow demonstrate imitation's acceptability to a community which presumably resists its use. Why? Most likely because imitation turns on assumptions about writing and learning which many find discomforting, if not altogether objectionable. There are, of course, fairly complex historical, cultural, and theoretical reasons for our current aversion to imitation, many of which we explore later in our review. But the important point for us is that those who argue for imitation-however much they may differ in their various arguments-share an awareness that its use must be justified in answer to, and anticipation of, its critical refusal by the community at large. What we infer from this awareness is the community's largely tacit rejection of imitation. That's not to say, of course, that explicit criticism of imitation is wholly absent from the literature.' But in a context where many readily assent to the idea that almost any form of direct imitation leads to a distortion of the writing process, there is little urgency to speak against its use in the writing classroom (Judy and Judy 127). Indeed, only those who desire a reevaluation of imitation need

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
1993-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773949309390976
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy revision collaborative writing
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (5)

  1. Dow (2023)
    Business and technical writing pedagogy
    Writing and Pedagogy
  2. Terrill (2019)
    Rhetorical Imitation and Civic Diversity
    Advances in the History of Rhetoric
  3. Edwards (2016)
    Framing Remix Rhetorically: Toward A Typology of Transformative Work
    Computers and Composition
  4. Kalbfleisch (2016)
    ImitatioReconsidered
    Pedagogy
  5. Terrill (2011)
    Mimesis, Duality, and Rhetorical Education
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly

References (102) · 15 in this index

  1. Auerbach Erich (1953)
    Mimesis: The Representation of Reality in Western Literature
  2. Bakhtin M. M (1981)
    The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays
    U of Texas P Slavic Series 1
  3. _____ (1984)
    Theory and History of Literature
  4. _____ (1986)
    Speech Genres and Other Late Essays
    U of Texas P Slavic Series 8
  5. Bartholomae David (1985)
    Writers on Writing
Show all 102 →
  1. _____ (1985)
    When A Writer Can't Write
  2. Berkenkotter Carol (1989)
    Journal of Advanced Composition
  3. 10.2307/377477
     ↗
  4. Boyd Richard (1991)
    Journal of Advanced Composition
  5. Braddock Richard (1963)
    Research in Written Composition
  6. Brooke (1988)
    Modeling a Writer's Identity: Reading and Imitation in the Writing Classroom
    College Composition and Communication
  7. _____ (1991)
    Writing and Sense of Self
  8. 10.2307/375442
     ↗
  9. Brower Reuben (1974)
    Mirror on Mirror: Translation, Imitation, Parody
     ↗
  10. Burke Kenneth (1957)
    The Philosophy of Literary Form: Studies in Symbolic Action
  11. 10.2307/355051
     ↗
  12. 10.1080/00335635109381613
     ↗
  13. 10.2307/377786
     ↗
  14. 10.2307/356450
     ↗
  15. Crowley Sharon (1985)
    Journal of Advanced Composition
  16. D'Angelo (1973)
    Imitation and Style
    College Composition and Communication
  17. _____ (1983)
    Forum: Essays on Theory and Practice in the Teaching of Writing
  18. _____ (1979)
    Linguistics, Stylistics, and the Teaching of Writing
  19. Dickinson Barbara Ann (1988)
    DAI
  20. Eschholz Paul A. (1980)
    Eight Approaches to Teaching Composition
  21. 10.2307/376707
     ↗
  22. 10.2307/376287
     ↗
  23. 10.1080/00405848009542901
     ↗
  24. 10.2307/375768
     ↗
  25. _____ (1983)
    Research on Writing: Principles and Methods
  26. Fogarty Daniel (1959)
    Roots for a New Rhetoric
  27. Gibson Walker (1966)
    Tough, Sweet and Stuffy
  28. Gorrell Donna (1987)
    10.37514/JBW-J.1987.6.2.06
    Journal of Basic Writing  ↗
  29. Graham Steve (1982)
    Focus on Exceptional Children
  30. 10.2307/357176
     ↗
  31. Gray James (1983)
    Theory and Practice in the Teaching of Composition : Processing, Distancing, Modeling
  32. Gruber (1977)
    "Servile Copying" and the Teaching of English Composition
    College English
  33. Guth Hans P. (1985)
    Writers on Writing
  34. 10.2307/357846
     ↗
  35. 10.2307/376218
     ↗
  36. 10.2307/376921
     ↗
  37. Hillocks George (1986)
    Research on Written Composition: New Directions for Teaching
  38. 10.1086/443789
     ↗
  39. Holquist Michael (1986)
    Bakhtin: Essays and Dialogues on His Work
  40. Hunt Maurice (1988)
    Freshman English News
  41. Judy Stephen (1981)
    An Introduction to the Teaching of Writing
  42. Kehl D. G (1986)
    The Territory of Language: Linguistics, Stylistics, and the Teaching of Composition
  43. 10.2307/357441
     ↗
  44. Klancher Jon (1989)
    Reclaiming Pedagogy: The Rhetoric of the Classroom
  45. Langer Judith
    ERIC
  46. Lanham Richard (1974)
    Style: An Anti‐Textbook
  47. Larmouth Donald (1970)
    Minnesota English Journal
  48. Larsen (1978)
    Back to the Board
    College Composition and Communication
  49. Lindemann Erika (1987)
    A Rhetoric for Writing Teachers
  50. Lodge David (1990)
    After Bakhtin: Essays on Fiction and Criticism
  51. Loux (1987)
    Using Imitations in Literature Classes
    College Composition and Communication
  52. Maimon Elaine P. (1983)
    Composition and Literature: Bridging the Gap
  53. 10.2307/356587
     ↗
  54. McCabe Bernard J. (1965)
    Classroom Practices in Teaching English, 1965–66
  55. McDonald James C. (1988)
    DAI
  56. 10.1086/388216
     ↗
  57. 10.2307/354877
     ↗
  58. Tate, Gary and Corbett, Edward P. J., eds. 1967.Teaching Freshman Composition, 255–60. New York: Oxford UP.
  59. Moffett James (1983)
    Teaching the Universe of Discourse
  60. Murray Donald (1968)
    A Writer Teaches Writing
  61. Myers Miles (1983)
    Theory and Practice in the Teaching of Composition: Processing, Distancing, Modeling
  62. Ong Walter (1982)
    The Horizon of Literature
  63. 10.2307/358894
     ↗
  64. Perelman Chaim (1990)
    The Rhetorical Tradition: Readings from Classical Times to the Present
  65. Phelps Louise Wetherbee (1986)
    Solving Problems in Literacy: Learners, Teachers, and Researchers
    Yearbook of the National Reading Conference
  66. Porter (1986)
    Intertextuality and the discourse community
    Rhetoric Review
  67. Purves et al. (1986)
    Viewpoints: Cultures, Text Models, and the Activity of Writing
    Research in the Teaching of English
  68. Rankin Elizabeth (1985)
    Freshman English News
  69. 10.2307/816736
     ↗
  70. Roemer (1984)
    Inventive Modeling: Rainy Mountain's Way to Composition
    College English
  71. Rohman (1965)
    Pre-Writing the Stage of Discovery in the Writing Process
    College Composition and Communication
  72. Ruszkiewicz (1979)
    Back to the Source: Personal Research in Writing
    College Composition and Communication
  73. 10.2307/375973
     ↗
  74. Ryan Sheila M. N. (1986)
    10.58680/la198625650
    Language Arts  ↗
  75. 10.2307/377158
     ↗
  76. 10.2307/357456
     ↗
  77. Shaughnessy Mina (1977)
    Errors and Expectations: A Guide for the Teacher of Basic Writing
  78. Shimabukuro James N. (1987)
    DAI
  79. Simmons Kathryn A. (1986)
    DAI
  80. Sommers Jeffrey (1984)
    Kentucky English Bulletin
  81. Spencer Jacqueline (1982)
    English Quarterly
  82. Starkey (1974)
    Imitatio Redux
    College Composition and Communication
  83. Stolarek Elizabeth Ann (1992)
    DAI
  84. Sullivan (1989)
    Attitudes toward imitation: Classical culture and the modern temper
    Rhetoric Review
  85. Todorov, Tzvetan. 1982.Theories of the Symbol, Edited by: Porter, Catherine. 111–46. Ithaca, NY: Cornell UP.
  86. TOMLINSON (1984)
    Talking about the Composing Process: The Limitations of Retrospective Accounts
    Written Communication
  87. Tourney Leonard
    ERIC
  88. Vygotsky L. S (1986)
    Thought and Language
  89. Walborn Eric D.
    ERIC
  90. 10.2307/356552
     ↗
  91. Werner (1989)
    Models and the Teaching of Technical Writing
    Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
  92. Wess (1981)
    Imitation theory and teacher writing: An annotated bibliography
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  93. Winkler Victoria (1983)
    New Essays in Technical and Scientific Communication: Research, Theory, Practice
  94. Winsor Dorothy A. (1990)
    Technical Communication
  95. 10.1080/00335637009382997
     ↗
  96. Young Richard (1980)
    Reinventing the Rhetorical Tradition
  97. _____ (1978)
    Research on Composing: Points of Departure
CrossRef global citation count: 7 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Rhetorica Jan 2021
    Kenneth Burke’s Permanence and Change: A Critical Companion by Ann George ↗
    Kyle Jensen
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism writing pedagogy revision collaborative writing archival research grammar and mechanics book reviews
  2. Philosophy & Rhetoric Oct 2025
    The Intellectual and Cultural Origins of Chaïm Perelman and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca’s New Rhetoric Project: Commentaries on and Translations of Seven Foundational Articles, 1933–1958 ↗
    Christopher W. Tindale
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis revision argument collaborative writing editorial matter
  3. Pedagogy Oct 2024
    Contributors ↗
    rhetorical criticism first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing writing across the curriculum graduate education two-year college service learning teacher development revision argument collaborative writing assessment writing program administration multimodality multilingual writers literacy studies race and writing disability studies community literacy editorial matter
  4. Philosophy & Rhetoric Dec 2021
    The Weimar Origins of Rhetorical Inquiry ↗
    Daniel M. Gross
    classical rhetoric rhetorical criticism feminist rhetorics writing pedagogy graduate education revision argument public rhetoric book reviews editorial matter
  5. Pedagogy Oct 2021
    When the Writing Classroom Is a Lab for Democracy ↗
    Moira A. Connelly
    rhetorical criticism first-year composition writing pedagogy graduate education teacher development revision argument collaborative writing writing centers peer tutoring digital rhetoric multimodality multilingual writers race and writing gender and writing editorial matter