Rhetoric Review Oct 2006

A Bibliographic Synthesis of Rhetorical Criticism

Jennifer deWinter

Abstract

While conducting research for this article, I often came across this claim: Rhetorical criticism has traditionally been housed in speech communication de partments.1 One look at the bibliography for this article seems only to validate this claim; almost all of the journals and books are written by and for speech communication scholars. And really, this comes as little surprise when we con sider that the majority of the New Rhetoricians are communication theorists or that speech communication scholarship has been interested in analyzing specific communication situations. In all, the work of these scholars attempts to define the strategies employed, determine whether those strategies were effective to a specific rhetorical situation, and from that, articulate theories based on this care ful observation about different approaches to rhetorical criticism. However, I remain uncomfortable with making the claim that rhetorical crit icism grew up in speech communication, which to me implies that the field of rhetoric and composition does not have a history with rhetorical criticism. Yet many of the publications in our field give lie to that implied claim?Shirley Wilson Logan's We Are Coming: The Persuasive Discourse of Nineteenth Century Black Women, for example, conducts rhetorical criticism of the public discourses and speeches of nineteenth-century black women, while Ken McAllister's Game Work: Language, Power, and Computer Game Culture con ducts an in-depth rhetorical analysis of computer games in an effort to articulate a rhetorical theory that can account for games as a rhetorical text. The reason that rhetorical criticism has historically belonged to speech communication may simply be the fact that speech communication scholars have attempted to define and theorize it as a legitimate disciplinary concern. The purpose of this bibliographic synthesis is to provide rhetoric and composition scholars with a broad understanding of the field so that we can begin to theorize the work we do with rhetorical criticism and think through the ways in which we can enrich our own scholarship. Due to page-length limitations, I am unable to provide a synthesis of all the different approaches to rhetorical criticism. I have chosen to limit my scope to definitions, general methodology, and objects of rhetorical criticism, which com prise the first three sections. The final section will summarize four textbooks on rhetorical criticism, all four of which provide excellent starting places for those

Journal
Rhetoric Review
Published
2006-10-01
DOI
10.1207/s15327981rr2504_2
CompPile
Search in CompPile ↗
Open Access
Closed
Topics
modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis digital rhetoric public rhetoric
Export
BibTeX RIS

Citation Context

Cited by in this index (0)

No articles in this index cite this work.

References (59)

  1. Alcoff Linda (1993)
    10.1086/494793
    Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 18  ↗
  2. Andrews, James R. The Practice of Rhetorical Criticism. New York: Macmillan, 1983.
  3. 10.2307/378935
     ↗
  4. Baxter Leslie A (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374348
    Western Journal of Speech Communication  ↗
  5. Benson, Thomas W., ed. Landmark Essays on Rhetorical Criticism. Davis, CA: Hermagoras P, 1993.
Show all 59 →
  1. - ed. Speech Communication in the 20th Century. Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP, 1985.
  2. Bitzer Lloyd F (1968)
    Philosophy and Rhetoric 1
  3. Bitzer, Lloyd F., and Edwin Black, eds. The Prospect of Rhetoric: Report of the National Development Project.…
  4. Black Edwin (1980)
    10.1080/10570318009374018
    The Western Journal of Speech Communication 44  ↗
  5. - "The Prospect of Rhetoric: Twenty-Five Years Later." Making and Unmaking the Prospects for Rhetoric: Select…
  6. - Rhetorical Criticism: A Study in Method. 2nd ed. Madison: U of Wisconsin P, 1978.
  7. - Rhetorical Questions: Studies of Public Discourse. U of Chicago P, 1992.
  8. Blair, Carole. "We Are All Just Prisoners Here of Our Own Device." Making and Unmaking the Prospects for Rhet…
  9. Brigance, William Norwood, ed. A History and Criticism of American Public Address, Vol. 1. New York: McGraw-H…
  10. - ed. A History and Criticism of American Public Address, Vol. 2. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1943.
  11. Brockriede Wayne (1974)
    10.1080/00335637409383222
    Quarterly Journal of Speech 60  ↗
  12. Brummett, Barry. Rhetorical Dimensions of Popular Culture. Tuscaloosa: U of Alabama P, 1991.
  13. Bruner M. Lane (2002)
    10.1080/10570310209374738
    Western Journal of Communication 66  ↗
  14. Burgchardt, Carl R., ed. Readings in Rhetorical Criticism. State College, PA: Strata P, 2005.
  15. Campbell John Angus (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374347
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54  ↗
  16. (1990)
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54
  17. Ceccarelli Leah (1998)
    10.1080/00335639809384229
    The Quarterly Journal of Speech 84  ↗
  18. Cohen, Herman. "The Development of Research in Speech Communication: A Historical Perspective." In Speech Com…
  19. Condit Celeste (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374346
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54  ↗
  20. Cox J. Robert. (1990)
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54
  21. Darsey James (1994)
    10.1080/10570319409374494
    Western Journal of Communication 58  ↗
  22. Foss, Sonja K. Rhetorical Criticism: Exploration & Practice, 3rd ed. Long Grove, IL: Waveland, 2004.
  23. Foucault, Michel. The Archaeology of Knowledge and the Discourse on Language. Trans. A. M. Sheridan Smith. Ne…
  24. Gaonkar Dilip Parameshwar (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374344
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54  ↗
  25. Gates, Henry Louis, Jr. "The Signifying Monkey and the Language of Signifyin(g): Rhetorical Difference and th…
  26. Hart Roderick P (1994)
    10.1080/10570319409374502
    Western Journal of Communication 58  ↗
  27. Hasian Marouf (2001)
    10.1080/10570310109374707
    Western Journal of Communication 65  ↗
  28. Herzberg, Bruce. "Michel Foucault's Rhetorical Theory." Contending with Words: Composition and Rhetoric in a …
  29. Hochmuth Marie
    A History and Criticism of American Public Address
  30. Hochmuth, Marie Kathryn, W. Norwood Brigance, and Donald Bryant, eds. A History and Criticism of American Pub…
  31. Horner, Winifred Bryan, ed. The Present State of Scholarship in Historical and Contemporary Rhetoric. Columbi…
  32. Howell, Wilbur Samuel. Poetics, Rhetoric, and Logic: Studies in the Basic Disciplines of Criticism. Ithaca, N…
  33. Jamieson Kathleen M (1975)
    10.1080/00335637509383303
    The Quarterly Journal of Speech 61  ↗
  34. (1990)
    Communication Monographs 57
  35. Jamieson Kathleen Hall (1982)
    10.1080/00335638209383600
    The Quarterly Journal of Speech 68  ↗
  36. Jasinski James (2001)
    10.1080/10570310109374705
    Western Journal of Communication 65  ↗
  37. Kuypers, Jim A., ed. The Art of Rhetorical Criticism. Boston: Pearson, 2005.
  38. Leff, Michael C., and Gerald P. Mohrmann. "Lincoln at Cooper Union: A Rhetorical Analysis of the Text." Landm…
     ↗
  39. Leff Michael C (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374342
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54  ↗
  40. Logan, Shirley Wilson. "We Are Coming": The Persuasive Discourse of Nineteenth-Century Black Women. Carbondal…
  41. Lyons, Scott. "Crying for Revision: Postmodern Indians and Rhetorics of Tradition." Making and Unmaking the P…
  42. McAllister, Ken S. Game Work: Language, Power, and Computer Game Culture. Tuscaloosa: U of Alabama P, 2005.
  43. McGee Michael Calvin (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374343
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54  ↗
  44. McKeon, Zahava Karl. Novels and Arguments: Inventing Rhetorical Criticism. U of Chicago P, 1982.
  45. Miller Carolyn R (1984)
    10.1080/00335638409383686
    Quarterly Journal of Speech 70  ↗
  46. Mountford, Roxanne. "Making and Unmaking the Prospects for Rhetoric." Making and Unmaking the Prospects for R…
  47. Nichols, Marie Hochmuth. Rhetoric and Criticism. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State UP, 1963.
  48. Pearce, W. Barnett. "Scientific Research Methods in Communication Studies and Their Implications for Theory a…
  49. Rybacki, Karyn Charles, and Donald Jay Rybacki. Communication Criticism: Approaches & Genres, 2nd ed. Boston:…
  50. Smith Craig R (1996)
    10.1080/01463379609370010
    Communication Quarterly 44  ↗
  51. Stewart, Charles J. "Historical Survey: Rhetorical Criticism in Twentieth Century America." Explorations in R…
  52. Taylor Bryan C (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374349
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54  ↗
  53. Thonssen, Lester, A. Craig Baird, and Waldo W. Braden. Speech Criticism. New York: Ronald Press, 1970.
  54. Troester Rod (1990)
    10.1080/10570319009374350
    Western Journal of Speech Communication 54  ↗
CrossRef global citation count: 0 View in citation network → Build reading path →

Related Articles

  1. Philosophy & Rhetoric Sep 2024
    Where’s the Rhetoric? Imagining a Unified Field ↗
    Joshua Hanan
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism composition theory genre theory discourse analysis cultural rhetorics argument qualitative research quantitative research digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric affect and writing body and rhetoric editorial matter
  2. Rhetoric & Public Affairs Sep 2024
    Populist Rhetorics Case Studies and a Minimalist Definition ↗
    Arthur E. Walzer
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis argument digital rhetoric social media disability studies public rhetoric editorial matter
  3. Pedagogy Jan 2022
    Contributors ↗
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism genre theory discourse analysis african american rhetorics decolonial rhetorics first-year composition writing pedagogy basic writing writing across the curriculum graduate education teacher development argument collaborative writing transfer assessment portfolios writing program administration writing centers peer tutoring technical communication professional writing archival research digital rhetoric social media grammar and mechanics literacy studies race and writing gender and writing disability studies public rhetoric community literacy literary studies editorial matter
  4. Advances in the History of Rhetoric Sep 2017
    Making Visual Rhetoric More Difficult ↗
    Nathan Atkinson
    modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis archival research digital rhetoric multimodality public rhetoric
  5. Philosophy & Rhetoric May 2015
    Rhetorical Citizenship and Public Deliberation ↗
    Matthew Houdek
    classical rhetoric modern rhetorical theory rhetorical criticism discourse analysis cultural rhetorics service learning argument portfolios qualitative research digital rhetoric race and writing gender and writing public rhetoric