Rhetoric Society Quarterly Jan 1991

Rhetoric in praise of silence: The ideology of Carlyle's paradox

Christine Persak

Abstract

The alleged death of rhetoric in nineteenth century, so often cited by historians of discipline, has always seemed paradoxical to Victorian scholars familiar with social conflicts of that century and volumes of deliberative discourse to which they gave rise. These comments on demise of rhetoric generally construe it as an academic discipline or as use of stylistic devices-definitions which have so limited research that Donald C. Stewart remarked in 1983 that the most notable feature of scholarship in nineteenth-century rhetoric is its relative absence (153).1 However, recent studies by James Berlin and Susan Jarratt have broadened investigation of rhetoric's history to include discussions of relationship between language, knowledge, and society.2 Jarratt's proposed revisionary history would investigate implicit theories of rhetoric in any texts which explore relation of knowledge to language as well as roles of community and authority in establishing truth and prescribing ethical behavior (Toward 11-14; Naming). In this essay, I wish to trace a theory of rhetoric and its ideological implications in work of Victorian prophet Thomas Carlyle.3 When estrangement between upper and lower classes caused by rise of capitalism became central subject of deliberative discourse, Carlyle gained a large readership through his incisive social criticism.4 His writing influenced an entire generation which included John Stuart Mill, Charles

Journal
Rhetoric Society Quarterly
Published
1991-01-01
DOI
10.1080/02773949109390907
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
rhetorical criticism discourse analysis editorial matter
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (37) · 2 in this index

  1. Traill, H. D., ed. 1896–99.The Works of Thomas Carlyle, Centenary edition, 30 vols, 79London: Chapman and Hall. 26
  2. 10.2307/3199716
     ↗
  3. Ball Terence (1988)
    Transforming Political Discourse: Political Theory and Critical Conceptual History
  4. Bentley Eric (1969)
    The Cult of the Superman: A Study of Heroism in Carlyle and Neitzsche, with Notes on Othe…
  5. Berlin James A. (1984)
    Writing Instruction in Nineteenth‐Century American Colleges
Show all 37 →
  1. Berlin (1983)
    Mathew Arnold's rhetoric: The method of an elegant Jeremiah
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  2. Berlin (1980)
    The rhetoric of romanticism: The case for Coleridge
    Rhetoric Society Quarterly
  3. Burke Kenneth (1984)
    Attitudes Toward History
     ↗
  4. _____ (1943)
    View
  5. _____ (1966)
    Language as Symbolic Action: Essays on Life, Literature, and Method
  6. _____ (1973)
    The Philosophy of Literary Form: Studies in Symbolic Action
  7. _____ (1969)
    A Rhetoric of Motives
  8. _____ (1896)
    The Works of Thomas Carlyle
  9. 10.2307/356590
     ↗
  10. Daiches David (1981)
    Thomas Carlyle 1981: Papers Given at the International Thomas Carlyle Centenary Symposium
  11. Golden James L. (1973)
    The Rhetoric of Western Thought
  12. Grierson Herbert J. (1940)
    Thomas Carlyle
  13. Harrold Charles Frederick (1934)
    Carlyle and German Thought, 1819–1834
    Yale University Studies in English 82
  14. Himmelfarb Gertrude (1985)
    The Idea of Poverty: England in the Early Industrial
  15. _____ (1983)
    History and Class: Essential Readings in Theory and Interpretation
  16. Holloway John (1965)
    The Victorian Sage: Studies in Argument
  17. Horner Winifred Bryan (1990)
    A Short History of Writing Instruction From Ancient Greece to Twentieth‐Century America
  18. IJsseling Samuel (1976)
    Rhetoric and Philosophy in Conflict: An Historical
  19. Ikeler A. Abbott (1972)
    Puritan Temper and Transcendental Faith: Carlyle's Literary Vision
  20. Jarratt Susan (1987)
    PrelText
  21. _____. 1985. “A Victorian Sophistic: The Rhetoric of Knowledge in Darwin, Newman, and Pater”. U of Texas at A…
  22. _____. 1988. “Walter Pater and the Naming of Rhetoric”. Conference on College Composition and Communication. …
  23. 10.2307/378186
     ↗
  24. Kennedy George A. (1980)
    Classical Rhetoric and Its Christian and Secular Tradition from Ancient to Modern Times
  25. Landow George (1989)
    Victorian Perspectives: Six Essays
     ↗
  26. LeQuesne A. L (1982)
    Carlyle
  27. Marcus Steven (1974)
    Engels, Manchester, and the Working Class
  28. Miller J Hillis (1989)
    Victorian Perspectives: Six Essays
  29. Morley John (1970)
    Nineteenth‐Century Essays
  30. Plato (1960)
    Gorgias
  31. Rosenberg Philip (1974)
    The Seventh Hero: Thomas Carlyle and the Theory of Radical Activism
     ↗
  32. Stewart Donald E. (1983)
    The Present State of Scholarship in Historical and Contemporary Rhetoric
CrossRef global citation count: 2 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Philosophy & Rhetoric Oct 2025
    The Intellectual and Cultural Origins of Chaïm Perelman and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca’s New Rhetoric Project: Commentaries on and Translations of Seven Foundational Articles, 1933–1958 ↗
    Christopher W. Tindale
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis revision argument collaborative writing editorial matter
  2. Philosophy & Rhetoric Apr 2025
    Introduction: On the Desirability of Speaking to Others ↗
    Nirvana Tanoukhi; Nicholas Dunn
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument social media race and writing gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric literary studies editorial matter
  3. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Dec 2024
    American Kairos: Washington National Cathedral and the New Civil Religion ↗
    Randall Fowler
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument archival research race and writing gender and writing public rhetoric body and rhetoric place and space editorial matter
  4. Technical Communication Quarterly Oct 2024
    “I Feel Like I’m in a Box”: Contrasting Virtual Reality “Imaginaries” in the Context of Academic Innovation Labs ↗
    Brent Lucia; Matthew A. Vetter; David A. Solberg
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis creative writing graduate education teacher development professional writing digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics editorial matter
  5. Technical Communication Quarterly Oct 2024
    Social Justice and “Harmful Tech”: Dis-Orienting Militarized Research ↗
    Calvin Pollak; Sanvi Bhardwaj
    rhetorical criticism discourse analysis writing pedagogy teacher development technical communication scientific writing race and writing disability studies editorial matter